Hi Sameer,

I suggest you to go for the full group , even I was in the same dilemma in the previous attempt, but I prepared for the complete group and cleared it. plz prepare for it, you can do it......

dude.\

beleive me..i prepared only 3 months for 8 papers and i cleared..you can do it boss...rememeber dont waste an attempt appearing only for two papers

for DT go with banger sir

go for all subject

Hi Samir

Go for all the papers.. never think of any option of writing one or 2 papers..

Still u have one and half months time...

All the best.. u can do it

U CAN PREPARE FOR FULL GROUP.

PLAN FOR PREPARATION:

ISCA 7 DAYS

DT  10 DAYS

IDT 7 DAYS

COSTING 7 DAYS  

TOTAL:    31 DAYS

U CAN USE REMAINING DAYS FOR REVISON AND THIS TIME IS SUFFICIENT FOR YOU TO CLEAR THE FULL GROUP

I WISH YOU ALL THE BEST FOR OUR SUCCESS

why are you scared.  Go on full group

go for whole group bcz to take exemption in any subject is not so easy ,i have seen many cases who try to get exemption in idt only which is very easy compared to all others bt no one is yet seen to get ............

is manoharan a really bad bk for dt?

It would not be appropriate to rate any book good or bad. Everyone has a different style of learning, understanding and analysing the concepts and on the basis of that, the book is decided. If one is able to understand from a particular book and is confident, he/she must carry on from the same book, regardless of the public opinion about that book. What is important is understanding the concepts, the provisions of the law and every book does the same job. Speaking of Manoharan, no comments on that as I have not seen the book as VK Singhania has kept me busy.

thanks neeraj.....................i thought i wasted my tym on a wrong bk...................bt nw i dont think so................i m wid ryt bk as long as i understand.thanks again

Originally posted by : CA finalist
	is manoharan a really bad bk for dt?

at CA FINAL level it is the potential of the student which matters not the book which he/she refers.

If u would see the first page of the book ..."Recommended by The Institute of chartered accountants of india".

TN manoharan is one of very best direct tax professors of INDIA and he is one of those three former presidents of ICAI who won the very prestegious PADMASREE AWARD.

Do you still think that he can write such a bad book which is not appropriate for CA FINAL level ?

@ suvajit sir :- thanks for ur reply,nw i m very much confident wid the bk................i did not say that the bk is bad but one of the members out here said that its not a gud bk and i hv already covered max. part of the bk and tym is very short so can not afford to change the bk and start afresh..............and i m doing self study so i thought if there is a suggestion from one of the seniors out here then i shud ponder over it.................but thanks u hv actly solved my confusion.i dont think i need to change the book.

Mr. Hari : i wud really appreciate if u cud gv some valuable suggestions for preperation for dt ,which can actually help.................

Originally posted by : Hari H
	Originally posted by : SUVAJIT SAHU at CA FINAL level it is the potential of the student which matters not the book which he/she refers. If it is so then why students dont refer Institutes Module ???? Dear dont play the verbal gymnastics and mislead others. If u would see the first page of the book ..."Recommended by The Institute of chartered accountants of india". This is the gratitude by the ICAI in return to his acceptance to become President of ICAI. TN manoharan is one of very best direct tax professors of INDIA and he is one of those three former presidents of ICAI who won the very prestegious PADMASREE AWARD. May be but that doesnot mean his book is best. Do you still think that he can write such a bad book which is not appropriate for CA FINAL level ? Yes. This book is not appropriate for those who aims to clear group II in first shot.

The student fraternity will really appreciate and would rather feel enlightened if you can come up with your in depth review and opinion about the books for CA FINAL Direct Taxes authored by VK Singhania, Vinod Gupta, Padhukas and of course the Institute's study module.

Seriously, its a humble request.