Error in CA final result-An analysis

Final 3084 views 19 replies

Nancy

Article

243 Points Joined June 2009

Dear Friends

Remember, Result is never a parameter to judge anyone's intelligence. Result declared by ICAI is:

Year Apprd	Total of Both Groups, Ist Group & IInd Group			Both Groups			Only Ist Group			Only IInd Group
Year Apprd	Total of Both Groups, Ist Group & IInd Group			Both Groups			Only Ist Group			Only IInd Group			Apprd	Passed	%	Apprd	Passed	%	Apprd	Passed	%	Apprd	Passed	%
Nov' 2008	59646	14580	24.44%	14614	2926	20.02	21176	5892	27.82	23856	5762	24.15
June' 2009	72313	15143	20.94%	18625	2579	13.85	25848	8379	32.42	27840	4185	15.03

There seems some error in either result declared by ICAI in this attempt or in last attempt (because data for Nov.’08 is mismatching). Result analysis till last attempt by ICAI was:

Year Apprd	Total of Both Groups, Ist Group & IInd Group			Both Groups			Only Ist Group			Only IInd Group
Year Apprd	Total of Both Groups, Ist Group & IInd Group			Both Groups			Only Ist Group			Only IInd Group			Apprd	Passed	%	Apprd	Passed	%	Apprd	Passed	%	Apprd	Passed	%
Nov’2007	23976	7002	29.20%	8654	2446	28.26	7483	2437	32.57	7839	2119	27.03
May’2008	25625	6654	25.97%	10570	2642	25.00	6965	1927	26.67	8090	2085	25.77
Nov' 2008	30399	6142	20.20%	14606	2961	20.27	6558	1230	18.76	9235	1951	21.13

Detailed results declared for this attempt & last attempt by ICAI are attached with this mail.

CA. Parag Gupta

(Faculty-Costing & O.R. for CA Final)

Costing By Parag Gupta

Ground Floor, A-156

Gali No. 4, Shakarpur

(Opposite Walia Nursing Home)

Delhi - 110092

Ph : +91 9891432632

Email : paraggupta_ca @ yahoo.co.in

Yahoo Group : https://groups.yahoo.com/group/costingbyparaggupta

P.S.: For any Costing & O.R. related query, you are requested to call me during 9:00 p.m.-11:00 p.m. For registration enquiry, any other query, etc. you may contact during 10:00 a.m.- 05:30 p.m.

Attached File : 26 result analysis.zip downloaded: 189 times

Replies (19)

Nancy

Article

243 Points Joined June 2009

Please go through above mail of Parag Gupta sir before making any conclusion on this attempt's result.

Guest

Forword the mistake to president uttam agarwal.

CA. Shwetank Vats

Chartered Accountant

653 Points Joined May 2008

Passing result Jun'09 very low as compairing of last so many attemps

sachin

haaaa

68 Points Joined April 2009

Thanks a Lottt sir.. u Really ROCK in finding this great and Big Mistake... keep it up ....

N GANESHAN.

CA FINAL STUDENT - PRACTITIONER

921 Points Joined September 2007

WHAT THESE PEPOPE ARE DOING ? THEY ARE PLAYING WITH NO. OF STUDENTS LIFE... HAY WHAT A ICAI...

Hitesh Bajaj

Asst. Manager

58 Points Joined March 2009

guys....dont find discrepancies with icai....if they really found out some mistake you never know some one has passed they may suddenly tell you....boss your result was wrongly printed....????:(

Nayan Dutta

CA and ICWA

73 Points Joined July 2008

how can we confirm what happened? And what we can do about it, besides studying onemore time.......

CA.Lekshmi Devi

Chartered Accountant

120 Points Joined February 2009

Originally posted by :Raja ji banaras wale
"	guys....dont find discrepancies with icai....if they really found out some mistake you never know some one has passed they may suddenly tell you....boss your result was wrongly printed....????:(	"

Hi, i am getting scared with this. As per declared result i have qualified... Does this mean that there are chances of passing students being failed or vice versa? I am very nervous .... Will someone tell me what is it? As per Parag Gupta sirs attachment, what i understand is that 72313 is the total of students appeared in both groups, group I and group II(ie;. 18625+25848+27840). Also 15143 passed is the total of 2579+8379+4185. So I think the mistake is only in total data and not in individual results?

Rahul Savyanavar

Assistant

31 Points Joined August 2009

This analysys is good one.

This is a technical jargon.

There is a lot of scope to improve reporting standard by icai.

M.Sridevi

Student

31 Points Joined August 2009

there are any chances of correction in the results declared by ICAI.

Lalit aggarwal

371 Points Joined March 2007

no sri devi ji,no chance........

Bharati

Article Assistant

45 Points Joined July 2009

Hey HI NaNcY.......

Thanks for giving such a good analysis...........

I m a BIG victim of such a BIG MISTAKE.........I was execpting to clear my CA Final exams........2 my surprise 13th August,2009 was a day which have put me in trauma..........I have fluncked in 4 subjects & tht's not alll.....In all the 4 subjects I got 36......& 1 MORE THNG MY both groups total is the same i.e. 189.....Now u'll say is this not a game played by institute with innocent people like us who have put their level best 4 success..........I have lost fait in ICAI.........

Bharati

Article Assistant

45 Points Joined July 2009

Hey HI NaNcY.......

Thanks for giving such a good analysis...........

Bharati

Article Assistant

45 Points Joined July 2009

Hey HI NaNcY.......

Thanks for giving such a good analysis...........

I m a BIG victim of such a BIG MISTAKE.........I was excepting to clear my CA Final exams........2 my surprise 13th August,2009 was a day which have put me in trauma..........I have flunked in 4 subjects & tht's not all.....In all the 4 subjects I got 36......& 1 MORE THNG MY both groups total is the same i.e. 189.....Now u'll say is this not a game played by institute with innocent people like us who have put their level best 4 success..........I have lost fait in ICAI.........