Sumit (PR) (336 Points)
11 September 2010What can be intention of ICAI by Re-Allowing choice in exam?
i mean first they disallow and then again grant choice. is this a course of action taken after president's message that only so no. of students passed and a Co's leading Director & Central council member reccomendation that upto 2020 we need 20 LAKH CA's and 60 years down the line we aren't even 2 LAKH?
What do our Experts make out of this Action of institute? Will it be a bit liberal if not much??
Akhilesh
(Trainee)
(43 Points)
Replied 11 September 2010
1) I think past 2 exam results which are of single digit, ALL TIME LOW -3/6/9% etc.
2) Also it was highly injustice when they removed options for the first time in NOV-09 exam
3) They might have received criticism from students/Govt. (As ICAI is governed by Govt they are answerable to our Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA)
Anyways, its a welcome change from ICAI. Now I think they should bring more transparency in exam results tooo.....
bharat
(a)
(153 Points)
Replied 11 September 2010
CA Harish Suwalka
(Chartered Accountant ( Bhilwara ))
(4125 Points)
Replied 11 September 2010
agree with akhil
too low results may be the reason for this change...but really a pleasant surprise by icai
chandar
(Deputy Manager-Accounts)
(296 Points)
Replied 11 September 2010
inki chaal hai ye result low declare karenge aur bolenge ki humne toh is baar choice bhi di thi fir bhi students nahi kar paye........
tum log ye sab choddo aur ye kosish karo ki ye kitna bhi tough bana le tab bhi pass to inhe karna hi padega . you make yourself stable in the list of pass students.
Akash Pincha
(CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT)
(188 Points)
Replied 11 September 2010
I think that there will not be any choice question in the examination, as in the anouncement have you noticed that it is not been signed by any of the official..........From this type of announcement they are trying to test the student mentally also in the examination as they often do with such types of announcement before the exam..............So, guys from my point of view dont trust this notification..... i.e. dont change your strategic plans for preparation............if in the exams there are choice question its good.......... but as a student we should not believe in this type of notification........as insti donot hv good past track record.....
BEST OF LUCK FOR THE EXAMS.........
Akhilesh
(Trainee)
(43 Points)
Replied 11 September 2010
I think Akash may be right.....This might be the trap of ICAI .....They did this before also at the time of MAY-10 Final (New) exam where similar kind of notification was issued regarding AS-30/31 that students will not be tasted on practical problems of the same AS. However, In exam , we got such questions. This is rediculous if they are intentionally doing such cheap things.....
Martianman
(student)
(115 Points)
Replied 12 September 2010
agree.no point wasting time studyin such notfctns.wont make much diff n the final outcome.so get ready for war.nothing else
CA Manish K Dhoot
(CA, B. Com, NCFM, CPCM)
(5015 Points)
Replied 12 September 2010
There is some problem...
If ICAI Says there will be no choice, then students panic and blame ICAI.
If ICAI says there will be choice, then students again panic and blame ICAI and think there is some doubt in announcement.
You must be happy from this announcement.
jose.p
(CA in service)
(1676 Points)
Replied 12 September 2010
Rahul Agarwal
(Future CA)
(217 Points)
Replied 14 September 2010
The Insti is trying to lure students by sumthing new this time.
Tadpa Tadpa ke marenge!!!!!!!
CMA chaitanya
(AICWA,(CA))
(29 Points)
Replied 14 September 2010
sorry friends
we are dolls because we are in the hands of great insutitue called ca
"BOSS IS ALWAYS RIGHT"
we are very unlucky fellows until clear
CA Mohit Thareja
(Assistant Manager-Accounts & Finance)
(1117 Points)
Replied 14 September 2010
| Originally posted by : Sumit | ||
 |
What can be intention of ICAI by Re-Allowing choice in exam? i mean first they disallow and then again grant choice. is this a course of action taken after president's message that only so no. of students passed and a Co's leading Director & Central council member reccomendation that upto 2020 we need 20 LAKH CA's and 60 years down the line we aren't even 2 LAKH? What do our Experts make out of this Action of institute? Will it be a bit liberal if not much?? |
 |
hey sumit
plsss provide me the source from where did u got the reccomendation abt. need of 2o lakhs C.As !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Princes
(CA Final)
(243 Points)
Replied 15 September 2010
Hamare CA student ka mentality dekho
kabhi bhi khush nahi rehne bala hai.
Nahi choice to problem
Choice diya to tarah tarah ki comment
Be happy don't worry. jo mila, khushi khushi swikar karo
Ankit Jain
(Article (Final))
(110 Points)
Replied 15 September 2010
| Originally posted by : chandar | ||
|
|
inki chaal hai ye result low declare karenge aur bolenge ki humne toh is baar choice bhi di thi fir bhi students nahi kar paye........ tum log ye sab choddo aur ye kosish karo ki ye kitna bhi tough bana le tab bhi pass to inhe karna hi padega . you make yourself stable in the list of pass students. |
|
CAclubindia
