Go AD-Free with CAclubindia Pro and get a FREE CCI Coffee Mug. Subscribe Now!

Review of CA Bhanwar Borana pen drive classes for CA Final Direct Tax

Gaurav Gupta (Articled Assistant) (37 Points)

17 May 2018

Hello, can anybody give a review about CA Bhanwar Borana sir's classes in pen drive mode for CA Final Direct Tax?

Reply
Follow
Share

13 Replies

Shiwali Garg (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (413 Points)
Replied 17 May 2018

Best teacher at present for DT...go for it. :)

1 Like

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Gaurav Gupta (Articled Assistant) (37 Points)
Replied 17 May 2018

Thanks. But when I visited his website, I found that only Fast Track batch is available in pen drive mode. The lecs are only of approx 96 hrs. How can he complete such vast syllabus of CA Final Direct Tax in 96 hrs? Do he covers everything in detail as required for CA final?

1 Like

Shiwali Garg (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (413 Points)
Replied 17 May 2018

That is fast track batch whch is of 96 hrs but he also takes regular batch. Fasttrack will cover all the concepts but not in full detail, if u wanna learn everythng from scratch den go for his regular one.
Call on his helpline number for further details.

Gaurav Gupta (Articled Assistant) (37 Points)
Replied 17 May 2018

Yes. I call the helpline. Thanks for the help

Shiwali Garg (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (413 Points)
Replied 17 May 2018

u r welcome.

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Ankit (CA) (44 Points)
Replied 13 June 2018

I think the best teacher for direct tax now is bhanwar borana as his teaching skills are unique and the online classes comes in pendrives or dvd which is available at makemydelivery .

https://www.makemydelivery.com/product/ca-final-ft-batch-nov-18-bhanwar-borana-old-new-syllabus/

Gaurav Gupta (Articled Assistant) (37 Points)
Replied 13 June 2018

Thanks for the advice.

Rajiv Ranjan (Article ) (6 Points)
Replied 28 April 2019

Hi!!! I am a CA Final student. I am a student of Bhanwar Borana Sir. The biggest mistake of my life is that I joined his classes and wasted my .precious 6 months of life. Anyone who is proposing to join his class, must speak to Victims of his class. He makes big promises but all false. The following are false promises: 1. False promise to cover practical questions in class. No questions covered. Students asked to refer to his compiler 2. He simply reads the law and no explanation. He says Theek Hai. Theek Hai. Apne aap 2 baar pad lena, samajh aa jaega 3. After module 3 he rushes and rushes. Perhaps he himself does not know the law 4 He didn’t cover the most important Vodafone case and related amendments properly. Perhaps he himself does not understand the case and related amendments. 5. We were told that there will be 65 to 70 lectures. 70 lectures were given but we were forced to watch another 10 lectures on youtube 6. Model tax convention lectures on youtube. You must see to know what Bhanwar Borana Sir actually is!! Simply reading and saying theek hai. Theek hai. 2 baar pad lena samajh aa jaega 7 Giving wrong examples. For example DTAA with Hongkong. There isno DTAA but there is TIEA with Hongkong Friends! Please do not waste ur money, time and career with such teachers. If you don’t believe me, please speak to the students who are victims of his classes 242 views · To score well in subject like DT you should cut the course and follow the following steps: Buy Summary module of Vinod Gupta Sir. Download all the revisionary videos available on you tube of Bhawar Bhorana Sir. Divide the course in the modules mentioned in revisionary book of VG sir. First complete high weightage chapters lyk Capital Gain,PGBP,TDS etc. The best part is in every revisionary video of BB sir he discussed the weightage of every chapters and important topics so to make subject easy to learn and retain. Solve PM at least 2 times before exam. Solve Mock test paper conducted by the institute.These steps are sufficient to score well in vast subject lyk DT. All d very best. 8.1k views · Friends! I wont answer the above question! I am Assistant Manager at KPMG Mumbai. I attended Vinod Gupta Sir Classes at Mumbai. In my technical round in interview, I was able to answer 100 percent questions on taxation and international taxation. The tax partner was very impressed with me. When he asked that how cum I got so much knowledge, I answered that this is what i studied in VG Sir Classes. The tax partner gave a smiling look at me. I was terrified thinking he will reject me on the ground that i got the knowledge from coaching classes He stood up!!!! He said that he himself studied from VG Sir in Delhi!! He asked me whether I can join from Today!! 1.1k views · · My recommendation would be Bhawar Borana. The reasons for the same are as follows- DT is a kind of subject which is almost impossible to revise on last day. This man made this thing possible with his last day revision lectures and his superb compact. CA is all about how to present your viewpoint on paper in 180 minutes. Atleast for the degree it matters like anything. Sad but true. This preceptor will make you prepare your subject that you will be able to attend and solve the paper in that 180 minutes. Best combination will be to take classes from Bhawar Borana and revise the concepts from his compact and solve the questions from VG Question Bank which is available in market. This will provide you ample confidence to perform best in exam. Go for Bhawar Borana revision lectures as many times as you can. Caselaws are also one of the important topic which cover atleast 20 to 25 marks in paper for sure. By Bhawar Borana’s case law book you can make sure to score well in case law thing. His short and point to point case law and their final judgments make them easy to remember.

