25 September 2013
A Company follows Accrual basis of accounting for recording income from both domestic and foreign clients for selling goods (furniture, etc).
However, in recent times there has been uncertainty regarding payment from parties in Afghanistan, Nigeria etc. The company had to make provision for bad debts/write off the bad debts frequently as per the audit observations on the ground of uncertainty of realisation.
However, constant follow up for realisation of the payment continued and in some cases, the company realised the payment after an abnormally long period.
Recognition of income due to receipt of these payments used to create confusion as to whether these should be treated as current year’s income or prior period income.
Hence, the company now accounts for this foreign income on cash basis and also has started writing off amount from such foreign parties if not receivable at all. Can the company do the same??
14 July 2024
The situation described involves uncertainty and challenges related to the realization of income from foreign clients, particularly in countries like Afghanistan and Nigeria. The company has been facing issues with delayed payments and potential bad debts, leading to confusion regarding the recognition of income. Here’s how the company can address these concerns:
### Transition to Cash Basis for Foreign Income:
Given the uncertainties and difficulties in realizing income from certain foreign clients, the company has decided to switch to cash basis accounting for recording income from these clients. Here’s what this transition involves:
1. **Cash Basis Accounting:** - Cash basis accounting means that income is recognized only when cash is actually received, rather than when it is earned (accrual basis). - Under cash basis accounting, revenue is recognized when cash is received, and expenses are recognized when cash is paid.
2. **Writing Off Bad Debts:** - The company has started writing off amounts from foreign parties when it becomes clear that the amounts are not receivable. - This is a prudent approach to reflect the true financial position, especially when the collectability of debts is in doubt.
### Can the Company Transition to Cash Basis Accounting?
Yes, the company can transition to cash basis accounting for recording income from these uncertain foreign clients. Here’s why this approach is reasonable:
- **Prudence Principle:** Switching to cash basis accounting reflects a prudent approach to financial reporting, especially when there are significant uncertainties regarding the realization of income.
- **Matching Principle:** While accrual basis matches income with the period it is earned (regardless of when cash is received), cash basis aligns income recognition with actual cash receipts. Given the delays and uncertainties, cash basis provides a clearer picture of actual cash inflows.
- **Conservatism:** Writing off bad debts and accounting for income on cash basis aligns with the principle of conservatism in accounting, where uncertainties and risks are appropriately recognized.
### Treatment of Realized Payments:
- **Current Year's Income:** Income should be recognized in the current year when cash is received under cash basis accounting. This is straightforward and avoids confusion about whether it should be recognized in the current or prior period.
- **Prior Period Income:** If payments are received for invoices that were previously written off or considered uncollectible in prior periods, this income should typically be recognized in the current period when cash is received. It should not be adjusted as prior period income unless there are specific reasons to do so under accounting standards (which generally do not require retroactive adjustments unless errors are identified).
### Conclusion:
The company’s decision to switch to cash basis accounting for recording income from uncertain foreign clients and to write off bad debts as necessary is appropriate under the circumstances described. This approach provides a more conservative and accurate representation of the company’s financial position and performance. It’s advisable for the company to document these accounting policies clearly and ensure they are consistently applied to maintain transparency and compliance with accounting standards. If there are specific regulatory requirements or reporting standards applicable to foreign income or bad debt write-offs, consulting with a professional accountant or auditor would be beneficial.
CAclubindia
