Singhania v/s Manoharan

1022 views 3 replies

jomi

JJJ

55 Points Joined January 2011

Hi friends,

I am writing this for my friend.....he is a Ca final student relying on Self study alone..........He has Manoharans Text on Income tax.....Can any one comment on the benefits of the two text books....i.e...Singhania or Manoharan...which is better???

Has any one referred both the texts?

Can any one please give a comparison between the 2 texts???....which is the best one for self study????

Replies (3)

Guest

I had also this confusion in my studies during exam days. I have purchased and gone through both the books. In my opinion, Singhaniya is the best for self study as compared to Manoharan. The presentation in Singhaniya book is much better.

CS,CA F,Numrologi TusharSampat

CS CA F Numerologist Astrologer Graph

85935 Points Joined May 2010

For exam of for any purpose Singhania is considered to be the ultimate book for any professional exam in inda for income tax.

But Problem with singhania is that its too huge ncontains many case laws n cannot be completed within1.5 days for revision during exam.Otherwise its d best book for self study.

Dont have any knowledge for manoharan ,i have never used it.