Chartered Accountant
86505 Points
Joined April 2011
Excel is never been a good suggestion for accounting pupose.
CFO- at NHTF
58280 Points
Joined August 2012
For small businesses who choose for 44AD/44ADA , voucher maintenance is not required.
Just invoices data is sufficient and which can be maintained in electronic form
GST Practitioner & Accounts
15056 Points
Joined March 2014
If you see ITR4, information like , Sundry creditors, sundry debtors, inventory, and Cash and equivalent are mandatory . (In Shedule Business and profession E15, E19,E20,E22) .
CFO- at NHTF
58280 Points
Joined August 2012
Outstandings can be traced from ledger in excel i
Chartered Accountant
86505 Points
Joined April 2011
Not possible for calculating every ledger and details through excel
CFO- at NHTF
58280 Points
Joined August 2012
For 44ADA cases excel is sufficient
Chartered Accountant
86505 Points
Joined April 2011
Not at all
GST Practitioner & Accounts
15056 Points
Joined March 2014
Ok,but what about Cash and equivalent ( Cash transactions) are also mandatory in ITR4 . You have to maintain Vouchers.
CFO- at NHTF
58280 Points
Joined August 2012
Bank Balance can be obtained from Bank Statement and which is available in electronic mode and pdf can be downloaded.
Cash Book in excel is available
Chartered Accountant
86505 Points
Joined April 2011
When nothing can be maintained in Excel then how cash book will be available in Excel. I suggest you to make accounting in Tally 7.2
CFO- at NHTF
58280 Points
Joined August 2012
For ITR-4 Tally is not required
Chartered Accountant
86505 Points
Joined April 2011
Depends on no. of transactions.
CFO- at NHTF
58280 Points
Joined August 2012
Number of transactions are irrelevant when 44AD/44ADA is applicable
Chartered Accountant
86505 Points
Joined April 2011
But accounting depends on number of transactions.
CFO- at NHTF
58280 Points
Joined August 2012
44AD/ 44ADA doesn't require accounts.Will number of transactions has relevance?