What level of professionalism our very own institute follows

Final 642 views 2 replies

Anubhav Jain

CA Practice

31 Points Joined January 2014

Hi Friends

I am very sorry for the subject which I chose for posting this message, but I really mean it.

Hi I am CA Anubhav Jain ,

I would like to draw you attention to the working (Evaluating Exam Papers)of our esteemed Institute , which ruins the life of a prospective candidate enrolled for being a Chartered Accountant.

Students enter this field hoping for a bright future at a tender age, but every body of us knows what is the plight of students during and after becoming a Qualified Professional.

This time I experienced it my self when my brother SAMBHAV JAIN , a meritorious student from the very beginning,

Student of DPS R.K.Puram

Graduate From Sri Ram College Of Arts And Commerce

Trained from Ernst And Young

has to go through this phase in life, which people of our society call as his BAD LUCK.

He got exemption (above 65%) in SEVEN out of eight subjects but got just 22% in the eighth paper , in which he scored 78% in his IPCC (Inter ) examination.

My problem is that , people call it happened due to his BAD LUCK!!

My problem is how can a student scoring 78% in inter in same subject + more than 65 in all the rest of the papers in final get only 22% in ISCA paper.

A doubt which comes to my mind is that, whether our esteemed Institute's result depend on LUCK ?

If yes- then what sort of Professionalism are we talking about?

If no- then how can a student of such calibre, get just this much when he got 78% in the very same Exam at the Inter level plus he got above average score in the rest of the seven papers ?

Dear Friends, It is high time now, that we should get over this LUCK thing. We work hard and be rewarded accordingly and our future should not depend on the results based on the LUCK. This just ruins ones life.

Kindly support ,if like my view as we need to send a strong message to our esteemed Intitute.

This time we experienced thousands of students getting marks in the range of 20-30% in ISCA. Why is it so?

Are we not competent enough to understand this subject? Or does institute consider Accountancy/Auditing/Law/Taxation above this subject?

Friends something seriously is wrong and strong message need to be send .

Support me, Support my fellow brothers who are in the process of becoming a professional, so that they do not face this problem as Sambhav is facing.

Thanks a Lot.

Anubhav Jain

9868729930(For any views do contact)

anubhavjain176 @ gmail.com

Replies (2)

Guest

I very much support you .I am also a final student . In ISCA twice I got around 30 marks and third time I got '0' . Any person after clearing PE 2 even if not prepared for the exam given a paper can't they score a single digit mark unless they didn't attempt to answer ? . I wrote 30+ sheets for that answer sheet . They have just striked all the pages. I was completely devasted and colud not touch the book for next 6 mths. It took me nearly 7-8 mths to comeout of that shock . I was also an average student and scored a university rank in B.com and completed PG Diploma in Computer applications. Have I got 40 mks I would have cleared that group. We approached many people in ICAI who expressed that definetely this is unacceptable. But they can't help as there is no reevaluation .But they told me to take judicial route. But who has the time and energy to fight and get the justice?? .

KARTIK

JOB

240 Points Joined December 2008

I agree with your views first of all, i took 6 attempts to clear my ca final..But I cleared my cs and cwa in one shot i was a merit holder for cwa finals, still i struggled for ca costing many times, that subject was a nightmare for me. i used to flunk in this paper.

Imagine the situation of a cwa merit holder struggling for ca costing.

i qualified in november 2010. But after that the results were very liberal, many people who dont deserve to pass where passing out.

The paypackages reduced drastically, many of my friends after qualifying were working for salary as low as 10,000 per month in ca firms.

It is so strange to see that we after qualifying with lot of struggles and the new era passing out so easily and as a result the prestige of our profession was getting down

i agree that results shouldnt be based on luck but icai also shud not pass out people like mba and bcom grads.

coz we earned this title with lots of hardwork, failures and dedication

CA.KARTIK