Unfair system of icai? Result Mismatch

Final 1490 views 12 replies

Its a serious injustice done with the students, who really put on so much hard work for 6 months....two of my friends cleared first grp in the initial list and later on they were declared failed...we all are aware about the system of gracing of marks, but that is done before declaring the result...this list was a gazette list initially declared at 2 pm....which was later modified declaring them to be failed, really unfair on part of those pass students, and institute should be answerable

 

Replies (12)
@ pallavi jain- I don't think icai did slashing of marks bcoz slashing is not done at the last moment. Icai clarified that it was an error on their part. One of my frnd whose name was their on the first list but removed from second was failing in 2 subjects.
Normally if slashing or gracing is done, it is done only in one subject of the group.

my frnd has passed in all the subjects...he did not pass bcoz of aggregate

I know lot of people could not clear bcoz of the aggregate.
My point is that If only in one case - person who is failing 2 subjects is having his name in first list as passed, then for sure it is an error.
If slashing is done it is done for everybody.
Tell ur frnd this case and make him understand the situation.

what i am saying is that we all are aware about this gracing and slashing system nd dat is done with everybody....here the point is not this....the point is once you have declared the final result then how can it be changed....watver is to be done should be done before declaring the result and not after

Yes, at this point I agree with u. I hope this type of situation does not arise in future.

has anybody filed writ petition ?

Himanshu plz go through ca sunil maggo sir YouTube video... Who raise voice against this manipulation in ca final results... Initially 24000 students passed later they reduced it to 19000....u can easily find it on YouTube or share ur mailid i will send... Almost 700 students file writ petition... But nothing gonna happen
So start ur preparation and try ur luck in next attempt

We are taught Internal Controls and other due diligence standards in CA course. But Isn't it responsibility of the Institute to follow same quality standards in their operations (especially in sensitive matters such as results of students) 

Hahha.... Ye sab to bus kahne ki baate hai๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚in some attempt they ask so simple questions and give more results and in some attampts they give out of course questions paper and give results in single digit... They don't maintain their consistency and no discrimination towards each students.... U can't fight with system especially in India... Just try ur luck and get ur degree and be quiet... That is being taught
So don't mugg up ur mind in all these things... Just do ur study once again and better luck next time... Nothing gonna change... Bcz there is no unity in CA students.... Sabko apni padi nahi.... Nahi to sab mil ke protest karo... Then everything is possible
Nahi to articleship me hi itni exploitation nai hoti baccho ke... Agar sab me unity ho to... One ca final student in Hyderabad commit suicide due to intolerance level of his principal.... He is from poor family.... What is happening with his parents after that


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register