TDS Deduction for NR

CA Bijay Shrestha (Never Give up....No matter what....)   (858 Points)

22 December 2019  

An Indian Company is required to make payment of Technical Fees of Rs. 5 Lakh to a foreign Company. Indian TDS rate is 10%. That Foreign Company does not have PE in India.

This Technical Fee is in the nature of Business income for that foreign Company.

Now as per Article 7 of DTAA – Business Profit:  Business Income is taxable in India if that foreign company has PE in India and that income is attributable to that PE.

And As per Article 13 of DTAA - ROYALTIES AND FEES FOR TECHNICAL SERVICES AND PAYMENTS FOR THE USE OF EQUIPMENT:  TDS rate is 5%.

Now my query is :

Is the Indian Company required to deduct TDS @ 5% as per Article 13 or no TDS deduction required as per Article 7 since that Fee is business income for that Foreign Company?