Go Ad-Free on CAclubindia with Daily Mobile Updates. Subscribe Now!

THE GREAT ADMIN OF CACLUBINDIA

CA PRIKSHIT WADHWA (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (339 Points)

13 August 2008

Dear All,

I want to share my experience with you all about this website and its great Admin. I submitted news on this site for two times and every time I receive a message, that the same will be displayed on approval. And you folks know what, Each Time the news was approved and displayed. Great Na?????? But the news was said to be submitted by ADmin itself.

Excellent Admin, Good Job. News submitted by me and displayed to be of yours. Atleast points should also be given to the members who submiited the news before the same was displayed.

In fact I was mistaken that the website is being hosted by some handful of educated persons.

I would prefer that victims like me should also raise their voice and stop such malpractice on site.

Reply
Follow
Share

14 Replies

Admin (CCI Team) (12885 Points)
Replied 13 August 2008

Kindly send details of the news submitted by you. As certain news if not posted properly are rectified and the id is assigned to admin automatically.

The technical team would look further into the matter

Regards
ADmin

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA PRIKSHIT WADHWA (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (339 Points)
Replied 13 August 2008

Sir,

The news Procedure for filing TDS returns with insufficient deductee PAN was submitted by me.

Regards

Priksh*t Wadhwa

CA Nallathambi Srinivasan (Audit Team Member) (1584 Points)
Replied 13 August 2008

I also face the same problem but in Web Directory. I have submitted Three Web Links but it is not updated in Web Directory.

For Bank With BSR Codes

For Online Tax Refund Status

For ESI Hospitals & Branches

Aisha (Finance Professional) (8099 Points)
Replied 13 August 2008

I hve been a member of the website for the last 1 year now... but i hve not faced ne such biasness from the ADMIN.. We all need to understand tat the ADMIN has to be extra careful while approving news as it effects other membersss...

(Guest)

its all peace now .....

Income Tax : Procedure for filing TDS returns with insufficient deductee PAN
Posted on : 13 August 2008 by CA PRIKSHIT WADHWA [ Scorecard : 211]

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA CS CIMA Prakash Somani (Landmark Group) (23502 Points)
Replied 15 September 2008

I also didn't face this problem since my joining even Admin has done his and/or her job very well. I got prompt replies of all my suggestions, opinions etc.

:)cheers:)

Rushikesh (Chartered Accountant - Manager Finance) (2375 Points)
Replied 15 September 2008

This site though mainatined by Admin, is for all of us..

We all are benefitted from it... Well, though Admin needs to be careful, there are cases when there may be some lapses.." to err is human"

No one is talking about the benefits received...If we all are benefitted say, 80%, then why brood over remaning 20%...well, try to talk to Admin, and get it resolved!!!

I would request all to take it up with Admin through private message to the Admin, then post it here, if the issue persists..!!!

If you all are not aware, there is a way how we can send Private Messages to the memebers..

CA CS CIMA Prakash Somani (Landmark Group) (23502 Points)
Replied 15 September 2008

It has been resolved and Admin has already provide the reason for this mistake.

:)cheers:)

CA PRIKSHIT WADHWA (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (339 Points)
Replied 17 September 2008

if the admin is not in a position to maintain this site error free then such site shouls be closed or Rushikesh, you should alongwith your so called, 80% benefitted visitors should help the Admin

Originally posted by :Rushikesh
"	This site though mainatined by Admin, is for all of us.. We all are benefitted from it... Well, though Admin needs to be careful, there are cases when there may be some lapses.." to err is human" No one is talking about the benefits received...If we all are benefitted say, 80%, then why brood over remaning 20%...well, try to talk to Admin, and get it resolved!!! I would request all to take it up with Admin through private message to the Admin, then post it here, if the issue persists..!!! If you all are not aware, there is a way how we can send Private Messages to the memebers..	"

Rushikesh (Chartered Accountant - Manager Finance) (2375 Points)
Replied 17 September 2008

Pariksh*t...there are errors in anything you see...

I do not say, its correct..but have some patience and tolerance for this...

