CA Abdul Halim Siddiqui (Partner) (481 Points)
30 March 2009WHY THERE IS NO MOU BETWEEN ICAI & ( ICSI , ICWAI). IN MY OPINION ICAI BELIEVE IN FULL DETERMINATION & THERE IS NO SHORT CUT SUCCESS.
SHORT CUT TO SUCCESS IN A WAY BY CLAIMING EXEMPTION IN SOME SUBJECT . ON THE OTHER HAND , ICWAI PROVIDE TO ICSI MEMBERS & VICE VERSA.
EXPRESS YOUR VIEWS!!!
CMA KNVV Sri Vidya - Sri Kanth
(C.A.Final (New) ICWAI FINAL (New))
(11269 Points)
Replied 30 March 2009
YA its true
i agree with you
there should be some exemption in the papers of ICSI n ICWAI for a student who study ICAI
i really pity for this
Sumit Jain
(CA)
(4760 Points)
Replied 30 March 2009
| Originally posted by :halim siddiqui | ||
| " | WHY THERE IS NO MOU BETWEEN ICAI & ( ICSI , ICWAI). IN MY OPINION ICAI BELIEVE IN FULL DETERMINATION & THERE IS NO SHORT CUT SUCCESS. SHORT CUT TO SUCCESS IN A WAY BY CLAIMING EXEMPTION IN SOME SUBJECT . ON THE OTHER HAND , ICWAI PROVIDE TO ICSI MEMBERS & VICE VERSA. EXPRESS YOUR VIEWS!!! |
" |
i also agree
Prodyut Banerjee
(Advocate)
(309 Points)
Replied 01 April 2009
WHY THERE IS NO MOU BETWEEN ICAI & ( ICSI , ICWAI). IN MY OPINION ICAI BELIEVE IN FULL DETERMINATION & THERE IS NO SHORT CUT SUCCESS.
SHORT CUT TO SUCCESS IN A WAY BY CLAIMING EXEMPTION IN SOME SUBJECT . !!!!!!!!!!
WHAT A JOKE. THATS WHY THERE IS MOU BETWEEN ICAI AND CPA- AUSTRALIA / ICAEW (SHORT CUT!!!!!!!!)
Ashish
(Stock Market Professional)
(77 Points)
Replied 17 June 2009
Mr Halim
Success will not come from repetitive study of the same thing. Actually ICSI & ICWAI both know this fact so they made MOU not as you like think.
And again for your kind information ICSI has lowest passing percentage compare to each other institute.
And even if you think so then tell me the objectives behind CA & CPA mou. At a glance both have different audit ,methodology , different accounting standards, US has different regulation. Whether ICAI thought that they CPAs are better that Indian CAs. and by this MOU ICAI will be benefited.
And again ICSI & ICWAI both belive to focus on new things and subject not on a single thing again & again. Be assure. before makin anywrong expression of such kind
Franklin George
(Finance Manager)
(31 Points)
Replied 05 May 2016
ICAI has tie-ups with many outside India & in India.
But for co-professional courses there aint no exemption, like for CS & ICWA.
The theme is the same for many subjects, yet to do it again if you are a CA or partly CA.
The idea behind exemption is that one institution accepts the quality & level of exams done by other.
But why doesnt ICAI accept it and no other insitute accept ICAI (i mean ICSI or ICWAI).
If there is a good moto behind it, i would like to know.
CAclubindia
