samkit (article) (55 Points)
04 October 2009paper wil be more practical & difficult..eg:
Bobby darling has aproachd u 4 filing his/her return.Wht wil b d slab rate aplicable?
20mARKS COMPULSORY QUE.
PLZ ANYBODY KNOW PLZ REPLY.
BHAGYESH RAVANGE
(C.A Job)
(1528 Points)
Replied 04 October 2009
may be this sort of question would be asked
The Harshit Aggarwal
(B.Com(H) ,CS Final)
(5278 Points)
Replied 04 October 2009
| Originally posted by :samkit | ||
| " | OUR HONOURABLE PRESIDENT OF ICAI MR.UTTAM PRAKASH AGRAWAL SAYS THAT THE paper wil be more practical & difficult..eg: Bobby darling has aproachd u 4 filing his/her return.Wht wil b d slab rate aplicable? 20mARKS COMPULSORY QUE. PLZ ANYBODY KNOW PLZ REPLY. |
" |
Initially he was a boy but now.........he becomes she.
So treat Bobby Darling as a woman !!
AMIT KAPOOR
(SELF EMPLOYED)
(491 Points)
Replied 04 October 2009
compute the income as per man slab and also compute as woman slab and divide it by 2 that should be tax laibility of boby darling
GAURAV MEHTA
(ARTICLE ASST.)
(53 Points)
Replied 04 October 2009
so simple...if bobby darling wanna file his/her return...ask her/him to say which slab he/she will like...!!
samkit
(article)
(55 Points)
Replied 04 October 2009
GAURAV MEHTA
(ARTICLE ASST.)
(53 Points)
Replied 04 October 2009
so buddy if u knw. d answer plz let us knw...thn....
CA MOHIT GUPTA
(PRACTICE)
(49 Points)
Replied 04 October 2009
Dear All...
First of all you have to check his/her status in PAN Card....
If He/She had not yet applied for a PAN No...
Than You have to check her status for the Previous year for which income tax is to be computed
GAURAV MEHTA
(ARTICLE ASST.)
(53 Points)
Replied 04 October 2009
how can nybody has filed return w/o a PAN ?
n if it is feasible...then if wants to chang its slab then wht?
| Originally posted by :samkit | ||
| " | " | |
haa hoooooooooooooooooooo heeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa aha ahjauhduahwhfjoETHJaert
CA CS Bhumika Thakkar
(CA,CS)
(1618 Points)
Replied 04 October 2009
well..if he files by d name pankaj i.e his original name den d 1 applcble for men n if bobby den d 1 applcble for women..
amit kumar jha
(article trainee)
(72 Points)
Replied 04 October 2009
kyo dara raha ho yaar, U.Agarwal ne tujhe message kiya hai kya..........
samkit
(article)
(55 Points)
Replied 05 October 2009
1.1st opinion is that in the case of boby darling,
uske pas abhi bhi sare certificates as a male hei na ki female ke. he doesn't have prove of the same.
isliye slab rate individual(male) ka hi lagega lkn agr saal me kisi bhi din wo ye prove kr de ki now he is female to slab rate female ka hi lagega...
2.you know institute has asked you confirmed answer as institute has weighted of 20 marks of this question so you must have knowledge of a.y.2009-10.as per a.y.2009-10 there is no defination included in the income tax act of male,female or other category.
so u must have written also regarding this.and as per u see feelings of boby darling like a female so u also can say that she/he has also applicable FEMALE slab rate because in india every one want to pay less tax and want more white income but still institute has not launched suggested answer so depends upon the suggested answer what will be the answer.
3.said that he/she has all certificate of male and not female but no one of us go to bobby darling home to see the certificate and also no books published in the market who has that certificate of male may be he cnverted female also and you already know this quetion has 20 marks weighted so answer must be sure.
4.I ALSO READ I.TAX BEARER ACT BUT THERE IS SLAB APPLICABLE OF INDIVIDUAL(MALE,FEMALE,SENIORCITIZEN MALE AND FEMALE) BUT THERE NO SLAB FOR SHEMALE.AS BOBBY DARLING IS SHEMALE SO MAY BE HE/SHE IS EXEMPTHED FORM I.TAX
Sagar
(Article)
(162 Points)
Replied 14 October 2009
His/Her Income shall be exempted u/s 10.......
new provision in new direct tax code
CAclubindia
