Students beware of such unqualified teachrs & classes

Sathish M (Management Accountant) (40581 Points)
Replied 02 June 2013

Yes, awareness amongst students is one of the measures, to stop these so -called Premier coaching academies from making false claims and playing with the lives of students in India. We already heard a tragic incident today from Vijayawada wherein a student has taken the extreme step of ending his life.

Mr. Rakesh, I hope the momentum from your end continues and gets equal support from the student and member fraternity of ICAI and other professional bodies to ensure that bogus / fake coaching academies is exposed for lying about their credentials.

CA RAKESH TALWAR (Senior Partner) (107 Points)
Replied 02 June 2013

Nice Satishji, I am happy that you have started the First step of Support for my drive, & hope you will also come on to help me by Posting the names & credentials of such classes & extend this forum & keep it alive, Sir to be very Honest I have very less faith that the students here will come out in our support as majority of students here are just a Blind followers of Fake / Bogus & Tall claims & are more Interested in Forums & post like Thanks / Good / Thoughts of the day & such useless & foolish unprofessional & Buttry posts, But whatever happens we & people like us should take the responsibility towards guiding the students community for the Correct Path

Sir Keep this Post alive & spread it to Majirity of Students.

1 Like

Sathish M (Management Accountant) (40581 Points)
Replied 02 June 2013

Mr.Rakesh, I really empathize with your observations but it really undermines the very essence of you novel initiative if you sound cynical.

The point is very simple, even if one student gets benefitted from the herd of 1000's then your purpose is served. You should rather expose the real culprits with true intent; it should not become a platform of allegations and counter allegations. The real cause it to bring in the awareness amongst the students/ parents of such dubious coaching academies.

CA RAKESH TALWAR (Senior Partner) (107 Points)
Replied 02 June 2013

I agree to you Mr Satish & whatever opinions & statement made by me here are duly backed & supported by the authentic evidences & my own personal enquiry conducted for them & whatever next details & names which I would put here would also have the necessary evidence & my own & personal survey conducted & credentials verified about such classes. See i have mentioned that Mr Reji is a CA but I have taken his claims for a Slap. & for other two Classes Samir Gokhale study circle & Global Management I have said that the owners at first claim their profile as Fake & misguiding. Sir I have no personal grudge with any one nor do I have any person interest or conflicts of Interest, & i Am & will do this for all classes on PAN india level. Yes I have seen the incidence of a Boy commiting sucide at Superwhizz Academy Andhra Pradesh. Very sad for this

(Guest)

How can a senior partner has got so much free time to gather such baseless information.??

CA RAKESH TALWAR (Senior Partner) (107 Points)
Replied 02 June 2013

Yes CA Pillai you are right in having a question to yourself. How does a senoir Partner have this much time to get into enquiries. But understand one thing CA Pillai. Time Management done in a proper way allows you to do all such things which you want to do. & the statement I dont have time is a statement made by the most free people. The busiest People have all the time planned in such a way that he has time to do all things which he is supposed to do.

The great Dhirubhai Ambani always said that " The Person who says he does not have Time is the person who has the most of the time, & The person who wants to do things know how to Plan his time & things he wants to do.

I hope I have made your doubt very clear in a Loud & Proper way.

Yogita (Partner) (434 Points)
Replied 02 June 2013

Thanks CA Rakesh Sir for Ringing a Bellof caution to we students, wrong classes & Teachers means a Career bet for students like us after wasting a Big money after them. Thanks Once Again

Sathish M (Management Accountant) (40581 Points)
Replied 02 June 2013

Originally posted by : CA Pillai

How can a senior partner has got so much free time to gather such baseless information.??

Sir, from where do you gather information shared by Mr. Rakesh is baseless. The moot question is, are you too not making, a fallacy of hasty generalization? Are you also not making an allegation in that case?

I already mentioned in my above post - “You should rather expose the real culprits with true intent; it should not become a platform of allegations and counter allegations”

Anoop K. Singh (practice) (120 Points)
Replied 03 June 2013

I agree with the opinions and facts expressed above. But Mr Rakesh was himself promoting one of such classes as seen in his earlier posts. So how can u be sure that it is only for helping stdents or for putting down some other classes for promoting some class?

1 Like

(Guest)

Thank You Mr. Anoop k.Singh for pointing out the real intention of the author behind giving such misleading information about other classes.

@ Mr Satish & Mr. Rakesh.

I think there is no constitutional rule that only qualified chartered accountant should run the coaching institute.

Experienced and capable person can also teach the CA students as long as it benefits the students in all the way.

and as far as your findings are concerned its absolutely has got no value. students are smart enough to choose which classes they want to join and to which not.

And i said you wasted your time or rather you have got a plan to start coaching instituein in near future so in order to get some publicity, you started spreading such information which may not be true.

And mr.sathish right said thre should be evidence otherwise findings/ blabbering has got zero value.

2 Like

Ankur Garg (Company Secretary and Compliance Officer) (114773 Points)
Replied 03 June 2013

Thanks for sharing such useful thread. This is going to be an eye opener for many.

Thanks to other members for sharing valuable opinions.

Ki$hor B (Training & Advisory) (3015 Points)
Replied 03 June 2013

Appreciate the efforts of Rakesh!

Anoop K. Singh (practice) (120 Points)
Replied 03 June 2013

There are only 6-7 proper classes in mumbai for CA IPCC & Final:

1. Professional Academy

2. Prime Academy

3. Bhide Classes

4. J K Shah (its useless now a days)

5. Tayal Institute

6. R S Classes

7. Sukh Sagor Institute

There may be some additions to this list which I may not know.

All other classes are just trying to pull in students through some or the other way, ethical or unethical, which is not good.

Sathish M (Management Accountant) (40581 Points)
Replied 03 June 2013

Anoop sir, if that is true kindly post the link over here, so that no one is taken for a ride. No one should hold high moral position if one's hand is dirt stained.