Go Ad-Free on CAclubindia with Daily Mobile Updates. Subscribe Now!

rank holders--some r dummy

shinoj (ab) (1201 Points)

19 November 2009

many rankers r dummy working 1 year in big firm then take dummy........no doubt every can not take dummy n get rank...but rankers do not want to take risk..............I GUESS U GUYS R MISSING MY POINT......I'VE SAID.....BRILLIANT STUDENTS WORK FOR 1 YEAR LEARNED EVERY THING AND TAKE DUMMY FOR 2 YEARS AND WORK HARD TO GET RANK.......ULTIMALY WORK IN HUL FOR GOOD SALARY.......WELL GUYS SOME MAY LEARN EVERY THING IN 1 YEAR...SOME MAY NOT BE ABLE TO LEARN IN 3 YEARS TOO....REMEMBER IN IIM TOO TRAINING IN LONLY 2 MONTHS ...BUT THEY MUCH BETTER PAY SCALE THAN RANKERS OF CA FINAL......QUALITY MATTERS............

Reply
Follow
Share

32 Replies

Anitha N R (student) (27 Points)
Replied 19 November 2009

May be. There are some rank holders like that... But there are also others who do regular articleship n get rank.... Sorry.. Dont mind me telling u this...Cos i myself am a rank holder in PCC n i do regular articleship only!!!!

1 Like

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA Devanshi Gandhi (Ajani) (FCA DISA Mcom CIFRS & LLB) (9060 Points)
Replied 19 November 2009

dummy is not the only thing which helps students to get ranks.........

1 Like

CA Rohit Garg (CA ) (330 Points)
Replied 19 November 2009

ya i agree dummy is not d requirmnt 4 rank...

NANDINI MASAND (learner ) (330 Points)
Replied 20 November 2009

agreed bt not applicable to all rank holders....................n if 1 take dummy na it reflects during the campus interview..............on evn in practice..............

Rahul Bansal (Finalist) (35929 Points)
Replied 20 November 2009

GETTING RANK IN EXAMS IS COMPLETELY USELESS FOR THOSE WHO DO NOT HAVE PROPER WORKING KNOWLEDGE IN CORPORATE WORLD......!!!!!!!!!!

3 Like

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

shinoj (ab) (1201 Points)
Replied 20 November 2009

Originally posted by :CA Devanshi Gandhi
"	dummy is not the only thing which helps students to get ranks.........	"

.I'VE SAID.....BRILLIANT STUDENTS WORK FOR 1 YEAR LEARNED EVERY THING AND TAKE DUMMY FOR 2 YEARS AND WORK HARD TO GET RANK.......ULTIMALY WORK IN HUL FOR GOOD SALARY.......WELL GUYS SOME MAY LEARN EVERY THING IN 1 YEAR...SOME MAY NOT BE ABLE TO LEARN IN 3 YEARS TOO....REMEMBER IN IIM TOO TRAINING IN LONLY 2 MONTHS ...BUT THEY MUCH BETTER PAY SCALE THAN RANKERS OF CA FINAL......QUALITY MATTERS............

shinoj (ab) (1201 Points)
Replied 20 November 2009

Originally posted by :RAHUL BANSAL
"	GETTING RANK IN EXAMS IS COMPLETELY USELESS FOR THOSE WHO DO NOT HAVE PROPER WORKING KNOWLEDGE IN CORPORATE WORLD......!!!!!!!!!!	"

shinoj (ab) (1201 Points)
Replied 20 November 2009

Originally posted by :NANDINI MASAND
"	agreed bt not applicable to all rank holders....................n if 1 take dummy na it reflects during the campus interview..............on evn in practice..............	"

Rohit Thourani (Practice) (96 Points)
Replied 20 November 2009

1. Its the dummy which is polluting the ca environment thats why ICAI has taken harder steps like "all questions compulsory"

2. rather than scolding students institute should take hard action on members engaged in giving dummy and cancel their CP

3. Also useless papers like MICS should be eliminated and a Centralised VIVA should be conducted to analyse student on practical terms whether he is having any practical experience or not.

4. This would provide a way to put a check on dummy students.

5. Also the papers should me more practical including topics like what queries are raised by a assessing officer under section 143(2), asking applicability of Form no. in income tax rules. This would reflect the practical attitude of Institute which will defeat the intentions of dummy students.

2 Like

CA Sumit Arora (CA) (1411 Points)
Replied 20 November 2009

I agreen with Rohit

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Robin (AUDITOR) (854 Points)
Replied 20 November 2009

THE APPROACH TOWARDS EXAM MATTERS AND NOT DUMMY OR WORK !

nishant (student) (53 Points)
Replied 20 November 2009

Only thing that matters is passing CA whether by getting dummy

or no dummy articleship...

sometimes in life end justifies the means ......

wat say ....friends

Kapil Arora (STUDENT) (376 Points)
Replied 20 November 2009

Originally posted by :rohit
"	1. Its the dummy which is polluting the ca environment thats why ICAI has taken harder steps like "all questions compulsory" 2. rather than scolding students institute should take hard action on members engaged in giving dummy and cancel their CP 3. Also useless papers like MICS should be eliminated and a Centralised VIVA should be conducted to analyse student on practical terms whether he is having any practical experience or not. 4. This would provide a way to put a check on dummy students. 5. Also the papers should me more practical including topics like what queries are raised by a assessing officer under section 143(2), asking applicability of Form no. in income tax rules. This would reflect the practical attitude of Institute which will defeat the intentions of dummy students.	"

Ya Rohit u r abs right there should be something like that my one of the friend posted the application to our hon'ble president shri uttam parkash sir

vandana (student) (225 Points)
Replied 20 November 2009

Don't waste your time in to all this..............WELL GUYS SOME MAY LEARN EVERY THING IN 1 YEAR...SOME MAY NOT BE ABLE TO LEARN IN 3 YEARS TOO

it depends on person to person..remember you will get, what you deserve..so all you have to do is to prove yourself deserving....................ultimately its your personality and attitude, which can leads you to a good salary and respectable position..