Ad Free CAclubindia and Daily Updates on your Mobile. Subscribe Now!

STATEMENT OF FACT & GROUND OF APPEAL

SUGATA GANGULY (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (88 Points)

28 January 2010

WHAT IS STATEMENT OF FACT & GROUN OF APPEAL?IS THERE ANY GENERAL FORMAT FOR PREAPARING THIS?

Reply
Follow
Share

9 Replies

Amir (Learner) (4016 Points)
Replied 28 January 2010

Dear Sugata,

There is no prescribed format for drafting statement of facts & grounds of appeal..

Following link might help u

/forum/sample-of-drafting-appeal-to-cit-a--61844.asp

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Devendra Singh (Prop) (29 Points)
Replied 19 March 2012

Dear Sir

as per attached file what is grounds of appeal

Assessesing authourity imposed panalaty U/s 271(1)(c)

Attached File : 778529 950950 isahq.rar downloaded: 6150 times

1 Like

Anumanchipalli Sathikonda (Tax Consultant) (1559 Points)
Replied 19 March 2012

Mr.Sugata Ganguly

Statement Of Facts and Grounds Of Appeal are documents in an appeal preferred by an aggrieved assessee before the Copmmissioner of Income-tax (Appeals). I will try to explain the procedure of appeal in detail.

An Aggrieved assessee can prefer an appeal before the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) against the orders listed in section 246 and 246A. The said orders are generally known as 'appelable orders'. Every appeal should be made in the prescribed form as per the provisions of section 249. The prescribed form is Form No.35 as prescribed under Rule 45 of Income-tax Rules, 1992. The said form is generally known as 'Memorandum of Appeal'. The appeal should be filed with the Commissioner [hereafter the word 'commissioner' is used for Commissioner of Income-tax (appeals) ] within 30 (Thirty) days from the date of service of demand notice where the appeal relates to any assessment or penalty. Similarly the 30 days time limit is fixed in respect of appeals in other matters also. Please see Section 249. The memorandum of appeal (Form No.35) should be accompanied with -

(1) Challan for payment of appeal fee (Please see section 249 for the prescribed fee)

(2) Two Certified copies of the order of the assessing officer against which the appeal is preferred (assessment order, penalty order or any other order)

(3) Demand Notice in Original i.e. the form No.35 should be accompanied with Original Demand Notice.

(4) Statement of Facts (in duplicate)

(5) Grounds of Appeal (in duplicate)

The form No.35 is also to be filed in duplicate.

A Court Fee Stamp worth Rs.2/- has to be affixed to one of the Forms No.35.

Form No.35 is to be verified by the assessee in the manner prescribed. Persons who can sign a return of income can also sign the Form No.35. Please see section 140.

Now lets discuss what are the statement of facts.

Generally the statement of facts and grounds of appeal are drafted in third person. In the statment of facts a brief discussion about the assessee (here in the appeal he/she is called appellant). After briefing about the appellant the facats about grievance of the appellant are stated. Assume that the assessee is an Individual. During the previous year relevant to the assessmen year 2009-10 he has borrowed a sum of Rs.50,000/- which has not been accepted by the assessing officer and added the same to the returned income. The same assessee has also made certain cash payments exceeding the limits prescribed u/s 40A which have been disallowed by the assessing officer. The business of the assessee is that of a Civil Contractor. Now the following are the Statement of Facts and Grounds of Appeal.

STEMENT OF FACTS

The appellant is an Individual carrying on the business as a Civil Contractor for the last several years. He has filed his return of income declaring a total income of Rs.4,50,000/-. The return of income has been processed u/s 143(1) acceoting the returned income. Subsequently the case has been selected for scruitiny. The assessment has been completed determining the total income at Rs.6,00,000/- against the retuned income of Rs.4,50,000/-. While doing so the assessing officer has made the following addtions/disallowances.

(1) Rs,50,000/- loan borrowed by the assessee from Mr.------ on the plea that the lender is not having sufficeint income to lend the said money to the appellant.

(2) Rs.50,000/- payment made to various individual labourers which payment is made to the group leader of the labourers who in turn made the payment to the individual labourers.

