Dear friends,
Will self study be sufficient for clearing CA. Final at just one attempt? If Not, then in which subjects we should consult coaching institutes?
anubhuti srivastava
(CA-FINAL (NEW COURSE) STUDENT)
(24 Points)
Replied 08 October 2010
i think a teacher is required in every field for the guidance.so doin coaching is a better option to prepare for the exams. in CA-FINAL, coachings of accounts, mafa, direct & indirect tax and cost can be done and self study could be done for theory subjects.
sudhakar ca cwa
(service)
(1518 Points)
Replied 08 October 2010
teaching will helps in logical thinking helps in interpretation.
my opinion u can self study IDT DT ISCA AND AUDITING
accounts also no prob
but MAFA COSTING and Law coaching will helpful for good marks
Karan Thacker
(CA)
(117 Points)
Replied 08 October 2010
For every subject coaching is needed. Coaching from yourself only. You should become your own master and you should only be regular in your studies.....
Manoj jain
(Intern)
(535 Points)
Replied 08 October 2010
I think we can become a CA without any coaching
but from my view coaching is necessary because we cannot become an efficient CA through self study..
as our ultimate concept will not be in depth. it is only through that we can make our doubts clear...
C.A. Sanjay Bhatia
(CA)
(496 Points)
Replied 08 October 2010
SELF STUDY WILL DEFINATELY WORK . JUST FOLLOW THE BEST BOOKS IN EACH SUBJECT.
THESE BOOKS ARE WRITTEN IN THE MANNER AS IF TEACHER IS EXPLAINING TO YOU. YOU JUST HAVE TO THROUGHLY GO THROUGH THEM.
THE BOOKS ARE:
ACCOUNTS: D.S. RAWAT OR MP VIJAYKUMAR
MAFA: S.D. BALA
AUDIT : ICAI MODULE
LAW: MUNISH BHANDARI
COST: SAXENA & VASHISHT
DT: VINOD GUPTA
IDT : BANGAR'S
ICSA : ICAI MODULE
C.A. Sanjay Bhatia
(CA)
(496 Points)
Replied 08 October 2010
ICAI COMPILER CAN BE DONE ALONG WITH ABOVE MENTIONED BOOKS FOR BETTER PRACTICE.
DOING THIS YOU WILL SURELY CLEAR CA FINALS IN FIRST ATTEMPT WITH FLYING COLOURS.
BEST OF LUCK
Azim Khan ACA,CS,CMA*,LLB*
(Proprietor)
(1312 Points)
Replied 08 October 2010
agreed with sudhakar & others. self study really works.....
Bharath
(C.A,C.S)
(3983 Points)
Replied 08 October 2010
hey frnd,..RGRDING COACHING ONE POINTS TO SAY,..
EVEN IF U ATTEND THE BEST COACHING CLASSES ANYWHERE THE ULTIMATE THING IS THE AMOUNT OF EFORT U PUT WHILE READING OR SOLVING,..
COACHING JST SAVES U SOME TIME IN TERMS OF INTERPRETATION OF THE SUBJECTS AND ANY DOUBTS,...COACHING IS NOT A COMPULSION,...IF U FEEL THAT U CAN MANAGE THEN U CAN DO SELF STUDY,...
I JST ATTENTED COACHING FOR ACCOUNTS IN MY FINAL,..PREPARING ALL OTHER SUB ON MY OWN,.SO JST THINK AND DECIDE WHICH ONE TO JOIN AND WHICH ONE TO SELF STUDY DEPENDING ON UR CAPABILITIES,..
COZ SOME MAY B STRONG IN THEPRY SOME IN PRACTICLAS,...SO IT UPTO U TO RECIPROCATE AND MAKE A WISE DECISION,...
ALL THE BEST FOR UR CARRER,...
Gokul Viswanath Shenoy
(Company Secretary & Finance Manager)
(430 Points)
Replied 08 October 2010
well, even if u got a guide..ur performance depends on ur self study..guidance needed,but self study is more important
Himanshu Sharma
( CA FINAL STUDENT)
(66 Points)
Replied 08 October 2010
i think anubhuti is very right mohini , rest itis a matter of personal choice
CS Vijay Daxini
(At Practice)
(732 Points)
Replied 08 October 2010
i thinnk if u r determined then u can go for self study i have cleared whole c.s (final 1 grp. appearing in this december..)on self study basis...but first go through scanner and then have allok at study material reference books are available for each subjects u can buy it and preapre it u r self please note that analytical skills help u in u r self study...for any info u can revert back to me....yhanks and regards
CS.rahul gaba
(ca final student)
(61 Points)
Replied 09 October 2010
Well, its a tricky one.
I think coachings are really important. Although exams can be passed without coachings but one should know what are the probabilities keeping in mind their own strengths. I know that i have not taken coaching for CS final and cleared it with ease and tha too with a rank. But do i know a lot about CS subjects and all. the answer is no because i have not read things in depth at all. So ya its like running on a sword when u decide about going for coaching or not. My personal view is must for CA Final. rest falls on u.
Thanuks & regards
RG
Vidya
(ca final)
(56 Points)
Replied 09 October 2010
Hi Mohini....
You are getting advices left right center I see:-) So let me put in mine. Surely the books available in the market are fantastic. You surely can do self study. No 2 ways about it....
BUT.....
-->When you sit with a problem in MAFA, you will have to break ur head in solving it. Where as when you go to a class, it will be served to you on a silver platter.
-->Some body has already done all the home work of going through the scanner and given you (in certain subject books) what is important etc etc...
-->when some one in the class asks a doubt you will realise that there are different ways of looking at the a particular topic:-) which trust me on this one, helped me for my final. When a question on accounting standard was asked, i remembered this doubt which was asked in class. That helped me solve the problem.
-->when you see ur co-students studying you will be motivated to study.
I can go on and on but I will stop with one more point..
--> you will enjoy the subjects, have fun and make new friends:-)
All the very best dear...
Goog luck:-)
GSTR 9 and 9C for FY 23-24 as amended by Notification 12/2024 dated 10th July 2024(with recording)
CAclubindia
