Please tell which book is better for IPCC and Final in tax TN Manoharan or Padhuka and when it is good to buy a tax book which covers amendments I saw padhuka it is in tabular format and can clear concept and is well written and simple however i do not have any idea about tn manoharan which i found many referenced in caclubindia please tell how is tn manoharan, only drawback in padhuka is does not have lots of sum to practice, which would be better to buy for practical problems vk singhania or girish ahuja. Please give ur view.....
17 Replies
CS RAJESH C.CHOUDHARY
(ASSISTANT MANAGER)
(14607 Points)
Replied 21 November 2012
But for Direct tax, you can prefer Girish Ahuja or V.K.Singhania....
The language of G.Ahuja is easier than V.K.Singhania...
His book is simple and sufficient at the same time.
listen friend, Everybody will suggest you according to their experiences. I would say both are good. Just have a look at both the books and check which pattern is better for you. Ultimately it depends on you how you study it.
all the very best.
Regards,
RAJESH CHOUDHARY
Raj Kr
(CA Final student )
(200 Points)
Replied 21 November 2012
Vinod K shinghania is best for CA Final n IPCC-GIrish Ahuja.
Rohit
(CA-Final)
(1485 Points)
Replied 21 November 2012
I am doing CA IPCC and studying from 2 Books :-
T.N. Manoharan - for understanding provisions (due to its easy language)
V.K Singhnia - for advance Questions and missed provisions or any point.
CA Pooja Agarwal
(Chartered Accountant)
(3228 Points)
Replied 21 November 2012
i would suggest V.K.Sighania
CA Final Docent
(No work)
(690 Points)
Replied 21 November 2012
trust me it takes entire life to complete vinod k singhania.
hence go either for tn monoharan or girish ahuja.
dont buy two books u will be confused
tn monoharan consits of theory theory theory and theory but in easy language
u check girish ahuja, if it contains less theory then buy it immediately
if u are used to read big big books from ur childhood then go for monoharan
dont think about padukas, vinod k singhania
so ur choice will be between tn monoharan and girish ahuja:)
Sumit Middha
(Head (Fin.& A/c) M.COM M.A.(Eco) MBA CS Final)
(2453 Points)
Replied 21 November 2012
| Originally posted by : Rohit | ||
 |
I am doing CA IPCC and studying from 2 Books :- T.N. Manoharan - for understanding provisions (due to its easy language) V.K Singhnia - for advance Questions and missed provisions or any point. |
 |
Ashwini Kumar Rohilla
(M.Com and CA-FINAL)
(949 Points)
Replied 21 November 2012
According to me:
CA Dr. Girish Ahuja's Book is best because point to point explanation and notes are given with number of examples and Sir's point of view is also given in some point.
Which is easy to understand the relevant concept....
Ashwini Kumar Rohilla
(M.Com and CA-FINAL)
(949 Points)
Replied 21 November 2012
Same as above......
Keerthi
(Assistant Manager)
(48 Points)
Replied 21 November 2012
Bangar book is excellent for CA Final for both direct and indirect taxes..Exam oriented and very clearly explained concepts and easy to understand..The right book for CA Final..
@VaibhavJ
(Believe!! Live your dreams!)
(33516 Points)
Replied 21 November 2012
Go for VS Datey for IDT, full clarity on Subject Matter.
For DT Girish Ahuja & Ravi Gupta is Best..
vicky singh
(ipcc and bcom programme)
(42 Points)
Replied 22 November 2012
i refer v k singhania for tax believe me it is total best if u have potential to solve lot of questions but it clear ur mind at every concept believe me u will rock i done this for nov12 paper refer it
Varshit Shah
(Self Employed)
(676 Points)
Replied 22 November 2012
If you are knowledge oriented person and wants to make your BASE strong then ,
IPCC - Tax - Vinod Singhania , if you have solved it properly and if you know the provision properly this will help you in final. It will take less time in final to understand the basic proviso. Some times it is difficult to understand particular provision by just reading the same i.e. by reading theory only , if we have any practical question on that , then it is easy to understand. Singhania sir's book provide this. Your score will be 60+ sure shot if done it properly.
Final - Tax - Preference - if you have time - Vinod Gupta ( Very conceptual + covered lots of practical question to helping in understanding the concept , specially Assessment Procedures )
Exam Oriented - Bangar
Even do not forget to solve PRACTICE MANUAL. Well designed and will surely help in scoring 50+.
Best of luck.
Ankita CWA Final Student
(Principle Internal Auditor)
(348 Points)
Replied 22 November 2012
I will suggeste "Banker" for In direct Taxand Vinod "Gupta" Book for Direct tax
Recent Topics
- Iska djd djrbdsjebshe sir ur rei ejr reinr the jr
- GST registration for medical shop in Karnataka
- Hsshs me know if you are free number of the
- Chu Kang and the situation of the situation and I
- How to reverse wrong transaction payment in phonep
- Paytm wrong transaction
- How to reverse wrong transaction payment in phonep
- Issue with refund for person who has filed for rel
- How to take ITC for October 2024 GST Payment in PM
- How to refund a wrong transaction Phone Pe?
Related Threads
CAclubindia
