Knowledge Partner:
The Bengal Chamber of Commerce & Industry
91
st
Issue: 23 Oct 2016 – 29 Oct 2016
TAX CONNECT ADVISORY SERVICES LLP
Kolkata: 1, Old Court House Corver, ^Toao House_ 1 st
Floor, R.No.-13 (North), Kolkata- 700001
Gujarat: Quarter no. 3/174, Gujarat Refinery Township, Jawaharnagar, Vadodara- 391320
Contact: +919331042424; +919 831594980; +913322625203
Email: tb.chatterjee@yahoo.co.in; cavivekjalan@gmail.com
TAX CONNECT
INCOME TAX
CENTRAL EXCISE
SERVICE TAX
CUSTOMS
STATE TAXES
Page 2 Tax Connect: 91st
Issue
23 Oct 2016 – 29 Oct 2016
EDITORIAL
Friends,
Last week, the Centre proposed to impose an additional
levy in the form of cess over and above Goods and
Service Tax on the luxury and demerit goods like big cars,
aerated beverages, tobacco products.
This left the third meeting of GST Council on 19 October
with undecided tax rate structure. The Cess is proposed
as a means to finance the compensation it will have to
pay to the States. The Council has decided to meet again
in the first week of November where the tax structure is
expected to be finalized after consensus is reached on
funding the compensation.
On the other hand, the Assam Government has already
started with the process of collection of data in order to
facilitate communication of GST registration number to
the existing registered entities. The same has been done
vide CIRCULAR No. 9/2016 on 13 October 2016 wherein
detailed steps have been provided to be followed by a
taxpayer for furnishing their details.
Now, an update about the present taxes -
In Central Excise, it was held by Hon’ble CESTAT of
Mumbai that cenvat credit cannot be denied to the
assessee merely, on the ground that the dealer was non-
existent at the time of investigation.
In Customs, three additional stations/routes have been
specified for import and export of goods by land or
inland water ways.
Also, foreign currency exchange rates have been revised.
In Income-Tax , the Government has specified that
electronic mode is a valid mode of communication for
issuance of Form-2 under IDS. Further, it has been clarified that assessee cannot file
declaration under IDS for search and seizure conducted
after 01.06.2016 but before making of declaration
In Service Tax,
it has been held by CESTAT New Delhi
that if there is mutuality of interest between the
Association and its Members, then any service to
members by the Association is not a taxable service as
foundational facts of existence of two legal entities
(Service provider and service recipient) in such
transaction is missing.
The abovementioned notifications/circular and case laws
have been detailed further in the bulletin.
Just to reiterate that we remain available over a
telecom or e-mail.
Truly Yours
Timir Baran Chatterjee
M.Com, FCS, MBA (International Business)-IIFT, ACMA
Vivek Jalan
FCA, CIDT (ICAI), B. Com
Page 3 Tax Connect: 91st
Issue
23 Oct 2016 – 29 Oct 2016
SYNOPSIS
S. NO. TOPICS
PAGE
NO.
1] GODDS & SERVICE TAX 4
Analysis GST IMPACT ON HOTELS AND RESTAURANTS
2] TAX CALENDAR 5
a) SERVICE TAX 6
Case Laws If there is mutuality of interest between the Association and its Members, then any service to
members by the Association is not a taxable service as foundational facts of existence of two legal
entities (Service provider and service recipient) in such transaction is missing.
b) CENTRAL EXCISE 7
Case Laws The activity of packing refined edible oil received in tankers into small containe rs cannot be
treated as manufacturing activity.
Case Laws The cenvat credit cannot be denied to the assessee merely, on the ground that at the time of
investigation, the dealer was non-existent.
c) CUSTOMS 8
Notification/Circular Three additional stations/routes for import and export of goods by land or inl and water ways
Notification/Circular Fixation of TV of edible oil, brass, poppy seed, areca nut, gold and sliver
Notification/Circular Revision of exchange rate of foreign currencies into Rupee & vice versa
d) INCOME TAX 9
Notification/Circular Reconstruction or splitting up to be treated as demerger on fulfillment of specified conditions
Notification/Circular Special provisions for tax on distributed income of domestic company for buy-b ack of shares
Notification/Circular Electronic mode to be valid mode of communication for issuance of Form-2 und er IDS
Notification/Circular Search and seizure conducted after 01.06.2016 but before making of declaration under IDS:
Assessee cannot file declaration
4] STATE TAXES 10
Notification/Circular
Assam: Communication of provisional GST registration number (GSTIN) , Increase in rate of entry
tax on certain commodities
Bihar: Substitution of Form CH-I and insertion of FORM RT-IA, RT-IIIB for the registered developer,
who has opted to pay compounding tax
Haryana: Exempted 'technetium 99m generators' used in Diagnosis of cancer from VAT
5] IN STANDS - GST: MODEL LAW 2016 & BUSINESS PROCESSES : A TECHNICAL COMMENTARY 11
6] BOOK EXCLUSIVELY ON WORKS CONTRACT ( SERVICE TAX AND VAT)
12
Page 4 Tax Connect: 91st
Issue
23 Oct 2016 – 29 Oct 2016
GOODS & SERVICE TAX (GST)
GST IMPACT ON HOTELS AND RESTAURANTS
In the current tax regime multiple taxes in the form
of Service tax, VAT and luxury tax are levied on
hospitality and restaurant industry.
In restaurants, the taxes and service charges
(generally 10%) covers about one-third of our bill
amount. There is double taxation in the form of
VAT and Service Tax being levied on the same
transaction.
Most of the restaurants also charges service
charges which is generally 10% of the bill amount.
For example:
Food bill 4000
Service charge 10% 400
Taxable value for
service Tax (40%)
2400
Service Tax @14% 336
Swacch Bharat cess @
0.5%
12
KKC @0.5% 12
VAT (12.5%-14.5%) 580
Total taxes and
charges
1340
Effective tax rate 34%
The effective tax rate is even higher if there is
alcohol consumption which is subject to higher
VAT rates.
In hotels, rooms with tariff above Rs 1,000 attracts
service tax at 60% of room tariff (8.7%) and luxury
tax (8-12%).
GST which is expected to get capped at 18%-20%
shall have neutral impact on the hotel sector as
presently service tax payable by hotels is around
8.7% and luxury tax at around 8-12% (depending on
the state and type of service). Restaurants have to
pay service tax at around 5.6% and VAT at around
12%-14.5%.
However, under GST regime, the uniformity of tax
rates, better utilization of input credit, reduction in
double taxation, and benefits to end user in terms of
lower prices shall give a significant boost to the
hospitality and tourism industry. For global
competence, the tax rate must be maintained under
10% else, the industry shall continue to suffer due to
high taxation.
Page 5 Tax Connect: 91st
Issue
23 Oct 2016 – 29 Oct 2016
TAX CALENDAR
Due date COMPLIANCES FROM 23 rd
Oct , 2016 to
29 th
Oct, 2016
STATUTE
25th Oct, 2016 Filing of monthly/quarterly
VAT return
Delhi (Quarterly, if filed online)
Jharkhand (Monthly)
Issuance of WCT certificate West Bengal VAT Act (Monthly)
Mizoram VAT Act (Monthly)
28th Oct, 2016 Deposit of VAT of previous month Arunachal Pradesh VAT Act
Filing of monthly/quarterly/annual
VAT return
Arunachal Pradesh (Monthly, if annual turnover>Rs. 1
crore), Arunachal Pradesh (Quarterly, if annual
turnover