During the course of assessment proceedings a letter from Mr.--- is filed wherein he confirmed that he has lent the said money party out of his savings of agricultural income and partly amount receieved from his son who is a software engineer and working in New York, the USA. The lender has submitted a copy of his Farmer's Pass Book, Pattadar Pass Book and also a receipt from the rice mill (M/s.-------) to whom he sold the paddy. He has also submitted copy of his bank pass book wherein the sums sent by his son are deposited. He has identified the depsoits and withdrawls for the purpose of the loan given to the appelllant. The assessing officer further demanded a confirmation letter from the son the lender in the month of December, 2011. The lender has requested his son to send a confirmation letter. Meanwhile the assessing officer completed the assessment on 20-11-2011 on the pleas that the case will be barred by time by 31-12-2011. Whereas the letter from the son of the lender reached to the appelant on 22-11-2011.

Regarding the payment of Rs.50,000/- the appellant explained that the payment is not made to a single person. It has been made to several individual persons through the group leader of the labourers. The assessing officer has served a letter on the group leader to appear before him on 19-11-2011. The group leader could not attend on the appointed day as he has to attend a family function which is unavoidable. He has sent a telgram requesting to grant him two days time to attend. Un fortunately the telegram has reached the the assessing officer after the officer hours on 19-11-2011.

It is against this order of assessment this appeal is being prferred with a request to delete the addition made and allow the expenditure as claimed.

APPELLANT

GROUNDS OF APPEAL

1.The order of the assessing officer is erroneous on the facts and in the law. On the facts and in the circumstances ofthe case he ought to have accepted the returned income.

2. The learned assessing officer is not justified in treating the loan borrowed by the appelant as his income on the plea that a confirmation from the son of the lender is not received before the appointed day. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case he ought to have accepted the loan as sufficient evidences have been produced such as Farmer's Pass Book, Pattadar Pass Book and Bank Pass Book of the lender alongwith with a confirmatory letter.

3. The learned assessing officer is not justified in disallowing the payments made to the labourers invoking the provisions of section 40A(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case he has failed to appreciate the prevailing circumstances in the business of a civil contractor.

4.The learned assessing officer is not justified in not affording another opportunity to the appelant to produce a confirmatory letter from the son of the lender and also the group letter of the labour. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case he ought not have completed the assessment hastily.

5.Any other ground or grounds as may be urged at the time of hearing.

APPELLANT

Best Wishes

Sathikonda

p.s.:If you still need any futher clarification how to represent before the commissioner please feel free to communicate.

3 Like

Paras Kumar Jha (Accountant) (26 Points)
Replied 19 September 2014

Dear sir,

Please suggest me what can i do ?

our companies income tax return was invalid due to non receipt of ITR V for the A. Y. 2009 - 10

I have filed application u/s 119 (2b) but CIT has reject the application , she said that this ground is not falling u/s 119(2b). CPC tell me to file fresh return of F. Y. 2008 - 09 , But home department said that i have not accept your rteurn , it is beyond our authority , you file appeal against CPC

please suggest me what can I do?

Thanks & Regards

Paras Jha

AMRINDER SINGH (ACCOUNTANT) (22 Points)
Replied 26 July 2016

Dear Sir

WHAT IS STATEMENT OF FACT & GROUN OF APPEAL?

joint commissner imposed penalty u/s 271D

in ground of appeal "what is the issue?"

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Yas Sharma (Articled Assistant) (22 Points)
Replied 02 January 2020

What is statement of facts and grounds for filing appeal before CIT against of order of lower gross profit ratio

CMA M.Keerthi chandra (C.A FINAL STUDENT AND QUALIFIED C.M.A) (561 Points)
Replied 02 January 2020

In general 'Statement of Facts' means nothing but the facts of the case. There is no prescribed format for that and we can narrate the issue in simple English language.

In case of grounds of Appeal, in online Form 35, it is asked to submit ,section wise the issue and the order if any appealed against.

In general grounds of Appeal are the issues relating erroneously passing of , the Assessment order, Penalty order, Order denying 12A registration and such.

Prachi Bansal (3129 Points)
Replied 15 April 2021

How many days does an appeal take to be processed further?

SATISHBABU SWAMINATHAN (2 Points)
Replied 19 May 2024

what is the grounds of appeal against order passed by AO u/s 144 for no response by assessee for any of the notices issued. please provide model ground of appeal for this issue.