Question on Subsequent Sale - Excise part

Dear All,

 Let me ask you all question through an example. This is with regards to case of Mr A in Karnataka.

Persons involved: Supplier in Maharastra, Mr A in Karnataka, Customer in Uttar Pradesh.

Mr A enters into a transaction with Supplier in Maharastra. He charges him Rs 3,00,000 and excise duty of Rs 24,000 on it. Mr A inturn wants the goods to be moved to Customer in Uttar Pradesh directly. So, he asks Suppler to move it to Customers premises in UP. So the Supplier prepares an invoice wherin the goods are billed in Mr A's name & Shipped to Mr Customer. 

Mr A subsequently raises an invoice on Customer for Rs 5,00,000 and shows 24,000 as excise reimbursable.

The question is, Is it correct on part of Mr A to charge excise only for Rs 24,000 and not on 5,00,000 i.e. Rs 40,000?

Replies (2)

First of all I would like to inform you that you cannot raise a bill of Rs. 2,00,000 margin, which is almost 40%. This will make you liable for under valuation and liable for duty and penalty.

The difference of 5-10% is acceptable and in that case there can be a straight away transfer from Maharashtra to UP and the customer can take credit on the Cenvat invoice issed by the supplier.

Thanks Bashista,

But can you please tell based on what premise have you said that it is undervalued, Can you please elaborate with reference to some case law, section no etc.

 

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
16 September 2026
Internal Audit - Team Lead

Consulting & Beyond

Chennai

CA

View Details
Company
12 October 2026
Finance

I-Genext Consulting Private Limited

New Delhi

CA

View Details
Company
19 September 2026
CA/Semi-CA/BCom

Pravin Sarvaiya

Mumbai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 15 September 2026
Freelance Taxation Content Writer Intern

Interactive Media Pvt Ltd.

New Delhi

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 21 September 2026
CA Article Assistant

KK & Company Chartered Accountant

Pune

CA Inter

View Details
Company
15 September 2026
Client-site CA associate

Aditya Muley and Co

Mumbai

CA

View Details
Company
17 September 2026
Chartered Accountant

Dass Gupta & Associates

Gurgaon

CA

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 01 October 2026
Articled Assistant

KPSN & Associates LLP

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details