Dear Sapna,

People get paid according to their abilities and performances. I have personally seen an IIM Graduate working on 12 lacs package an annum at 3i Infotech. Can you beat that?

Think about it.

Originally posted by : Jinay
	Dear Sapna, People get paid according to their abilities and performances. I have personally seen an IIM Graduate working on 12 lacs package an annum at 3i Infotech. Can you beat that? Think about it.

But I think ability wise also CA are more capable than B.Com but still B.com get more than Ca because industry don't count articleship experience...... also the deviation from 5% to 25% result is out of logic how can they give 5 times more result sometimes........

can u be sure abt 25% result. have u personally searched all the passed candidates results online.....no

its only a declared percentage.

and y r u saying "how can they "?

maybe during those examinations students had studied hard and they got gud rsults or paper may hv come easy.

u should stop thinking negitive and always look at the positive side.

Originally posted by : Vieshesh Garg
	can u be sure abt 25% result. have u personally searched all the passed candidates results online.....no its only a declared percentage. and y r u saying "how can they "? maybe during those examinations students had studied hard and they got gud rsults or paper may hv come easy. u should stop thinking negitive and always look at the positive side.

Please check the file on page 8 of this post and check the deviation its more than the range I said........

you are not getting mee.....

i mean to say that its only a declared percentage and vignesh has given very gud reasons for the same so it actually is not that much high a percentage than the declared one.

Originally posted by : Vieshesh Garg
	you are not getting mee..... i mean to say that its only a declared percentage and vignesh has given very gud reasons for the same so it actually is not that much high a percentage than the declared one.

The passing percentage is not dependent on the Knowledge of the student but on the chairman and other incharge at ICAI what else..... its not about high or low almost some time results are more than 5 times of lowest results (as given in file of vignesh).

you can clearly see that no of persons appering in both groups have increased but years in which the result is around or more 20%, less people appeared in both groups but absolute no of passed students has almost remained same , hence higher percentage...ignore may 2011

Originally posted by : Vieshesh Garg
	you can clearly see that no of persons appering in both groups have increased but years in which the result is around or more 20%, less people appeared in both groups but absolute no of passed students has almost remained same , hence higher percentage...ignore may 2011

Number wise result increased from 802 in May 03 to 6649 in May 11 and of May 11 is ignored 5075 in May 12............. And percentage wise deviation is from 4.57 to 28.26.................

when the result in absolute no. the percentage has been 15-16.

so it all setteles down.

what i mean to say is whenever there is around 20% result there are less no of students appearing for the exam.ignore may 2011

Originally posted by : Vieshesh Garg
	when the result in absolute no. the percentage has been 15-16. so it all setteles down. what i mean to say is whenever there is around 20% result there are less no of students appearing for the exam.ignore may 2011

But the results has too much deviation and May 2011 was a jackpot after Nov 07 and May 08...

Well now i think u dont want to face the reality of corporate world.

erevything in lyf can't be as per your expectations and demand.

you have to fight it hard to earn a place in industry.

your ca friend failed to fight hence working at a lower pay

And u also have to accept the fact that there can be exceptions.

you b.com friend was an exception.

it is as simple as that.

and still the ball is in your court....you can still quit ca but i guess 4,00,000 students are definately not stupid to apply for ca every 6 months rather than b.com if b.com earned them higher pay.

Originally posted by : Vieshesh Garg
	Well now i think u dont want to face the reality of corporate world. erevything in lyf can't be as per your expectations and demand. you have to fight it hard to earn a place in industry. your ca friend failed to fight hence working at a lower pay And u also have to accept the fact that there can be exceptions. you b.com friend was an exception. it is as simple as that. and still the ball is in your court....you can still quit ca but i guess 4,00,000 students are definately not stupid to apply for ca every 6 months rather than b.com if b.com earned them higher pay.

It is very simple for eg. Industry capacity plus CA Firm capacity is say 1000 CA requirement and if the institute say clears 10000 student than except rank holders other CA's will either be unemployed or under employed if they are not doing practice and even in practice there is too much competition even TRP made by Income tax eat away much of the revenue of CA firms........

Sapna, you have done well to raise this issue.  I still believe that a lot depends on your capabilities.  If you want to rise in life, degree can serve only as a stepping stone.  But beyond that you need to be intelligent, harding and lots of initiative.

I have just uploaded a video on cash book and petty cash book on youtube.  I would be grateful, if you could give me your feedback.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNokgjDDJAc&feature=youtu.be

Originally posted by : Jag Bhushan Sharma
	Sapna, you have done well to raise this issue.  I still believe that a lot depends on your capabilities.  If you want to rise in life, degree can serve only as a stepping stone.  But beyond that you need to be intelligent, harding and lots of initiative.   I have just uploaded a video on cash book and petty cash book on youtube.  I would be grateful, if you could give me your feedback.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNokgjDDJAc&feature=youtu.be   https://www.youtube.com/user/jbsclasses

Yes Sir capabilities is required everywhere but my point was just comparing the Degree not individual. 3 years articleship instead of helping CA is harming them financially since its not counted by Industry and on other hand B.Com of same age by that time gain 3 years of experience in Industry and also good amount of training. Also I will PM the feedback of your classes video by today or tomorrow morning. Thanks again for sharing video link.

hey sapna such long discussion on such a topic,c exceptions r always there if ur bcom frnd is getting more than ur ca frnd then u cannot hv a generalised view,its all abt ur passion,and curiosity to learn which will tk u far.............the thing is as of nw u r very confused and u yourself dont know what u want to do,bcoz the biggest and worth opinions v can get only from ourselves not from others,crux is choose a profession in which u hv interest,dont get carried away by others,their pay package their intelligence,decide urself where u want to  c urself some years down the line,the tag line is hard work never fails b it any course,if u hv vision where u want to b u'll definitely achieve it.and coming to CA it does has bright future if one has stamina to work hard and leave a mark..............................all the best to u for a ryt decision.