shame for icai

Ravee (148 Points)
Replied 10 May 2007

This is a joke April fool? I totally agree with Mr. Sanjay Aggarwal.

[quote=1803]ATTENTION ALL THE CA STUDENTS REENA GULATI THE FIRST RANK HOLDER IN NOVEMBER 2005 EXAMS HAD BEEN FIRED FROM HER JOB AND GER CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT'S FIRM IS BANNED FOR 5 YEARS[/quote]

[quote=1893]HI ALL,

THIS IS A RUMUR ONLY. THIS IS NOT A TRUE NEWS.
THIS TYPE OF RUMUR IS VERY HARMFUL FOR OUR PROFESSION AND SPECIALLY FOR NEWLY QUALIFIED CA.
PLZ DO NOT BE PART/MEDIUM IN SPREADING THIS TYPE OF HARMFUL AND FALSE NEWS.

REENA IS PRESENTLY WORKING AND NOW ON TRANING IN HARDWARD BUSINESS SCHOOL.

WITH WARM REGARDS
SANJAY AGGARWAL
09871245836(DELHI)
SIMPLISANJAY @ GMAIL.COM[/quote]

Ca Student (52 Points)
Replied 10 May 2007

well i again say that -its a confirmed news.........reena gulati fired.......
                         i have been told by a authenticated person .......i cant tell the name.........

            i think that all the dummy cases will not like to agree to this.........

                       i can understand their pain..............but no one can deny to -what has actually happened ....no one can change that................

             all should  take a lesson from this..........

Ca Student (52 Points)
Replied 10 May 2007

well i again say that -its a confirmed news.........reena gulati fired.......
                         i have been told by a authenticated person .......i cant tell the name.........

            i think that all the dummy cases will not like to agree to this.........

                       i can understand their pain..............but no one can deny to -what has actually happened ....no one can change that................

             all should  take a lesson from this..........

Ca Student (52 Points)
Replied 10 May 2007

well i again say that -its a confirmed news.........reena gulati fired.......
                         i have been told by a authenticated person .......i cant tell the name.........

            i think that all the dummy cases will not like to agree to this.........

                       i can understand their pain..............but no one can deny to -what has actually happened ....no one can change that................

             all should  take a lesson from this..........

Ca Student (52 Points)
Replied 10 May 2007

i think -ravi is a dummy.........

                          otherwise -why would he be denying this fact -without proof.........i and matrix have proof...............

                  come on let us accept it ........and learn from it .......rather than run away from it friends.............

Ca Student (52 Points)
Replied 10 May 2007

i think -ravi is a dummy.........

                          otherwise -why would he be denying this fact -without proof.........i and matrix have proof...............

                  come on let us accept it ........and learn from it .......rather than run away from it friends.............

Ravee (148 Points)
Replied 10 May 2007

Please don't even try with your pitiful attempts at solemness. What proof do you have? If such an event were to occur it would have appeared in major newspapers or at the most in the CA Journal or in the HLL newsletter. But it hasn't so please stop this non-sense.

castudent and matrix are one and the same person.[b] For that matter I think you are dummy trying to overcompensate by saying how important articleship is.[/b]

Any person who has done or is doing articleship would never write in the juvenile manner of a pre-teen that you do.

Further instead of making baseless accusations and posting the same message 100 times concentrate on your studies and join somewhere for articleship instead of doing your deemed articleship - then you won't have time for this hate mongering and spreading ridiculous rumours.

Now I bet you castudent will reply with another 100 posts with the same content and then log out and log in again as matrix and post a retort. This is really funny ;)

Sumit (CA Practice ) (675 Points)
Replied 10 May 2007

Yaar

why are you fighting, there is no reason to fight at all.

I don't know whether she is fired or not but it is true that Articleship is very important for a successful CA career.

Keep your heads cool.

Bye

Sumit

Ravee (148 Points)
Replied 10 May 2007

Hi Sumit,

No one is fighting. I just don't like it when such remarks are passed.

Yes I agree articleship is very important that is the reason we are doing this work ;D. When people like you are there on this forum spreading great knowledge and helping others like me along comes this guy. :D

Ca Student (52 Points)
Replied 10 May 2007

i am not fighting yaar.................

                       but people like ravee shouldnt behave nonsense - by protecting  her without any knowledge of this matter.............

                   he just doesnt know of this and is claiming to know....that is foolish yaar..........

          if u dont know ....u better keep quiet .....and ICAI is not  a fool -to publicise that -its own student has been fired ............so better talk sense..........why would ICAI publicise the issue in the journal....

                let us accept this and be careful on the same for us

Ca Student (52 Points)
Replied 10 May 2007

i am not fighting yaar.................

                       but people like ravee shouldnt behave nonsense - by protecting  her without any knowledge of this matter.............

                   he just doesnt know of this and is claiming to know....that is foolish yaar..........

          if u dont know ....u better keep quiet .....and ICAI is not  a fool -to publicise that -its own student has been fired ............so better talk sense..........why would ICAI publicise the issue in the journal....

                let us accept this and be careful on the same for us

Ravee (148 Points)
Replied 10 May 2007

My friend castudent please note read with a calm mind what I have said.

You make a claim without proof I have not made any such claims I have quoted what another member has said and said I agree with what he said. In any law a person is innocent till proven guilty. You are making claims about a 3rd party who cannot defend herself that is grossly wrong.

Next you out of the blue claim that I am dummy how and why what did I personally attack you - when you do should I keep quiet? Would you do the same?

CA Journal does publish the names of persons against whom disciplinary action is taken and our media these days is such that the smallest of events even those sub-judice are published.

A matter such as this would have been highlighted definitely if it were true. And it is for your own good that I am saying that your writing style does not indicate the professionalism that is shown by anyone connected with the CA fraternity.

Please stop spreading rumours.

Ca Student (52 Points)
Replied 10 May 2007

friend -i am just quoting a person -very close to ICAI -let me confirm from him and i will disclose the source's authenticity.............to satisfy you.........

i am just telling all this -because many of us -work extraordinarily hard to balance -articleship and exams..........and many like -reena gulati -take dummy and skip articles and score good and take all credits ..........

so my mail is directed to such people only - i.e -dummys.........

Ravee (148 Points)
Replied 10 May 2007

Yes that is a better approach follow that.

As we learn while doing any audit you have to look for proper corroborative evidence and show it clearly in the WPs so that in case of review any person can draw the same conclusion that you have.

Similarly in this case post proper evidence. Good to see that you have seen my point of view and taken things in the right spirit.