Rajiv Ranjan (Article ) (6 Points)
Replied 28 April 2019

Originally posted by : Ajay Saxena
	Hi!!! I am a CA Final student. I am a student of Bhanwar Borana Sir. The biggest mistake of my life is that I joined his classes and wasted my .precious 6 months of life. Anyone who is proposing to join his class, must speak to Victims of his class. He makes big promises but all false. The following are false promises: 1. False promise to cover practical questions in class. No questions covered. Students asked to refer to his compiler 2. He simply reads the law and no explanation. He says Theek Hai. Theek Hai. Apne aap 2 baar pad lena, samajh aa jaega 3. After module 3 he rushes and rushes. Perhaps he himself does not know the law 4 He didn’t cover the most important Vodafone case and related amendments properly. Perhaps he himself does not understand the case and related amendments. 5. We were told that there will be 65 to 70 lectures. 70 lectures were given but we were forced to watch another 10 lectures on youtube 6. Model tax convention lectures on youtube. You must see to know what Bhanwar Borana Sir actually is!! Simply reading and saying theek hai. Theek hai. 2 baar pad lena samajh aa jaega 7 Giving wrong examples. For example DTAA with Hongkong. There isno DTAA but there is TIEA with Hongkong Friends! Please do not waste ur money, time and career with such teachers. If you don’t believe me, please speak to the students who are victims of his classes.

Ravi Mathur (Tax department of Ernst& Young) (10 Points)
Replied 29 April 2019

Hello Friends!

I do not want to comment on any teacher. There is no Comparison of Vinod Gupta Sir in CA Profession and CA Coaching.

I was a student of Vinod Gupta Sir and I am working in tax department of Ernst& Young. What I am today is because of knowledge given by VG Sir.

In our firm students are not allowed to attend any coaching except by VG Sir. All our partners and directors of EY are students of VG sir.

Friends if u want to learn tax and make career in taxation in big4 then only Vinod Gupta Sir can help you!!

He is not only a legend but God of Direct taxes

His modules are like Bhagwad Gita!!!!

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Vineeta singh (CA final student) (22 Points)
Replied 30 April 2019

Worst teacher is bhanwar borana, Better leave CA rather than attending his classes . I have wasted my attempt after attending his classes

Samaira Alvi (Accounting Manger) (26 Points)
Replied 11 May 2019

See Buddy, first of all pen drive is not the method of clearing something SERIOUS like CA, and second thing even if you are going to make that as your method, please make a Good choice, with all respect to BB sir, his methods are not enough to give you successful Journey as a CA.

Now, let me take the one and only name for direct tax and that is none other than CA Vinod Gupta Sir, he is a remarkable legend for Direct Tax, he does not need to shout or get aloud energy and not even need to repeat himself to make us understand.

So as per my suggestion you should go for his Virtual class and I am sure you will thank me for that, I am sharing a link of one his lecture watch it and see the real method, - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=otTGf-JKqnU

Neha Sharma (2 Points)
Replied 30 May 2019

Spending money on Pendrive classes of BB sir is the worst decision one can ever take while preparing for Direct Tax paper.

DT is one of the most complicated subjects of CA Final and it requires special attention and effort from the part of a student. While everyone knows that you should study every case, amendments and practical questions in detail, BB Sir is selling only 96 hours long lectures in which he claims to be covering all of the topics of Direct Tax.
Frankly speaking, he is only reading what is there in the book and repeating it again and again without explaining the same. Its better to do self study rather than studying from his video lectures.

So if you want to score well in DT paper, I'd recommend you to study from the five modules and books of Vinod Gupta Sir. It contains every topic in detail and explains every concept in a simplified manner. And if you are planning to self-study for the exam, I'd recommend you to study from his summary cum revision book.

And if you have enough time, I'd recommend you to join his virtual classes too.