Suspicion of highest degree cannot take place of evidence


Court :
ITAT Mumbai

Brief :
Bogus Sales/ Purchases: Addition solely on the basis of information received from the sales-tax department is not sustainable. Suspicion of the highest degree cannot take the place of evidence.

Citation :
Hiralal Chunilal Jain vs. ITO

Hiralal Chunilal Jain vs. ITO (ITAT Mumbai)

Bogus Sales/ Purchases: Addition solely on the basis of information received from the sales-tax department is not sustainable. Suspicion of the highest degree cannot take the place of evidence.

A) Facts of the case:

1. Assessee, an individual is proprietor of M/s. Divya Alloys and is engaged in business of resellers of ferrous and non ferrous metals.

2. AO found that the assessee had purchased goods worth Rs. 7.21 lakhs from Shiv Sagar Steel (India). The name of Shiv Sagar was appearing in the list of bogus parties forwarded by the sales tax authorities and the name of the assessee was appearing as beneficiaries in the list.

3. The AO directed the assessee to produce the party from whom he had claimed to have purchased goods. However, the supplier was not produced by the assessee. Summons issued to Shiv Sagar could not be served on the given address.

4. The AO held the purchase transaction bogus and treated the entire purchase (Rs.7.21 lakhs) as unexplained expenditure u/s.69C of the Act.

5. First Appellate Authority (FAA) held that an addition of 20% of the purchase would be justified in order to fulfill the gap difference of GP for the alleged purchase as well to plug any leakage of revenue.

B) Issue put before ITAT/Court:

Partial addition confirmed by the FAA was not justifiable, the AO had not granted cross examination of the party, even a copy of the statement was not provided wherein the allegation against the assessee were made by the alleged suppliers, all the purchases and sales were recorded in the books of accounts, the assessee was a reseller, the NP was 1.7%, the GP was about 7%, the FAA had ignored those vital facts while upholding the partial addition.

C) Observations of Honorable ITAT/Court:

1. The AO had received information from the investigation wing of STD, Maharashtra  that the assessee was one of the beneficiaries of accommodation entries. Shiv Sagar the supplier of the goods was one of the entities who had admitted to have bogus bills. The assessee had asked for cross examination of the supplier but same was not given. The AO had not supplied the copy of the statements of Shiv Sagar to the assessee. In the books of accounts of the assessee all the purchases and sales were recorded, payments were made through banking channels, the AO had made addition of entire purchases u/s.69 of the Act, the FAA had reduced it to 20%.

2. The AO had not rejected the sales of the assessee and the assessee was maintaining the quantative details and stock register.

3. Once the sales are accepted as genuine or not doubted the AO cannot reject the entire purchase.

4. AO had made the addition on the basis of information received from the Sales tax department, but he did not make any independent inquiry.

5. He did not follow the principles of natural justice before making the addition.

6. Considering the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, ITAT has reversed the order of the FAA.

7. Effective ground of appeal is decided in favor of the assessee.

 



Judgement posted by

Chartered Accountant

Chartered Acountant

Comments




CCI Pro



Company
Featured 07 November 2026
Paid Assisstant

DPV & Associates

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured ARTICLESHIP 28 October 2026
CA- Inter and Articles

N N V Satish & Co.,

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
19 November 2026
Accounts & Taxation Executive

MCSR and Associates LLP

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
10 November 2026
FP&A Executive

Gujarat Guardian

Ankleshwar

CA Final

View Details
Company
12 November 2026
Tax Product Specialist

BharatX.ai

Gurgaon

B.Com

View Details
Company
31 October 2026
Accountants

sankaran and krishnan

New Delhi

B.Com

View Details
Company
Featured 27 October 2026
semi-qualified CA

Saini Pati Shah & Co LLP, Chartered Accountants

Mumbai

CA Final

View Details
Company
30 October 2026
Asst Manager Accounts

Goodwin Pumps India Pvt Ltd

Chengalpattu

CA Inter

View Details