The days are not far off when students will perhaps unite and question such high handed things at the various offices of ICAI. The Students Associations in respective regions should be more pro active (and not simply toe the line of the council member - nominated as the Chairman of the Students Association, who is invariably a stooge of the Chairman of the RC - becoz the post is a nominated one - a quid pro quo for supporting a person for Vice Chairman position) and slowly have a federal set up at Pan India level - select prominent CAs, with no electoral ambitions and who have their hearts for the student community ( believe me, there are a lot of them) to be their mentors , in their respective regions and organise themselves with poise, maturity and responsibility to become a formidable body to ensure right things happen at the right measure in the right manner for the students and even be an effective bridge between the students and the Institute. Slowly, as the size of the organisation swells, they can influence the Government to amend CA regulations to provide for student-members in the committees that directly affect the students. Already many people have begun asking questions. And already there is a decision from Central Information Commission (posted by me under the Exam thread) in favour of a student who was rebuffed for his request for the evaluated answer sheets. So, there will be public support also. The situation that people who come to the helm of affairs for just an year or two can take decisions that would affect any section - be members or students - in the long term should be checked. So, dears, the Institute's future is in your hands. But dont wait for such days to come - you march towards the days.

 But Sir I have heard that voicing against the institute results in stringent measures taken by the Institute in the form of stricter evaluation which no one can question too...

I am now thinking to write a letter to HRD ministry,I agree with sir we should stand up for now for our own rights otherwise no one will.

Stop fearing that ICAI will evaluate u srtictly.that is jst a rumor.

If institutes believes all questions will be practical oriented with intention of testing  an in-depth knowledge then why can’t make it open book exam. Here important is test your understanding and knowledge not memory.....   Suck kind of stupid decision will make CA exam as Memory game

Dear Sir,

Finally got a reply from the institute.

As expected the reply is"The notification is based on the announcement by BOS".

I do not understand what they mean by that,none of my question are answered and this is the spirit of ICAI.

But I not bowed down by this reply .I will keep fighting for the students even after becoming a CA like Prabhakar sir.

Thanks everyone. 

 PRABHAKER SIR SAYS

"The days are not far off when students will perhaps unite and question such high handed things at the various offices of ICAI. The Students Associations in respective regions should be more pro active (and not simply toe the line of the council member - nominated as the Chairman of the Students Association, who is invariably a stooge of the Chairman of the RC - becoz the post is a nominated one - a quid pro quo for supporting a person for Vice Chairman position) and slowly have a federal set up at Pan India level - select prominent CAs, with no electoral ambitions and who have their hearts for the student community ( believe me, there are a lot of them) to be their mentors , in their respective regions and organise themselves with poise, maturity and responsibility to become a formidable body to ensure right things happen at the right measure in the right manner for the students and even be an effective bridge between the students and the Institute. Slowly, as the size of the organisation swells, they can influence the Government to amend CA regulations to provide for student-members in the committees that directly affect the students. Already many people have begun asking questions. And already there is a decision from Central Information Commission (posted by me under the Exam thread) in favour of a student who was rebuffed for his request for the evaluated answer sheets. So, there will be public support also. The situation that people who come to the helm of affairs for just an year or two can take decisions that would affect any section - be members or students - in the long term should be checked. So, dears, the Institute's future is in your hands. But dont wait for such days to come - you march towards the days."

I completely agree with what Tushar had to say to Aldrine's message!

Aldrine....

I really enjoyed exchanging views with you. I am stopping here from writing anymore msg on this subject. Because i feel ,by doing this, we are diverting the main topic..... finally....i will put my thought in single line.....

"Jack of all trades, master of none"...... no customs or religion denies the importance of development of logical thinking at first stage.... even accepting others belief, one need to understand the concept behind it....  even water ..... one must know what is water and its importance....

Hmmm!

even if this protest comes to the notice of ICAI i dont think those who appear in NOV 09 exams can escape this...

They will have to face..I m one such.

ICAI has increased the BP levels of its already pressurised students..