Tax query - interesting

Tax queries 770 views 9 replies

Hi All

 

Suppose an employee in private sector leaves the job without serving the notice period and pays the amount to his employer in lieu of that. What will be the treatment of that amount paid? Is there any deduction available to employee? If yes, under which section and which head?

 

Thanks

Replies (9)

I don't know, but usually BPOs are following this practice that if an employee leaves without issuing one months notice, then the employee has to pay one months salary as penalty to the company.

Hi deepak

As the employee has received his income and then paid back to the company it is just mere application of income and it is taxable in the hands of employee and no deduction is available.
 

IN THIS CASE EMPLOYEE CAN NOT TAKE ANY DEDUCTION IN HIS EXPENSE FOR PAY TO HIS EMPLOYER BECOZ NO ANY PROVISSION GIVEN IN THE INCOME TAX ACT

Hi Vijay

 

I am not convinced by the statement that it is an application of income. Because the employee has foregone it for not serving the notice period and has not got anything from the new employer as well.

 

If the same logic is applied in case of professional say CA, then he may not be allowed his office expenses incurred out of his professional receipts because it is mere application of income. In the same way, the employee who pays notice period pay is incurring it for his employment and not for his household purpose or any other purpose which can be treated as application of income.

 

I agree that there may not be any specific provision for the benefit of employees in these cases, but I am not convinced by the logic that it is mere application of income, Thanks anyways.

One month Salary is returned back to the employer, it means employee worked free of charge for One month.

So the salary returned would not be counted as Salary paid, even the employer will follow the same principle, otherwise it will be treated as His income - Why get confused so much.

There is a subtle difference:

It is NOTICE "PAY" that is paid to the EMPLOYER. as such, in the salary received from that employer, this amount of notice pay is deducted and net only taken for computation of Income. LOGIC -> Income under the head Salary is 1)Received and/or 2) Receivable. Hence received salary gets reduced by returned salary. Moreover, If he gives notice and completes service for that period he has to receive salary. There is nothing called like FREE SERVICE.

BUT, if the amount is paid as "DAMAGES", etc. then he can not get the above benefit.

1st of all we have to understand the meaning of notice pay .......

 

notice is to be given 1 calander month in advance by either side employer and employee before terminating the service. so if anybody breaks the contract i.e if employer removes the employee, he will pay 1 month extra salary to employee as penalty, similer way the employee if leaves without notice, he will pay one month salary to employer as penalty. 

regarding tax treatments, employee can not avail any incometax benefits for such notice pay , paid as penalty. TDS and all statuary deductions are applicable on such notice pay.

Agree with A CHENCHUMOHAN.

The payment made by EE to its ER is payment made for breach of contract of employment. Therefore no dedcution is allowed anywhere in the Act.

Thanks

https://taxbykk.blogspot.com/

I do not say, it is a breach of contract or for the breach of  a contract.

As it is included in the terms of contract so the payment to company or payment from company are in accordance with the contract.

 

HAD THE COMPANY PAID NOTICE PAY SALARY - CAN IT BE SAID THAT COMAPNY WILL NOT BE ALLOWED ANY EXPENDITURE ? OR

THE AMOUNT WILL NOT BE INCLUDED IN THE HANDS OF THE EMPLOYEE AS SALARY ?

FORM THE ABOVE LOGIC IT CAN BE SAID THAT WHAT THE EMPLOYEE HAS PAID BACK TO THE EMPLOYER 

WAS NOTHING BUT IT WAS SALARY.

IT CAN BE DEDUCTED AS HE HAS TO REFUND THE AMOUNT TO THE COMPANY IN TERMS OF SERVICE AGREEMENT.


 


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register