Easy Office
LCI Learning

solve 1 rs equal to 1 paisa

Page no : 3

suhas sathe (CA, Practice) (39 Points)
Replied 21 December 2010

Originally posted by : CMA. Sanjay Gupta

Now Lets check another Mathematical Illusion:



To prove   1=2


Let, x=y


or, 2x-x=2y-y


or, 2x-2y=x-y


or, 2(x-y)=x-y


or, 2=1
 

In last step u have divided by (x-y) to both side. As 1st  x = y, therefore x-y=0. but as per 1 of the basic rule of mathematics u can not divide by zero("0"0 to any thing. Dividing by zero has no meaning.
 therefore above conclusion is incorrect.

 

also for 100paisa=1 * 100paisa but not 1paisa * 100paisa cuz,

if i have Rs.10,000 ( all are Rs. 100 currency note) then i write it as,

100 * Rs. 100. I am not writting it as Rs.100 * Rs.100.

 

So there is no such word called as illusion in mathematics. :D


Raghunath Prasad (WORKING) (385 Points)
Replied 21 December 2010

 

Originally posted by : suhas




Originally posted by : CMA. Sanjay Gupta






Now Lets check another Mathematical Illusion:



To prove   1=2


Let, x=y


or, 2x-x=2y-y


or, 2x-2y=x-y


or, 2(x-y)=x-y


or, 2=1
 






In last step u have divided by (x-y) to both side. As 1st  x = y, therefore x-y=0. but as per 1 of the basic rule of mathematics u can not divide by zero("0"0 to any thing. Dividing by zero has no meaning.
 therefore above conclusion is incorrect.

 

also for 100paisa=1 * 100paisa but not 1paisa * 100paisa cuz,

if i have Rs.10,000 ( all are Rs. 100 currency note) then i write it as,

100 * Rs. 100. I am not writting it as Rs.100 * Rs.100.

 

So there is no such word called as illusion in mathematics. :D

 1*100=100

which methmatices rule tell that there is 1 and 100 are diffrent value

if we think 100 as paisa ya enthing value

than why we think diff value of 1

 

pls explain


Mayank Kothari (CA) (919 Points)
Replied 21 December 2010

Agreed with suhas

1 paisa *100 paisa = 100 paisa is incorrect

it witll be 1 paisa * 100 paisa = 100 paisa(Square)


Vikash Maheshwari (learner) (6358 Points)
Replied 21 December 2010

other members have stated d flaw in tht equation............nvr d less m amused by d choice of font color that u had chosen............initially i thought i needed to wear glasses 4 sure and my eyes have given up upon me..hehehe..kidding..............but nice and illusive post,...........wud definitely share wid frends........


SHIVAM GROVER (student) (304 Points)
Replied 21 December 2010

good oneeeeeeeee

 

par apni ta samajhto bar ae lollllllll



Raghunath Prasad (WORKING) (385 Points)
Replied 23 December 2010

thanx frd

 

and sorry yadi maine app logo ka time best kiya ho

 

 

kuch meri bat se sahmat he or kuch sahmat nahi he

but kisi ne bhi mughe ye nahi batya ki math ke kis rule me likha he ki

1*100=100

which math rule told us that 1 and 100 value are diffrent

 

i think so that 1 and 100 value is equal


ravi jain (CA final ) (48 Points)
Replied 23 December 2010

Dear, i received a email in which u write which rule say that 1*100=100. dear u undersant very well

listen dear if u use unit like Rs. and any measurment unit then this means u must be right with unit in other case write 1*100=100. so u do not mix two concept. we give to example for uderstanding

1. with Unit

1 m = 100cm

1 m = 1*100cm but not write 1cm*100cm = 100cm squer.

2 without unit.

100 = 1*100 not use any unit so write that Equation .

If friends u have any other solution then give comment on this matter. and also give any reply on my E-mail ID ravijain.ca2010 @ gmail.com

 



Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Join CCI Pro


Subscribe to the latest topics :

Search Forum: