Originally posted by : Future CA CS
	No,its correct,Companies (Disqualification of Directors under section 274(1)(g) of the Companies Act, 1956) Rules, 2003  have made distinction between ‘disqualifying company’ and ‘appointing company’. A Director is disqualified from being appointed or reappointed in appointing company but he can be reappointed in disqualifying company.

Totally agree with the interpretation as defaulting director can be re-appointed in the defaulting company without any problem. Reason being Law restricts the appointment of defaulting director in any other public company.

Regards

Thank u so much for detailed reply.........

but sir now am confused .....bez of these lines

“such person shall not be eligible to be appointed as a Director of any other public company” Hence to conclude I would say he will be eligible to be re-appointed as a director of the defaulting company or any other public company of which he was a director.llows

As per Munish bhandari law book it says as follows

A direcotr of defaulting company is not eligible for appointment in any other public company

or

is not elgible for reapoointment in any other public company in which he is already a director.

please clarify.

Brothers and Sisters ,

Mere hisab se , agar tum 274/1/g me disqualified hote ho , to 5 sal k liye aap kisi v Public Co. k director nei ban sakte ho........agar ,  koi kahe ki wo to defaulting co k director ban sakta hai - to aab muje batawo , KOUN SA BEWAKUF Co. jan buj kar kisi director k appoint karega jo pahele se 274/1/g me fasa hua hai ???

Originally posted by : Akash Kangsa Banik
	Brothers and Sisters , Mere hisab se , agar tum 274/1/g me disqualified hote ho , to 5 sal k liye aap kisi v Public Co. k director nei ban sakte ho........agar ,  koi kahe ki wo to defaulting co k director ban sakta hai - to aab muje batawo , KOUN SA BEWAKUF Co. jan buj kar kisi director k appoint karega jo pahele se 274/1/g me fasa hua hai ???

Very funny observation….

Akash ji….come on….you are in CA Final…yahi likh kar aayoga kya exam main??????

Bhaiya aisa nahi hoti law ki padai……workout on your law understanding….

Plz bura mat man na…i don't want to hurt you but it's a bit serious...

@ akash ji.......

LOL......very good spontaneous reaction............

Originally posted by : Ankur Garg
	Originally posted by : Akash Kangsa Banik Brothers and Sisters , Mere hisab se , agar tum 274/1/g me disqualified hote ho , to 5 sal k liye aap kisi v Public Co. k director nei ban sakte ho........agar ,  koi kahe ki wo to defaulting co k director ban sakta hai - to aab muje batawo , KOUN SA BEWAKUF Co. jan buj kar kisi director k appoint karega jo pahele se 274/1/g me fasa hua hai ???   Very funny observation…. Akash ji….come on….you are in CA Final…yahi likh kar aayoga kya exam main?????? Bhaiya aisa nahi hoti law ki padai……workout on your law understanding…. Plz bura mat man na…i don't want to hurt you but it's a bit serious...

Thanks for you guidlines Ankur Sir. I must write answers in CA Exam with due care. What I have told here, is nothing but a clear view i.e. interpretatation of sec 274/1/g in layman's language.  Most of the students give their opinion as per principles of law, so i tried to give a new and interesting look to them. Such types of things are very helpful for me to clear any doubt, but i know , it is not a recommanded answer by regulatory bodies. Thanks Again.

Please tell if winding up is deleted from syllabus applicable for may 2012?

Companies (second Amendment) Act, 2002 relating to winding up is not applicable

However students are adivsed to study only general provisions of winding up as covered under paragraph 9.4 of the study material

Source - RTP May 2012.

Originally posted by : Akash Kangsa Banik
	Thanks for you guidlines Ankur Sir. I must write answers in CA Exam with due care. What I have told here, is nothing but a clear view i.e. interpretatation of sec 274/1/g in layman's language.  Most of the students give their opinion as per principles of law, so i tried to give a new and interesting look to them. Such types of things are very helpful for me to clear any doubt, but i know , it is not a recommanded answer by regulatory bodies. Thanks Again.

Akash ji I hope my PM finds you in the best of spirit.

Stay cool and happy.