Go Ad-Free on CAclubindia with Daily Mobile Updates. Subscribe Now!

reagarding Article sheep

kamal (CWA) (125 Points)

06 March 2010

Dear Friends
I have seen many friends of mine which are suffering many problems regarding article ships.
CA had taken work from them almost 8-9 hour daily and not allowed leave before exam. ( not more then 15-20 days ).

Can students take action agaist them.
As per CA rules only 35 hour in week is compulsory for articleship.

It will overburdon on the studends.
because working 8-9 hour and travelling consumed 10-11 hours.

How can a studend can study.

For all that the student get only 1000 to 1500 Rs. Monthly.

is that goods in current time.
or Institute can take "serious" action for that.

Pl reply

Reply
Follow
Share

18 Replies

Ajay kumar (assistant) (481 Points)
Replied 06 March 2010

C A is not a Degree course it is a Professional Course Like M.B.B.S .

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

kamal (CWA) (125 Points)
Replied 06 March 2010

Dear Ajay

I Know it is a professinal cource , but the problem is how to servive is simple averge student who want to do someting in his life.

How can he spend 3.5 year with that amount ( max 1500.00) and working like a emploee.

you mean If a poor man want to study than CA in not for him.

How can he study in 4 hours ( after working 10 hours ) from where he get the energy.

In CA field most of the CA had called on sunday also.

Me myself a CWA my training period is also 3 year but the remm is 3500 to 5000. Atlest i can manage my personal & travelling exp.

But the CA student can not manage their Travelling Exp. Most of my friends had left CA because of that reason.

Ajay kumar (assistant) (481 Points)
Replied 06 March 2010

Every Student Already Know about This course Before his joining . Every person know that C.A Results is between 1-10%. I Donot know why student join this course . Where passing prbablity is just 10 percent.

kamal (CWA) (125 Points)
Replied 06 March 2010

Dear Ajay

I am not taking about %age of Passing

my question is regaring Haresment of CA

and no action taken by the Institute

Institute increase the Fees of CA cource every year due to "inflation " what about Article Remuneration which is still 1000 from last 10 years

and if any student take dummey then the institute will ready to take action.

if CA harrase the Student taking work like employee that institute did nothing,

DEVAKI (C. A. FINAL m.com) (91 Points)
Replied 06 March 2010

can we take excess hrs credit of whatever work done above 35 hrs per week in leave calculations?

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA Shiv Kumar Sharma (Practising Chartered Accountant) (637 Points)
Replied 06 March 2010

Dear Friend

As per institute guildlines we can take credit of excess hours work but these are only guildlines, nobody obey them

Gaurav sharma (PCC-Article Assistant) (36 Points)
Replied 06 March 2010

ya we can take credit of excess work aur agar me apna bataon to excess se hi meri 1 year ki training hui h jo 1.5 yr ke equal h bt we cant do anything abt this.......

RADHIKA JALAN (agarwal) (1521 Points)
Replied 06 March 2010

ya itz a very big problem.............institute should do something in this regard................

Gita Iyer (Specialist) (135 Points)
Replied 06 March 2010

Our institute should increase the stipend rules............. its high time.........

.........

loveseema (Partner, CA) (104 Points)
Replied 06 March 2010

sir,

As per my knowledge, NICASA deals with problems of CA students. Try to get the mail ID of NICASA and share your problem with them. they could give you a better solution.

But i would suggest you that talk to your CA and discuss ur problem with him, i have rarely seen any cases where institute has heard the problems of CA students.

If any of the above way don't help u, then the last option is after getting ur examination form signed by the CA, dont go to the office. ( but keep ur records of attending the office for more than 35 hours a week safely with urself)

ALL THE BEST!

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA Priya (CS Final) (1049 Points)
Replied 06 March 2010

Hey people........... This is a endless problem.......... Lakhs of people have already spoken about this and go carry on their work....... My only suggession is work work and work........ And try to learn as much as u can, while working...... Afterall u are not doing any work which is in no way related to yr studies......... No other option...... We have to struggle....... The only satisfaction we get is we learnt something at the end.......... All know that they are squezing us...... What to do? Just try to Make the environment favorable for u and keep enjoying......... tackle all these with a smile men.......

chippy (Chartered Accountant) (79 Points)
Replied 06 March 2010

i would say dnt go for big firms wer u hav to work like a donkey...experience is needed but for an average student it is very difficult to study after long hours of work...myself terminated from a firm in chennai bcos there was so much work and i cudn study staying in hostel..i joined a small firm near my home...l cleared CA in my first attempt....those having high IQ will tell u dat experience is needed and blah blah but dnt listen to dat..after passing u cud join sm firm for experience dats enuf...study first..i m telling this for average students who require more time for studying..

Gautam (article) (205 Points)
Replied 06 March 2010

Originally posted by : chippy
	i would say dnt go for big firms wer u hav to work like a donkey...experience is needed but for an average student it is very difficult to study after long hours of work...myself terminated from a firm in chennai bcos there was so much work and i cudn study staying in hostel..i joined a small firm near my home...l cleared CA in my first attempt....those having high IQ will tell u dat experience is needed and blah blah but dnt listen to dat..after passing u cud join sm firm for experience dats enuf...study first..i m telling this for average students who require more time for studying..