Anuj Mehta (Assistant) (221 Points)
31 March 2013Individuals:
A: 9 goods cairrages
B: 9 goods cairrages
A (HUF): 9 goods cairrages
Partnership firm (Partners- A & B):
AB Firm: 9 goods cairrages
Can all of them be assessed seperately u/s 44AE? Would your ans be different it were AB Pvt Ltd ?
CA CS Nirmal Pagaria
(Fresher)
(90 Points)
Replied 31 March 2013
Anuj Ji,
Under section 44AE An assessee engaged in plying, hiring, or leasing of goods carriage& Assessee owned not more than 10 vehicles during previous year. Then this provision sall be applicable. Under this provision u may declare presumptive income of assessee. It is applicable on all assesee even if they are resident or not.
In ur case u can assess income of above business in sec. 44AE including company. Further no deduction would be allowed us 30 to 38. however in case of partnership, further remuneration, interest(us 40b, 184,185) shall be allowed.
Anuj Mehta
(Assistant)
(221 Points)
Replied 31 March 2013
what if they incorporate another partneship firm and again own 9 goods cairrages?
so in all 3 individuals & 2 partnership firms.. all below 10 vehicles. can all of the assessee be assessed u/s 44AE?
wont be like evading tax or something? & its a Partnership firm (Partner & Individual are the same.. do seperate entity like in companies)
Nazia
(Asst Manager - Finance)
(139 Points)
Replied 01 April 2013
Assessment of firm & individuals are separate as per Income tax act, though profit of firm is clubbed in partner's income, firm & partners can be individually assessed under sec 44AE. No harm.
PF & ESI Course - Labour Code 2019 Along with Examples and Case Studies
CAclubindia
