For 1st ques the right answer is 47:25
In 2nd ques 5:3 is not gaining ratio it is new ratio between A & C there is mistake in study material
triumph-CMA
(Chartered Accountant)
(503 Points)
Replied 19 February 2009
For 1st ques the right answer is 47:25
In 2nd ques 5:3 is not gaining ratio it is new ratio between A & C there is mistake in study material
Santhosh Poojary
(SIEMPRE AHÍ PARA TI)
(15607 Points)
Replied 19 February 2009
THANKS DHIRENDRA SIR.........
bhoop
(account)
(99 Points)
Replied 23 February 2009
Actually both questions have some confusion, I think question should be New Profint/Loss Ratio of A & C is 5:3 and we need to find out gaining ratio of A & C from part of B.
Answer of 1st Problem
New Ratio is 5:3 i.e.
A = 5/8 and C=3/8
And old ratio is 4:3:2 i.e.
A=4/9; B = 3/9 and C = 2/9
Now we find out gaining ratio of A & C due to retirement of B
Gaining Ratio of A & C is = New Ratio - Old Ratio
A's gaining ratio = 5/8 - 4/9 = (45-32)/72 = 13/72
C's Gaining ratio = 3/8-2/9 = (27-16)/72 = 11/72
i.e 13:11
So option 'a' is correct answer
Now we moveing on Second Problem
When B retire, he also get his part of goodwill i.e 10800*3/9 = Rs. 3600
Now A & C sacrifices for Rs. 3600 in gaining Ratio 13:11
So A sacrifice for Rs. 3600*13/24=Rs. 1950
and C sacrifice for Rs. 3600*11/24 =Rs. 1650
So option 'd' is correct answer
B.N.Mishra
(Chartered Accountants)
(63 Points)
Replied 02 March 2009
Mr. Bhoop has the correct approach
LIVE Course on Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA)(with recording)
CAclubindia
