Ajay Kumar
(C.A. Final)
(27 Points)
Replied 11 November 2014
CS Dhruv Swami
(Student)
(157 Points)
Replied 11 November 2014
deepansh chawla
(CA FINALIST)
(180 Points)
Replied 11 November 2014
FOR ques 1(A) Apply AS 10 , WHICH STATES THAT DETENTION EXPENSES CANT BE CAPITALISED .
Tejas Satish Mirashi
(Article Clerk / Audit Assisstant)
(42 Points)
Replied 11 November 2014
Anubhuti Bhawsar
(ca final student)
(120 Points)
Replied 11 November 2014
dharmendra kumawat
(CA)
(72 Points)
Replied 11 November 2014
RAHUL AGARWAL
(Chartered Accountant)
(47 Points)
Replied 12 November 2014
PSPSPS
(Practicing)
(1344 Points)
Replied 12 November 2014
AUDIT PAPER ANALYSED & ANSWERED
Question 1 –
(a) AS 10 – Answer – Cannot be capitalized
(b) SA 500 & 501 – Question not on External Confirmations but on relying on Sufficient appropriate audit evidences and management representation. Auditor – Guilty
(c) SA 450 – Uncorrected Material Misstatement – Direct Question
(d) SA 250 – Responsibility on compliance with laws and regulations – Direct Question
Question 2 –
(a) Risk Assessment and Response to the assessed risk – SA 315 & 330 (also covered in SA 240 Frauds)
(b) Audit of CIS environment – SA 315
(c) SA 330 – Selection of Samples (Random, Haphazard, Systematic…)
(d) SA 300 – Audit Planning with risk assessment at assertion level
Question 3
(a) CARO – It is not a due just a show cause notice hence not to be reported as a statutory dues
(b) SA 510 - Opening Balance – Initial Engagements, with last year report being qualified, auditor to report in case of company not making a rectification
(c) SA 240 – Resignation of auditor due to limitation imposed by management, auditor to communicate to mgt, TCWG, if required to shareholders and regulatory bodies.
(d) SA 230 – Documentation and Guidance Note on Other seeking access to working papers – Auditor can refuse except if it is a legal requirement
Question 4
(a) CARO Applicability – Not applicable
(b) SA 4410 – Compilation of Financial Statements – Auditor cannot accept management view as identified misstatements to be reported even in case of compilation arrangements
(c) CARO – Default in repayment of dues to FI – Auditor to report alongwith a disclosure that it has been settled after the BS date
(d) SA 550 – Related parties – Transaction prima facie having risk of misstatement auditor to extend procedures…direct question
Question 5
(a) Tax Audit – Payments beyond 20000
(b) Insurance company audit – Verification of Outstanding claims…direct question…include how to check and disclosure requirements
(c) SA 260 & SA 700 - Reporting to SH and TCWG
(d) SA 705 & 706 – Qualification and Matter of Emphasis
Question 6
(a) CA Not guilty under Clause 4 of Part I of Schedule II (NO opinion hence substantial interest not relevant)
(b) CA Guilty – Confidentiality Clause 1 of Part I of Schedule II
(c) CA Guilty – Misappropriation of clients money & not keeping in separate bank account – Clause 10, Part I, Schedule II
(d) CA not guilty – Clause 1, Part II, Schedule II. Loan from article / relative prohibited but no prohibition to accept loan from company where article father is MD
Question 6
(a) Stock Brokers – Circuit Filters..Direct question
(b) Restriction of Shareholding in Cooperative society – maximum 1/5th or 1000 Rs by one member
(c) SA 210 – Acceptance of Audit Engagement – Checking Client Integrity before acceptance of audit (KYC)
(d) AS 26
(e) Cost audit short note – direct questions
Pooja
(articled assistant)
(25 Points)
Replied 12 November 2014
ANKIT MAHESHWARI
(ASSISTANT MANAGER )
(58 Points)
Replied 12 November 2014
shilpa_doll16@yahoo.com
(shilpa_doll16@yahoo.com)
(35 Points)
Replied 12 November 2014
Minakshi
(non working)
(57 Points)
Replied 12 November 2014