gaurav (CA Finale) (226 Points)
21 January 2012Hi,I hav Practice manual of last yr.
Does insti. ask quest. from current year p.m. or last yrs. p.m. will do?
And may i get a feedback on Devang Dalal book for ISCA..wht r d deficiences of this book and why its not preferred?Askin coz famous book shop here in mumbai recommended me this book whereas im preferrin to buy padhuka 4 it..which one to prefer pls. solve my query...
gaurang
(student)
(158 Points)
Replied 22 January 2012
Same query..Is the latest Practice manual only..relevant for 2012 exams or last years manual will do??
And wat abt Devang dalal..Is it module oriented ? and better than padhuka in terms of revising durin exams due to mnemonics it contains??
Pls. give a review if someone has scored good marks in recent Final papers from this book or else i will opt for padhuka too??
Rockstar2012
(student)
(21 Points)
Replied 24 January 2012
Huh..7.5lac members and no reply from any CA's passing this result or d previous one..Guess all r busy postin their success stories..
No concrete and precise replys to books related questions in the forum as per the questions asked by guys confused abt the authors..pity..People Just keep on postin d authors recommended wont do guys if a guy needs concrete reply as to y this book shud b preferred or not it shud be answered in tht manner only..Eg..Considerin gauravs query regd. Devang Dalals book..i fail to believe tht no one has referred tht book..and cant reply on the pros and cons of the book when it comes to scorin in d exams..and whether its module oriented or not??
My request:Pls. answer d query in whole as reqd. by d person concerned...which most dont do in the forum..
Reply to the quest.:ISCA-Go for Padhuka Reason:Module Oriented Ans...which d insti. requires d examinees to write in d current scenario to get marks..havent referred Devang Dalal so no comments abt tht book..and whether its module oriented or not?
Practice Manual : Buy d latest one applicable for 2012..
CAclubindia
