RAJEEV VERMA (ARTICLE ASSISSTANT) (79 Points)
12 April 2010
Please note that as per Sanjay sir, we are supposed to learn both test of hypothesis & time series forecasting for even old course. It is part of old course as well. So old course friends please prepare it for exams.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WmDAVrHMP7g
This is wrong and misleadign info...sanjay agarwall is wrong.he maybe a great teacher but icai.org decides the syllabus and what comes.icai clarified that time series and test of hypothesis cioming in the rtp was a mistake...please clarify with icai before passing such statements....
toime seeries and test of hypothesis is not there for old syllabus.
the syllabus as per icai is: https://www.icai.org/post.html?post_id=926
the syllabus as per sanjay agarwall for old syllabus includes time series and test of hypothesis(he said that because he saw the rtp and thought that they included it for old syllabus also...)...so students who want to follow sanjay can...i think a gud student wud follow what icai says!
Rahul Chakraborty
(Articled Assistant)
(21 Points)
Replied 12 April 2010
Time series and testing of hypothesis is applicable only for CA Final (New) Course.
RAJEEV VERMA
(ARTICLE ASSISSTANT)
(79 Points)
Replied 13 April 2010
Veerji, I am not able to find any clarification from ICAI on this issue. So I think, there no question you can ask upon words of Sanjay sir. To substantiate it, you yourself are saying that RTP of old course has provided questions on these chapters.
I think, you have seen that mail of Parag sir & are thinking this because of that mail only. We must not forgot that experience of Sanjay sir is far more than any of us (including Parag Sir). Sorry, I am not saying anything against Parag Sir.
I don't think any of us can doubt about knowledge of Sanjay sir (unless you take a clarification on this issue from ICAI).
I have listened several negative feedbacks about Sanjay sir but will not believe them until I see a clarification from ICAI, which I think we will ever recieve.
SACHIN GROVER
(CA STUDENT)
(102 Points)
Replied 20 April 2010
Rajeev, Sanjay Aggarwal might be good but is not god. Actually problem is with students like you who blindly starts having faith on teachers who have mass no. of students. Large no. of students never means that teacher is knowledgable or good in quality. Good example for same is Makkar sir for MAFA. He has several students but no students praises him for his teaching skills, same is case of Sanjay Aggarwal, he might have large no. of students but it don't mean that he is knowledgable. Among so many students, I rarely finds students who are real praiser of him.
Every of my friend who has taken class from sanjay aggarwal, told me that he is still confused about what over actual course is and what is the difference between new course and old course. One example is quoted by you only.
You have said you need to ICAI's clarification, to prove sanjay aggarwal as wrong. Just read the desired clarification & show it also to Sanjay aggarwal.
|
Revision Test Paper – May 2010 : Paper 5 : Cost Management ( Final Old) - (20-04-2010)
|
||||
|
CAclubindia