And, honestly tell, haven't you been benefitted by anything in this site??

the errors are there, its wrong..but what is important to correct those...

I guess, you would have been reading so called "ethical" message in "Others" section..why not try to practice those also??

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA PRIKSHIT WADHWA (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (339 Points)
Replied 18 September 2008

yOU ARE CORRECT TO SOME EXTENT RUSHIKESH, BUT ERRORS ARE MEANT TO BE CORRECTED AND NOT JUSTIFIED OR SUPPORTED. AS FAR AS BENEFITS ARE CONCERNED, YA, I AM REALLY BENEFITED A LOT BY THOSE FUNNY JOKES BY THE VISITORS IN THE MESSAGE FORUM AS I HAVE NOT TO VISIT FUNNY SITES NOW. CACLUBINDIA IS THERE. I AM REALLY BENEFITTED BY THE MESSAGE FORUMS LYING UNANSWERED BY THE VISITORS FOR MORE THAN 10 DAYS.eXPERT QUERIES LYING UNANSWERED FOR COUPLE OF DAYS. MOSTLTY VISITORES POINTS BADANE KE LIYE YAHAN AATA HAI. ETHICAL MESSAGES AUR JOKES KE LIYE HAR KOI TAYAR HAI, KISI KI HELP KE LIYE KOI NAHI.

Originally posted by :Rushikesh
"	Pariksh*t...there are errors in anything you see... I do not say, its correct..but have some patience and tolerance for this... And, honestly tell, haven't you been benefitted by anything in this site?? the errors are there, its wrong..but what is important to correct those... I guess, you would have been reading so called "ethical" message in "Others" section..why not try to practice those also??	"

Rushikesh (Chartered Accountant - Manager Finance) (2375 Points)
Replied 18 September 2008

Then, I guess, my friend, you've not made full use of this portal...

Check out the Shared Files section in any of the accounts, audit, lawetc.

Check the Articles, Judiciary, web Links, Circulars too..

Also, please compare the expert queries, answered to unanswered..

There can be issues which people here cannot answer..if you know the answers, why not be an expert and answer those..will be helpful to all..

And, please read what I have wrote very carefully..I didn't justify the mistakes..but we need to accept those and rectify those..but takes time for all things...The remedy is important, criticing is easy anyone can do it!!!

And, for funny jokes or sites...there are many you can refer to those if required...this section is for relaxation out from work...not for jokes..

And, for the queries or posts unaswered,...rather than any Tom, Dick and Harry answering them...better to wait for some expert..i know it may be too late..then better do not rely just on this..

Even I have two unaswered posts..but i have gathered information related ot it from elsewhere and got it resolved for myself...Maybe there's no one to answer about "CIA"(which was my query).. but now I can...

CA PRIKSHIT WADHWA (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (339 Points)
Replied 18 September 2008

Originally posted by :Rushikesh
"	Then, I guess, my friend, you've not made full use of this portal... Check out the Shared Files section in any of the accounts, audit, lawetc. Check the Articles, Judiciary, web Links, Circulars too.. Also, please compare the expert queries, answered to unanswered.. There can be issues which people here cannot answer..if you know the answers, why not be an expert and answer those..will be helpful to all.. And, please read what I have wrote very carefully..I didn't justify the mistakes..but we need to accept those and rectify those..but takes time for all things...The remedy is important, criticing is easy anyone can do it!!! And, for funny jokes or sites...there are many you can refer to those if required...this section is for relaxation out from work...not for jokes.. And, for the queries or posts unaswered,...rather than any Tom, Dick and Harry answering them...better to wait for some expert..i know it may be too late..then better do not rely just on this.. Even I have two unaswered posts..but i have gathered information related ot it from elsewhere and got it resolved for myself...Maybe there's no one to answer about "CIA"(which was my query).. but now I can...	"

great Rushikesh, U r really a Chartered Accountant. I surrender. I don't know that r u so free that u write such lenghty comments on such useless websites. Well, Dear I am not even so free to read your comments fully. Still go ahead and go on writing your comments.