A B Kundu

The assessee is having all the 5 heads of Income. Main source is Salary and House Rent. During the year 2018-19, he incurred loss in Futures & Options trading around Rs.37 Lakh.

Now, we know that in case of F&O transactions, it shall be assessed under the head PGBP and hence, we need to report this loss in the P&L A/c. But, as he doesn't maintain accounts regularly, at the time of filing ITR-3, he just filled up the Part-B of Balance Sheet and P&L (i.e., No Account Case).

Department has sent intimation U/s 139(9) by saying that as the loss is claimed under PGBP, Part-A of Balance Sheet and P&L has to be filled up.

Now, the question is - if we try to prepare the P&L A/c, What shall be the Turnover?

We know that, to determine whether the assessee is falling U/s 44AB, in case of F&O trading, the turnover is to be calculated by adding all the profits and losses in absolute figure. But, this should not be the turnover which shall come into P&L, right?

If we report the actual sale value and purchase value, definitely it will cross few crores easily. In that case, again department will say that Tax Audit needs to be done u/s 44AB!

What is the solution? Hope I am clear to present the matter.

Thanks.


R S Sai Kumar

One Assessee is having rental income of Rs.12,00,000 per year and he is also getting remuneration of Rs.12,00,000 from partnership firm, there by the total income is Rs.24,00,000 - is he liable for payment of GST?
please clarify


Ashutosh Kumar Jha
07 December 2019 at 17:57

TDS

Dear Members,

Please help on the following issue
If an NRI is purchasing an immovable property from an Indian Co. for Rs. 1.50 Crore then:

I) Is e liable to deduct TDS u/s 194IA?
II) If he (NRI) purchase such property in joint name with his spouse (a resident Indian), then who is liable to deduct TDS u/s 194IA?

Plese guide.

Regards
Ashutosh


SURABHI GUPTA
07 December 2019 at 16:33

ADT 1

A CA Proprietorship firm while filling ADT 1 ..as to file as Individual or Auditors Firm in form ?


Umesh Kumar
07 December 2019 at 15:31

Revision of TDS return

Dear Sir/Madam,

Please help me about
Can we revise TDS return of FY 2015-16 & FY 2016-17 in FY 2019-20 and if your answer is yes, Is there any Interest/penalty regarding the same?

Thanks in Advance.

Umesh K. RAthod


thotasrinivas
07 December 2019 at 15:15

Consolidated Wages

We required to pay Consolidated Wages around 18 Lakhs per month in terms of CASH. For that we required to withdrawn cash from bank every month. Now, as per new section 194N, Cash withdrawal >1Crore TDS is deducting by bank.. what is the solution for way to pay wages.

Please suggest us by way of legality of income tax


VIJAYRAJ L JOGANI
07 December 2019 at 14:31

GSTREGESTRATIONAPPLICABLE

IF A PERSON SALE A PERSONAL BELONGING AND THE SALE VALUE IS MORE THAN EXEMPTION LIMIT OF

GST (RS 40 LAKHS ) TO A BUSINESSMAN WHETHER HE IS LIABLE TO COLLECT AND PAY GST AND

REGESTRATION UNDER GST LAW??


Pankaj

Respected Sir,

Our Product Exempted (Nil Rated) , I have Paid RCM On Freight @5 % (2.5+2.5), But I want to know HAMALI (Loading & Unloading Charge in RCM) applicable ?
(2) Can i refund RCM ? If Yes, How Can ?

Pankaj


RITESH BAMNOTE
07 December 2019 at 13:33

Levy of GST

Charitable Trust Is Register u/s 12AA of Income-tax Act & Providing following services to students & others are liable for GST
1) Swimming 2) Aerobics 3) Health center(Gym) 4) Gymnasium 5) Hostel facility & mess 6) Summer Camp 7) Physiotherapy 8) Naturopathy 9) membership fees etc

also, provide any case law or entry number of exemption if applicable


Lovepreet Singh
07 December 2019 at 13:07

PAN CARD ISSUE

Hello, while obtaining my CIBIL score via PAN CARD , i came to know about several unknown address and Bank accounts which are not mine. I suspect PAN CARD missue.
What options i have now?
1. Can i apply for new PAN CARD and surrender old one?
2. What authority i report for this missuse?
FYI, that accounts belong to DMI finance , i am unable to contact them.






CCI Pro
Meet our CAclubindia PRO Members

Follow us



Answer Query