BALASUBRAMANYA B N
(CCI STUDENT....)
(44679 Points)
HELLO PEOPLE
IIM vs ICAI
WHAT YOU THINK OF IIM AND ICAI ITS IN SAME POSITION OR ITS GONE OF IIM OR STILL NOT YET REACHED IIM LEVEL.
WHAT YOU THINK PEOPLE...LEAVE YOUR COMMENTS HERE..LETS SEE HOW YOU THINK OF THIS....
HARISHANKAR SHAHI
(student)
(161 Points)
Replied 24 February 2009
i think IIM have more charm than and salary package also
Nikhil Devnani
(Article)
(29 Points)
Replied 25 February 2009
i think both have the same position. the only difference is that its easy to get an admission in ICAI, but difficult to pass out from ICAI, however its difficult to get an admission in IIM and easy to pass out from it.
Mayank kharbanda
(Risk Advisory Services)
(409 Points)
Replied 25 February 2009
IIM IS WAY 2 FAR AHEAD THAN ICAI...........IN TERMS OF EVERYTHING............
Satya Narayan
(asdsad)
(176 Points)
Replied 26 February 2009
|
Just see the output of best CA firm (pWC) and you do the math . How much should be paid for putting a rubber stamped signature on BS ( BullS***t ) . Never ever dare comparing CA with IIMs . ICAI never believed in all round development of it's student for CEO jobs. They train you for back office accounting jobs . Having said that there are CAs who are earning much more then IIMs folks. But on average IIMs will always get more for their all round exposure. SN
Originally posted by :Balasubramanya |
||
| " | HELLO PEOPLE IIM vs ICAI WHAT YOU THINK OF IIM AND ICAI ITS IN SAME POSITION OR ITS GONE OF IIM OR STILL NOT YET REACHED IIM LEVEL. WHAT YOU THINK PEOPLE...LEAVE YOUR COMMENTS HERE..LETS SEE HOW YOU THINK OF THIS.... |
" |
Krunal Raichura
(Financial Advisory)
(2134 Points)
Replied 26 February 2009
The attention of the crowd is caught by the most good looking girl, or say towards someone with minimum clothing, or fashionable clothing. When we go in some shop, our attention is caught by the item which is most well presented.
In the first case, please note that this girl may not be the best person. She may not be good by heart, she may not be intelligent, she maybe good at nothing except for her looks. In second case, that item in the shop may not be the best one, nor the cost benficial one. It may be the worst thing kept there decorated because it is not getting sold. In both the cases, the reaming ones are untouched, no one even bothers to look at them. There may still be some smart guys who would make an attempt to find out the qualities. No one has the time and interest to do it generally.
Thats exactly the case with Jobs. The people who are the most well presented, have good interpersonal and presentation skills and a charismatic personality catch the attention of recruiters and then their seniors. These guys may not be the most effecient ones nor they maybe the good at anything.
I attribute the above to CA vs MBA. Personal Branding is essenital for all. (See my blog on Caclub or krunal-raichura.blogspot.com to know more on Personal Branding. Criticisms/Suggestions are welcome).
As far as earning is concerned, we even have people who have never attended colleges, who have dropped out and today are in top 10, 50, 100 of forbes list of richest people in the world.
Santhosh Poojary
(SIEMPRE AHÍ PARA TI)
(15607 Points)
Replied 26 February 2009
IIM AND CA'S ARE TWO FACE OF ONE COIN.. WITHOUT SUPPORT OF WHICH ANY COMPANY OR ORGANISATION CANNOT RUN.................. WHEN U R COMPARING WITH KNOWLEDGE CA'S ARE FAR AHEAD FROM MBA'S..............
AND WHEN IT COMES TO EARNING THERE ARE MANY CA'S EARNING MORE THAN MBA'S .......................
SO NO COMPARISION....................
Sumit Jain
(CA)
(4760 Points)
Replied 27 February 2009
no
ca's are still behind
but as per current scenario
ca are more safer
AMIT GUPTA
(CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT)
(70 Points)
Replied 27 February 2009
well.in my books.there is no use comparing both.,.,.coz ca is a professional degree which it a statement in itself...n mba be it from iim or any other plc is post grad. diploma or degree....welll...i dnt think less of any of the two n plan to do both if things go in favour.,.,.well...some 1 very rightly said tht institute never paid attention to the grooming and pr skills of budding cas....but now they hv realised the importance of the packaging of a professinal n his grooming in many respects(communication n presentation) and hv started off with the gmcs couse a 3 mnth thing.,.,.so well...the initial question.,.maybe cas dnt get the much much hyped abt packages offered to iim mbas...but in the long run.,.comparing the cost to return or yeild in both...ca course turns out to b very reasonable...n gives a gud firm stand in the world..sorry for the long ccrap.,.but bhavnaon mein beh gaya...
Sushant Singh
(Student)
(208 Points)
Replied 11 March 2009
I think CA course is far far good then MBA course.
