ANAND KUMAR (Senior Accounts Executive M.com CS Professional) (64 Points)
10 September 2012Dear Friends,
One of My friend has got 186 marks in CA Final May'2012 exams First group , and he applied for verification of marks and supply of certified copies of answer books,
he got the verification has no descrepancies and after that he has got certified copies of answer books he is observing that his result marks and the marks in certified copies is different.
is it possible that both marks are different.
Mohit Bhownani
(Student)
(294 Points)
Replied 10 September 2012
can u tell us how much is the difference?
ANAND KUMAR
(Senior Accounts Executive M.com CS Professional)
(64 Points)
Replied 10 September 2012
he got more marks than in answer scriptts they can modify anything ?
Vijay Sridhar
(C A student)
(26 Points)
Replied 10 September 2012
What was the change in marks, Can you please let me know ?
CA Ashish Pathak
(Employed at Cipla Ltd.)
(2779 Points)
Replied 10 September 2012
How can this be possible? How can ICAI put any marks in the results as per its wishes? How can there be a difference between marks as per certified copies and what is being shown in the result?
And the fact is that this particular student applied for reverification and the reverification result shows "NO DISCREPANCY IN THE MARKS." This is simply ridiculous.... This shows how unreliable are CA reults... Because of such careless corrections many of the hardworking and deserving students fail and also some who don't deserve but qualifies. Such things really upsets those who work really hard but fails.
CA. Nuba Subzwari
(CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT)
(501 Points)
Replied 10 September 2012
Really!!!
m shocked?it doesn't matter how much is the difference,it matters how it happened..
now wat is the remedy for this?
Can anyone tell me why there is option for 1)supply of certified copies n 2)inspection & supply of certified copies.....
bcz they said that verification is the only remedy but they gave option for inspection also wen v apply for certified copies...what is the difference if i apply for suppy of certified copies only & if applied inspection as well?
GAURAV
(Article Assitant)
(22 Points)
Replied 10 September 2012
Dear Anandamalini
plz tell us wt is d difference so dt we can go for inspection of copies
it is very much unfair 4 those who tried whole heartedly bt couldn't pass out..
saurabh jawanpria
(final student )
(317 Points)
Replied 11 September 2012
don't get confused on inspection part as it only gives you the remedy to see your original papr in presence of icai officials...n yes this is rediculous ....my freinds also exp d same. i too applied bt didnt recvd till now bt reverification its showing no change
Joey Tribbiani
(fdg)
(2010 Points)
Replied 11 September 2012
Please clarify how much is the difference between marks in answer sheet and result displayed,or other reliable data. Merely saying something is not enough.
Shrinidhi
(Chartered Accountant CPA)
(32 Points)
Replied 11 September 2012
The same thing has happened with 2 of my friends too. one was in SFM paper and the other in Auditing paper. Its dishearting to know that there was no remedy made available to either of the 2 of my friends biut they were simply told to read the students declaration.
Also the declaration and other details on the application for inspection clearly says that the marks and other details should not be discussed with any Expert nor the Media otherwise the student will be prosecuted.
So its better not to discuss and not to give any other details of the person here.
CH MURALI KRISHNA, CMA, CA
(COST ACCOUNTANT)
(102 Points)
Replied 11 September 2012
Smruti
(CA)
(183 Points)
Replied 11 September 2012
how is this possible. i also did nt got any change in marks :).
CAclubindia
