Originally posted by : Amol
	I don't think there is any ego issue involved here. Surendra Sir has made some very genuine observations & his concern for students is evident. All his postings relating to Final Results are worth reading & it is necessary to ponder over them. Sometimes I don't agree with Sir's opinions on other topics, but I should say, as regards this particular issue, his opinions make a lot of sense.

why cant he directly write to i.c.a.i  about the negative results for the benifit of  97% students & what the use of posting in ca club ??? 

i hope 97% students dont want pitty words & they want proper action / guidance to fight ............

Institute having the thought that, Many CA's are unemployed only bcoz of high Pass Out in the year 2011.... So that they are controlling the passing %

But Its NOT a good one..........   It wil damage the name of the course CA....  

Why they are Playing with the life of the CA Students....???  

My Sincere Advice to all the CA Students to persue another course like CS / CWA along with CA to make ur career a guaranteed one.... 

His are not just pity words but reflect his true concern for students. It is not at all wrong to create awareness among students via this medium , in fact it is essential. Students community is the strength of ICAI.
 

Dear gvgr,

We can't do anything..........     Only Members in Council / Goverment will have to take action in this to save the life of CA Students.....     

Reaching CA Final Level Itself Takes 3.5 Years.... Again the Institute produces 3% results means...... Again Clearing CA Final will takes " ? " Years......           A Qualified Cost Accountant (CWA) gets 18 Marks in Costing Paper in CA Final ???  Whether it indicates that he doesn't have any knowledge in Costing...............     Already He is a Cost Accountant......      

Dont Know .....What's Institute required from the Students ???   

Dear all,

One thing i would like to mention

Ca course is not whole and sole of once career its just a suppliment to his base career.

One should be ready with alternative weapon in pocket

One should be passionate about the profession work not the certificate of profession

One should start earnign without the certificate it is really possible. Start ur own consutancy firm get clint give services like accounting taxation etc 

If not interest in setting up of firm opportunitie are there in industry with atc certificate even with package of 25k-30k. 

All the best

If not

I totally agree with you Sir, reason for controlling result is lack of demand of CA's in market!

There are too many CA's who have cleared for more than a year ago but not getting job

ICAI should also give imp on other side rather then controlling results they should create demand for CA's not only in India but also in foreign countries too!

Problem of India is surplus manpoer!! Unless clear attention is given to provide employment opportuinity result will get worsen!!

Daer all,

No body is ready to accept their prrsent status they always think of next.

Ex . I am claiming myself as accounting tehnician. I have the the certificate. We should be proud to be we are at the first. Later only we can think of next level.

No body cant stop us.

We are depending on icai think that they will form our career as ca . No never . They will give the input thats it we should form ourself. 

Dont depend be responsible to ourself. 

All the best