its a bad sign of management................

ICAI has proved itself to be one of the most unprofessional institute in the world. They lost the answer scripttt of  a student and now they have the audacity to ask the student to appear for a re-exam. Why should the student suffer? Whose fault was it that the answer scripttttt got misplaced? Following the typical Indian mentality of respecting the Guru, even if he is wrong, I am sure the student will now appear for the exam instead of dragging the institute to court. 

ICAI regularly goes to court to prevent better foreign accountancy institutes from setting up their offices and campuses in India. Litigations against CFA(USA), CIMA, ACCA....the list goes on. Students who have money can easily go to Australia, study Australian CPA (which is far more easier and scientific) and then come back to take a membership of this crappy institute. The poor English knowledge of the members of the institute speaks much about it's quality. Our institute probably has the most pathetic articleship structure in the world, let's face it, ALL CA's treat their articles like slaves unless he/she happens to be his relative. 

I have myself seen senior articles checking the answers scripttts of IPCC students. It simply proves that the quality control ICAI talks about is bullsh*t.

SHAME ICAI 

P.S: ICAEW has it's branch in China but not in India, thanks to ICAI.

P.P.S: I don't know what is wrong with Caclub forum, I am repeatedly modifying my reply but still the spelling of "scripttt" is coming out wrong when published. I know it contains only one "t". 

VERY BAD... WHAT IS THE RESPONSIBILITY INSITUTE IS TAKING? AND BY THIS WE CAN UNDERSTAND THE CREDIBILITY OF OUR ANSWER PAPERS. DUNNO HOW THEY HAVE EVALUATED.. 

You may say any thing, you want, but can any one give any solution for this, it is now proven truth that the answer sheets are lost, what use it is to look back, no better solution then re-test,

INOCENT

Its a fault of ICAI & I think, she should have been given two options, either re-sit the exam, if she want or passing marks.

image of our insitute wis getting worse.................

We have no words for consolation to - Grishma Nadiq . Such incidents are not expected at all .

Really a bad news..................Dont worry Ms. Grishma Nadiq...................Final victory is yours..........

y every  student have to give exam again yar???? 

well said Mr.Bhav Sharma...

I would like to know why first of all a notification was passed way back on January ?

Exam was conducted only in May right?Then ICAI , by itself found that this girl Grishma Nadiq's paper is missing and announced this fact in Official Gazzete and asked the student to give paper in July again?

Are all the above facts , as interepted by me, right?

ICAI, should have granted then 40 to her, as she must have lost her touch with studies for she was idle since 2 months. Unfair to student.

IT IS VERY SHOCKING TO ICAI .  ICAI SHOULD COMPENSATE THE STUDENT ADEQUATELY 

ALOK RAMAN 

what is the source of the information??????