Capital gains on transfer/surrender of tenancy

This query is : Resolved

v k sharma (Querist)
Follow

06 May 2015 Very old tenancy surrendered to landlord on condition that it is allotted to the person of my choice. The newly inducted tenant pays the old tenant a certain amount as compensation. Will this be treated as capital gains or as income from other sources?

v k sharma

v k sharma (Querist)
Follow

04 June 2015 No reply recd yet

v k sharma

v k sharma (Querist)
Follow

14 June 2015 Please anyone reply.

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Asha Kanta Sharma

Asha Kanta Sharma

(Expert)
Follow

18 July 2024 The surrender of a tenancy in exchange for compensation generally falls under the purview of the Income Tax Act, and the tax treatment depends on several factors:

1. **Nature of Compensation:** The amount received by the old tenant from the newly inducted tenant is crucial in determining its tax treatment.

2. **Capital Gains vs Income from Other Sources:**
- **Capital Gains:** If the amount received can be categorized as consideration for the surrender of a capital asset (in this case, the tenancy rights), it would likely be treated as capital gains. Capital gains are further classified as short-term or long-term based on the holding period of the asset.
- **Short-term Capital Gains (STCG):** If the tenancy was held for less than 24 months before surrender, any gain would be considered STCG and taxed at applicable slab rates.
- **Long-term Capital Gains (LTCG):** If the tenancy was held for 24 months or more, the gain would be considered LTCG and taxed at a flat rate of 20% with indexation benefit.

- **Income from Other Sources:** If the compensation received is not considered as capital gains (for example, if it does not meet the definition of a capital asset or does not meet the holding period requirement), it would typically be treated as income from other sources. Income from other sources is added to the individual's total income and taxed at applicable slab rates.

3. **Intent and Documentation:** The tax treatment may also hinge on the documentation and intent behind the transaction. If the surrender and compensation arrangement is structured as a sale or transfer of rights akin to a capital asset, it could lean towards capital gains treatment.

4. **Professional Advice:** Given the specific details and nuances of such transactions, it's advisable to seek guidance from a tax professional or chartered accountant who can review the specifics of the case. They can provide a precise determination of the tax implications based on the Income Tax Act and relevant judicial precedents.

In conclusion, whether the compensation received for the surrender of a tenancy is treated as capital gains or income from other sources depends on the nature of the transaction, the period of holding, and the specific circumstances surrounding the surrender. Professional advice will ensure compliance with tax laws and optimize tax implications.