CA Sunny Girdhar (Looking for Job) (121 Points)
20 July 2012Hi All,
Just came across the pass percentages of CA Final and it seems like that ICAI is not keen on getting back to old days of 2 or 3 % result. So, given the condition of jobs in the industry for CA, What you think that Why ICAI is doing it?
Is it due to pressure from RTI & Ruling of Re assessment or ICAI is trying to releive students of pressure?
Guys please share ur views !!!
Joey Tribbiani
(fdg)
(2010 Points)
Replied 20 July 2012
Is pass percentage announced by ICAI? I saw a post mentioning the results pass percentage to be 15% but the source was some regional newspaper and there is no announcement on ICAI website.
TARAK NATH
(Dy.Manager (Finance))
(196 Points)
Replied 20 July 2012
MCA has instructed the three institute to nearly double the pass percentage because with growth of indian economy ,India needs more professsional like Govt. has increased no. of IIT .It is because of this reason in comming years there will be a huge increase in % of passing .
Saurabh Maheshwari
(B.com,ACA)
(5923 Points)
Replied 20 July 2012
CA Sunny Girdhar
(Looking for Job)
(121 Points)
Replied 20 July 2012
Hmmmm..... very brave statement to make... But dnt forget my fren... Each era has got hard working n intelligent guys... N earlier generation was not exception too...
CA Sunny Girdhar
(Looking for Job)
(121 Points)
Replied 20 July 2012
@ Tarak : U r r8 in saying this but do u think CA's are getting job which is paying them as per their capability and hard work they have put in for becoming CA......
TARAK NATH
(Dy.Manager (Finance))
(196 Points)
Replied 20 July 2012
SUNNY, CA,CS,CMA are all professional qualification in academic nature.After becoming memeber one or more community it is the person who has decide it career.Merely passing can not and should not ensure highly paid up jobs.
After becomming a doctor one can not ensure he will earn huge. CA,CMA,CS are also same in nature
CA Sunny Girdhar
(Looking for Job)
(121 Points)
Replied 20 July 2012
Okie.
So. if a employer has to filter out a good CA out of such a huge dump of Pass outs. It is easy to filter out a Good MBA by Good College & Percentage... There may be a criteria of filtering by Ranks But it is not the right criteria as they may have Dummy Articleship Exposure.....
Thats the only concern !!!
Sushant Lohani
(CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT)
(1051 Points)
Replied 20 July 2012
Passing many CAs doesn't ensure quality. Change my name, if the upcoming campus placement becomes successful.
9pc freshers(attendants) got job offers during last campus. What about ICAI president's saying that "minimum package will be fixed at 9lacs pa"?
I dont think MCA gave any such instruction. Recession me 16pc passout; == more unemployed CAs(i consider CAs working at 10000pm as unemployed; even if CA firm me kaam karenge toh atleast 17-18k toh milni chahiye).
God save CA's brand value.....
CA Sunny Girdhar
(Looking for Job)
(121 Points)
Replied 20 July 2012
Thats what is happening to CA's now..... Now a CA can do nothing that join any BPO and getting a meagre Salary....
whats the use of working your A** out in Internship ???
CA Sunny Girdhar
(Looking for Job)
(121 Points)
Replied 20 July 2012
Thats what is happening to CA's now..... Now a CA can do nothing that join any BPO and getting a meagre Salary....
whats the use of working your A** out in Internship ???
TARAK NATH
(Dy.Manager (Finance))
(196 Points)
Replied 20 July 2012
Dr. Virappa Moily, minister MCA ,has told in recent meeting that india needs another 2.5 lakhs professionals within 2025. this information is given by one responsible officer of examination dept. of the institute.
CA Sunny Girdhar
(Looking for Job)
(121 Points)
Replied 20 July 2012
Ya i understand sir. I am not disputing the source of the Fact !!!
But the point is that the this need is not being showcased in the Vacancies/Job Offers for the CA's. But according to the comment by a senior official of ICAI, the higher result is to make sure that the mediocre firms in India can get CA's in low salary so that they can save their cost..... Thats really disgusting, isnt it ???
CA Harshavardhan
(Practice)
(33 Points)
Replied 20 July 2012
Hold on Guys......there is nothing like CA getting unemployed---- the only fact i want to put here is PLEASE DONT COME TO CONCLUSON BY LOOKING AT PASS PERCENTAGES AND FEW CA;S GETTING PAID 10000/- PM-
INSTITUTE IS NOT A FOOL TO GIVE SUCH RESULTS, THERE ARE EXPERIENCED PROFESSIONALS RUNNING THE INSTITUTE AND DEFINETELY WHATEVER THE INSTITUTE IS DOING IT IS DOING GOOD FOR THE SAKE OF THE PROFESSION
THE BRAND VALUE WILL ALWAYS REMAIN THE SAME....WHATEVER HAPPENS.....
PLEASE SEE THE TRUST BUSINESS PLACE ON THE CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS IN CORPORATE WORLD...THEY ARE LOOKED AS HEROS..YAR............
LETS ALL TRY TO BUILD CREDIBILITY FOR THE FUTURE CA;S JUST LIKE WHAT OUR SENIORS HAVE DONE FOR THE LAST 50 YEARS
piyush
(executive)
(26 Points)
Replied 20 July 2012
doagree with Mr Harshawardhan.fact that passing % is increased does'nt affect the credibility of CA.passing % is just 16.what about the MBA nd engineers there % result is almost near to 90% does this affects their credibility.take this point only those MBA nd engineers students succeds who are smart &knowledgeable
CAclubindia
