question
nidhi (student) (50 Points)
03 December 2016
book for ca final audit, and which teacher is better for sfm? sanjay saraf sir or aditya jain sir,?
14 Replies
CA Ankit Garg
(Qualified Chartered Accountant )
(1743 Points)
Replied 03 December 2016
Audit - CA RAVI TAORI SIR BOOK
For revision n short points CA SURBHI BANSAL MAM BOOK
For revision n short points CA SURBHI BANSAL MAM BOOK
CA Ankit Garg
(Qualified Chartered Accountant )
(1743 Points)
Replied 03 December 2016
Sanjay Saraf sir.. Don't have to think of any other option
nidhi
(student)
(50 Points)
Replied 03 December 2016
are you sure? cz none of my frnd is referring sanjay saraf sir. m bit confused
CA Ankit Garg
(Qualified Chartered Accountant )
(1743 Points)
Replied 03 December 2016
I myself took classes from sanjay Saraf sir for my ca final.. He is the best. Go for it
nidhi
(student)
(50 Points)
Replied 03 December 2016
ok... any changes? cz I have 2014classes of him. should I refer that only
SAURABH
(JODHPUR)
(72 Points)
Replied 03 December 2016
both r nice :)
& for audit-Aseem trivedi si book
CA Ankit Garg
(Qualified Chartered Accountant )
(1743 Points)
Replied 04 December 2016
@ nidhi der are lot of changes in changes in sfm. New concepts have been introduced. New sums have been included in practice manual, rtp, mock test papers, supplementary introduced by ICAI.
Don't refer old material n classes...
Better take classes.
Don't refer old material n classes...
Better take classes.
Dharmesh
(Student)
(1025 Points)
Replied 04 December 2016
aseem sirs book on SA is an incomplete book.. it just has selected question and answers.
CA Pallav Singhania
(IT System Auditor)
(33362 Points)
Replied 04 December 2016
Undoubtedly, Sanjay Saraf is good for SFM.
For Audit, the first preference is ICAI Practice Manual.
Secondly, Surbhi Bansal or Ravi Taori is a good option.
Karan Batra
(Creator: TheProTalks)
(2325 Points)
Replied 05 December 2016
I have taken classes and given my attempt this time using Aaditya jain sir 's notes and questions.
In my opinion it depends on you, let me explain myself,
If you are an average student who is not aware about some Finance terms and is ready to bear to do more practice for better understanding like referring other Practice manual, makkar sir's book then you should go with Aaditya jain sir as he lets you understand the basics of each chapter very easily however he doesn't uplifts you from that level. Secondly the major problem with his style and books is he changes the past examination questions
In my opinion it depends on you, let me explain myself,
If you are an average student who is not aware about some Finance terms and is ready to bear to do more practice for better understanding like referring other Practice manual, makkar sir's book then you should go with Aaditya jain sir as he lets you understand the basics of each chapter very easily however he doesn't uplifts you from that level. Secondly the major problem with his style and books is he changes the past examination questions
Karan Batra
(Creator: TheProTalks)
(2325 Points)
Replied 05 December 2016
In continuation :
He changes the questions given in his book which had come earlier in past exams or are in PM/RTP or he provides a NOTE/HINT with the question itself explaining the meaning of a difficult term and provides the answer below it. This hampers your interpretation skills and you never feel adequate and see yourself at level
He changes the questions given in his book which had come earlier in past exams or are in PM/RTP or he provides a NOTE/HINT with the question itself explaining the meaning of a difficult term and provides the answer below it. This hampers your interpretation skills and you never feel adequate and see yourself at level
Karan Batra
(Creator: TheProTalks)
(2325 Points)
Replied 05 December 2016
of Final exam.
If you want a indepth understanding you should go with Sanjay saraf sir. However I should caution you that without practise by yourself you won't succeed if you happen to take any of these teacher's classes.
If you want a indepth understanding you should go with Sanjay saraf sir. However I should caution you that without practise by yourself you won't succeed if you happen to take any of these teacher's classes.
Karan Batra
(Creator: TheProTalks)
(2325 Points)
Replied 05 December 2016
For audit this is what you can go through :
1.For individual chapters and PE go with Surbhi maam's book(e.g. PE, GIC, Peer review, NBFC, Stock Broker etc)
2.For SAs strictly advising you to go with CA Ravi taori's book. I am recommending this over Surbhi Maam's book is because he provides with the detailed view on each SA with "PNEMONICS" and trend is that summaries are now not expected on SAs in exams but individual aspects are tested and Surbhi maam's book provide a bird point of view not a detailed view.
3.After you are done with the chapter/SA, go through for a prima facie assessment from Study mat what topics were left by the author(if any).I recommend u to download the soft copy of all chapters Study mat in ur PC or mobile for this.
4.Complete PM,RTPs
5.Keep revising.
This strategy will assure you that whatever the level of paper is you will get good marks atleast.
PS. I had taken CA ravi taori's SAs pendrive from CAclubindia and it was worth it so you can check the same also.
1.For individual chapters and PE go with Surbhi maam's book(e.g. PE, GIC, Peer review, NBFC, Stock Broker etc)
2.For SAs strictly advising you to go with CA Ravi taori's book. I am recommending this over Surbhi Maam's book is because he provides with the detailed view on each SA with "PNEMONICS" and trend is that summaries are now not expected on SAs in exams but individual aspects are tested and Surbhi maam's book provide a bird point of view not a detailed view.
3.After you are done with the chapter/SA, go through for a prima facie assessment from Study mat what topics were left by the author(if any).I recommend u to download the soft copy of all chapters Study mat in ur PC or mobile for this.
4.Complete PM,RTPs
5.Keep revising.
This strategy will assure you that whatever the level of paper is you will get good marks atleast.
PS. I had taken CA ravi taori's SAs pendrive from CAclubindia and it was worth it so you can check the same also.
Recent Topics
- NRO Interest - Taxed at source and in Foreign Coun
- Clarity needed on effective date
- Income Tax Refund Deadline Shortened to Five Years
- Rectification Applications for Past GST Demands
- Where can I find a trusted provider to hire a skip
- GST Invoices Series
- FILING OF ITR AY 20-21
- CLAIMING OF U CLAIMED RCM
- Building construction works
- REGARDING GSTR-9 F.Y 2023-24
Related Threads
CAclubindia