The only thing which is lacking is focus on grooming PERSONALITY DEVELOPMENT of CA s.
You can easily spot the difference between a CA student & MBA Student in terms of personality development.
But as you know CA's have more deeper knowledge then MBA students , the only cause why recruiting companies attracts towards MBA students is coz.... because of their overall personality development.
ICAI has realized the importance of personality development that's why they have started Residential programme & GMCS programme.
But , i want to ask that is it really effective because i have listen that this course is not taken seriously not only by students but also teachers.
CA Ankur Mittal
(Assistant Manager @ Reliance Communication)
(759 Points)
Replied 11 March 2009
| Originally posted by :Krunal Raichura | ||
| " | The attention of the crowd is caught by the most good looking girl, or say towards someone with minimum clothing, or fashionable clothing. When we go in some shop, our attention is caught by the item which is most well presented. In the first case, please note that this girl may not be the best person. She may not be good by heart, she may not be intelligent, she maybe good at nothing except for her looks. In second case, that item in the shop may not be the best one, nor the cost benficial one. It may be the worst thing kept there decorated because it is not getting sold. In both the cases, the reaming ones are untouched, no one even bothers to look at them. There may still be some smart guys who would make an attempt to find out the qualities. No one has the time and interest to do it generally. Thats exactly the case with Jobs. The people who are the most well presented, have good interpersonal and presentation skills and a charismatic personality catch the attention of recruiters and then their seniors. These guys may not be the most effecient ones nor they maybe the good at anything. I attribute the above to CA vs MBA. Personal Branding is essenital for all. ). As far as earning is concerned, we even have people who have never attended colleges, who have dropped out and today are in top 10, 50, 100 of forbes list of richest people in the world. |
" |
Krunal Very Well Presented !!! Comparison..Hats Off to you
Aarti
(abc)
(64 Points)
Replied 10 December 2009
Sorry to disappoint you...For knowing the answer pls. meet 3 CAs and 3 IIMs yourself. CAs don't have the attitude, th course is about EXAMS only while IIM gives more exposure to practical areas.
So the diff. is not just personal grooming, if it were so long back CAs would dress up well and all that 'nakhra'. Friend, it is the attitude at B schools which makes them premium material. U can feel an MBA when he walks into a room but sorry you cannot generally find much difference between a CA and a 12th pass clerk in govt. office [of course a CA would look more serious and sad compared to the clerk ;) ] . The objectives of both the courses are different though they are portrayed to be similar. Industry prefers the one who can do things and not the one who just obeys orders.
For doubts meet a few of both and speak for just 5 mins and u will understand the difference.
seeker
(JUNIOR OFFICER)
(227 Points)
Replied 08 June 2010
IIM’s students are recruited from cream of various fields like Engineering, Doctors, C.A’s, Some students already have 1-7 years industry Experience.
Majority have elite schooling and have been trained to be expressive, confident even before joining IIM’s. They already have a attitude. They represent Modern, Young , Urban India.
During M.B.A they are trained to lead the People in organization. Their courses are designed as per industry needs, are updated continously, Industry leaders regularly visits at IIM’S as guest faculty,
It is most difficult to get into IIM’s, They are groomed be a manager in a organization. Since they are to lead the team, to take decision in crisis situation, to formulate organization’s policy in respone to Business environments , They are paid havily, They are organization’s vital organ similar to be called as Brain in human Body.
Now coming to second diffcult profession after medical in
But what is the need for C.A is to compare with I.I.M’s, Their fields are separate. M.B.A’s Give a kick start to any Carrer, so as happens with an Engineer, Doctor or any profession.
But why C.A are so paranoid about IIM’s. What is need to compare them selves with them. Perhaps there is competition in Corporate Sector with M.B.A where C.A are supposed to do Lion’s Walk in domain of finance are looking fearful by walk of a polished quick fix lion look alike Fox.
Do every C.A need to do M.B.A Like every M.B.B.S does M.D for Specialization to be successfull, It is true that it is era of specialization.
Then What is objective of C.A is to practice or to serve industry , I think it is to do indepenent practice their course is designed on these lines. But there are not enough oppertunities
In corporate Sector M.B.A are superior to C.A Where knowledge is only one of many other criterias for success.
C.A can catch up with M.B.A easily as it is not difficult to polish your self , the only thing needed is drastic change in curriculum.
C.A who wants to go to Coorporate can have separate curriculum for Industry in their Final with less statuary Powers and C.A who want to be Lion or with power of cerification ( I mean into practice ) should go into hard core study in their final
Oppertunities are immense only thing require is Positive attitude. We have real substance only some polishing can make us recognized at par with best.
It is more difficult to acquire knowledge compare to acquire the ability to show knowledge. A flower does not need dressing, Smells automatically comes out from it.
Finally C.A are far better than M.B.A’s , they are not supposed to be corporate slaves. They are independent, knowledgable and Hard worker.
CAclubindia
