Yes Urvashi is Right........Right.........Right ......and ..........Right
In my openion Half of the Rules of ICAI are against their Students.
Mohan Verma
(Assistant Manager - Finance & Accounts)
(4328 Points)
Replied 02 May 2009
Yes Urvashi is Right........Right.........Right ......and ..........Right
In my openion Half of the Rules of ICAI are against their Students.
CA Hemlata Saini
(Chartered Accountant)
(163 Points)
Replied 02 May 2009
Yes Urvashi is absolutely right
And about the matter of conveyence most of c.a do not reimburse conyence and some reimburse only in case of student visit to client place only.
What about dat money student spend on travelling from home to office and office to home.
that cost is almost more than stipend allowaed.
Prodyut Banerjee
(Advocate)
(309 Points)
Replied 04 May 2009
Dear Urvashi
Dear All
First we have to accept the basic difference of CS/ CA/ ICWA with MBBS/ Engineering/ MBA/ Research Fellow (NET/ SLATE Qualified). In case of CA/ ICWAI/ CS the entry is very easy and passing the final is tough but in case of the others it is reverse. Hence being a student of CS/ CA/ ICWA inter does not prove any credibility( certainly the inter passed students have already proved some credibility) and it is proved only after Final. On the other hand getting chance in Medical/ Engg/ MBA itself proves the credentiality of the student. Hence this difference in stipend. Once a candidate is CS/ CA/ ICWA qualified he/ she will get the same value as his Doctor/ Engineer/ MBA friend. In case of JRF etc - you cant compare at all a student of CA/ CS/ ICWA with a JRF candidate who has already obtained Masters degree and cracked one of the toughest entrance exam. Hence their stipend is bound to be much more than CA/ CS/ ICWA Student.
However I fully agree that present CA Article stipend is too little and should be increased to certain level (but please dont compare with JRF candidate). ICAI should change its training structure and make it similar in line with ICSI training. My experience shows that CS trainiees get some more stipend than CA Articles.
Regards
kaushal kumar agarwal
(article & audit assistant)
(28 Points)
Replied 20 September 2009
ca sosan ca students article ship period 8 hours minimum working and stipend 750 rule follow ICAI and working hours not rules follow ICAI and ICAI rules article not stend after 7p.m but this rules not follo
Analysis of 20 GST Notices (including 2 Appeals) and Practise on Drafting(with recording)
GSTR 9 and 9C for FY 23-24 as amended by Notification 12/2024 dated 10th July 2024(with recording)
CAclubindia
