This is the mistake of the institute .................

She must b given 60  marks without conducting the exam. (with her prior concent)

This is very bad but for the hard worker students not for the rich and those person who have the very high power in politics and ICAI ,,,,,,,,, But this openly spreading the news in the general public will create the room for    the corruption in the ICAI also like  delhi university  .

ICAI itself asking for the bribe in the indirect way , they are not directly asking for this however they are telling the way how can somebody can give the money to them.  Now Chartered Accountancy Course will also became thevalue less course like Engineering

Students will pay  the bribe at the examination centre to the examinor for holding the answer sheet of the subject in which they will feel they get fail and again give the exam. by having the excuse that their paper has lost.       

its true really bad for student community.

there is no any better solution than re-examination .

             probably  ICAI is one of the few institutes who are openely accepting their mistake, moreover this type of incidences happen very rare so i dont think we should criticize our institute afterall we are the future  MEMBERS of this institute

hi guys,

u knw wht guys after spending 4 years of my life in CA i feel dat v all committed 2 blunder mistakes in r life...

1. V were born in india.

2. V choose to b CAs.

really guys i m totally fed up of this system and trust me guys "It hapnes only in India"....

I feel pity on my mother land for beeing ruled by a race of Stupids.....

v indians are born slaves... v were in a better state when britishers ruled us.. Atleast at that time only britishers used to rob us but today every one is bussy robing d other person... let it b the govt or our so called "Highly Professional" institute..

I am sry if i hurt d feelings of any bdy.. bt guys dats d truth....

v must send representations from the student community to d institute requesting it to stop such practices which defame d degnity of our profession.... v must not let foolish things happen... so come on guys.... some 1 will have to lead... make an application and feed it on caclub india....

All my CA friends download d application , sign it and send it to the institute... please guys i request u all that its high time to arise and fight back 4 ur rights.........

Originally posted by : siddharth jain
	there is no any better solution than re-examination .              probably  ICAI is one of the few institutes who are openely accepting their mistake, moreover this type of incidences happen very rare so i dont think we should criticize our institute afterall we are the future  MEMBERS of this institute

Yeah, its right...mistake happens once...............

we can't judge with what we see.....

Institute which expects accuracy ..... must deliver the same too....

Originally posted by : Ashok R. Shukla
	Originally posted by : siddharth jain there is no any better solution than re-examination .              probably  ICAI is one of the few institutes who are openely accepting their mistake, moreover this type of incidences happen very rare so i dont think we should criticize our institute afterall we are the future  MEMBERS of this institute Yeah, its right...mistake happens once............... we can't judge with what we see.....

mistake do happen  we all accept... but the fact is person making the mistake should bear the burden but here is other way around.....

Could be bad news for the girl but overall my faith on institute's procedure has increased. An organization should not be afraid of accepting mistakes and I am sure it would prove positively for the girl. Now I know that atleast institute won't give me random marks.
 

we do not know how many times this has been happened... however we are come  to know this first time.. too bad

Originally posted by : Shrikant Subramanian
	I would like to know why first of all a notification was passed way back on January ? Exam was conducted only in May right?Then ICAI , by itself found that this girl Grishma Nadiq's paper is missing and announced this fact in Official Gazzete and asked the student to give paper in July again? Are all the above facts , as interepted by me, right? ICAI, should have granted then 40 to her, as she must have lost her touch with studies for she was idle since 2 months. Unfair to student.

ok...mr.shrikant subramanian...wil u accept 40 marks...if this situation is yours.......

UNFAIR thng happened to dat girl.... nthng can compensate Ms. Grishma Nadiq efforts what she had put it for 6 months to write d exam....we all are CA students right ....we know the pain to write the exam again n again...so how can you say to grant institute 40 marks to her to compensate the loss occur to that poor girl...

It's the only her to take the decision...whether to go with the institute...or against the institue...

Institue accepted it's mistake......n it's not the institue giving her chance....IT IS THE INSTITUTE TAKING OPPURTUNITY TO RECTIFY THEIR MISTAKE.....

However we have to appreciate Institue....coz instead of hiding this matter n giving just pass marks....they have taken some what justifiable decision....

are kahi mera paper bhi to nahi kho dia

me nahi dene wala dubara paper :-)   :-)

Hard luck