Ad Free CAclubindia and Daily Updates on your Mobile. Subscribe Now!

Please Express ur VIEWs Here

Narayan paudel (FINAL) (205 Points)

31 July 2009

Hello Friends,

I Feel Institute is Doing Injustice To Pcc Students by Implimenting 3 1/2 years articleship.. whereas for new ipcc and PE II is jus 3 years.. and they can write final exam in 2 1/2 yrs...

I Feel There is no need to form STUDY GROUP for Considering the REduction of articleship period for PCC student.. bcoz they 're only suffering 3 & 1/2 years period...

I Strongly feel that , it is really an INJUSTICE with PCC students.....

If ICAI DO not consider in reduction in articleship period then IT is purely known that ICAI Is Selfish and alwa consider only its members and not students...

PLEASE EXPRESS UR VIEWS, WE NEED TO TAKE THIS UP TO ICAI COMMITTEE ....

PLEASE THOSE WHO R NT PCC STUDENTS ALSOARE WELCOME TO EXPRESS UR VIEWS..

PLEASE HELP US

Reply
Follow
Share

16 Replies

Rahul Chobdar (Chartered Accountant (Financial Management)) (561 Points)
Replied 31 July 2009

What about the CPT (3 month) advantage, my Friend

& for IPCC only after u clear u r First Group u can start ur articleship,

So i think Life is Unfair !

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

(Guest)

Our Institute has always shown sick attitude towards students issues....what can we do now????maybe after qualifying, we can change the trend......as of now we have to take things as they come.This is not the first instance our inst has shown this type of attitude...so y to start the same story again

Narayan paudel (FINAL) (205 Points)
Replied 31 July 2009

Originally posted by :R.S.C.
"	What about the CPT (3 month) advantage, my Friend & for IPCC only after u clear u r First Group u can start ur articleship, So i think Life is Unfair !	"

Friend IPCC is far better thn PCC atleast u'll be matured enough to handle work in offices(after passin 1 grp) at d tim of joining but PCC student was lik PEON in office. ((bring tea, go for d xerox and more.)) we did articlesh at premature stage,,.. we suffered d mental torture in office wen dint know anythi in office.. u should consider urself lucky my dear...

shubham gangrade (C.A final) (33 Points)
Replied 31 July 2009

i heard tht Institute is taking action against this.

some students has send E-mail to President.

soon i think there will be an announcement regarding this.

lets hope for this.

Rahul Chobdar (Chartered Accountant (Financial Management)) (561 Points)
Replied 31 July 2009

I have no wrong intensions, i just wanted to highlight the positive side of doing articleship early.

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

BHATI HARISH KUMAR (practicing company secretary) (209 Points)
Replied 31 July 2009

my opinion if have to time write both groups other wise write only one group ,dont take risk

Jeeth Kochar (AUDIT EXECUTIVE) (92 Points)
Replied 01 August 2009

Dear friend what all i can say is this...... ICAI has got the symbol of "Eagle" but its members (course scheme makers and higher officials) has got the character of a mon(k)ey.

[Money can do anything it wants, monkeys can jump whereever it wants without considering others trouble & problems].

{These sentences are not to hurt anyone but to make realise everyone that students are at the hights of trouble and disappointed due to the frequent changes of schemes}

aditi daga (management trainee) (272 Points)
Replied 01 August 2009

I REALLY FEEL ASHAMED OF WAT U THINK ABT UR INSTITUTE.......U SHUD BE PROUD DAT U ARE A PART OF SUCH A REPUTED INSTITUTION........ ONCE U PASS OUT THEN U WILL REALIZE ITS VALUE.

PLZ STOP USING THESE KIND OF LANGUAGES:

Dear friend what all i can say is this...... ICAI has got the symbol of "Eagle" but its members (course scheme makers and higher officials) has got the character of a mon(k)ey.

IT is purely known that ICAI Is Selfish and alwa consider only its members and not students...

CA Dhiraj Ramchandani (CA, M. com) (10823 Points)
Replied 01 August 2009

Originally posted by :R.S.C.
"	I have no wrong intensions, i just wanted to highlight the positive side of doing articleship early.	"

I do understand ur view...

But our articleship started on the completion of CPT itself,...., while the x-gen will njoy their 9 months of PCC studies first...

Do u think its so fair???? I kno, it'll b difficult for them too to cover all the syllabus in 9months,,, bt they dnt hav ny articlship, neither they r preparing two groups....

CA Dhiraj Ramchandani (CA, M. com) (10823 Points)
Replied 01 August 2009

Originally posted by :Narayan paudel
"	Originally posted by :R.S.C. " What about the CPT (3 month) advantage, my Friend & for IPCC only after u clear u r First Group u can start ur articleship, So i think Life is Unfair ! " Friend IPCC is far better thn PCC atleast u'll be matured enough to handle work in offices(after passin 1 grp) at d tim of joining but PCC student was lik PEON in office. ((bring tea, go for d xerox and more.)) we did articlesh at premature stage,,.. we suffered d mental torture in office wen dint know anythi in office.. u should consider urself lucky my dear...	"

hi narayan.. i do agree,,. v r not suppose to do this all in the office, rather no articles are expected or shd b forced to do sch things...

But, i do consider our batch to b best, as v cn get mor experience of articleship then our seniors and now also mor then our juniors...

No doubt, our articleship tenure is long then others,, bt then its worthless to regret now for the same... our global institute has many other works to do rather then paying attention to students' complaints....

But yes, its good that v can share our views in such posts and try to show are non-satisfaction.. great man..

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

yogesh sharma (student) (61 Points)
Replied 01 August 2009

Originally posted by :shubham gangrade
"	i heard tht Institute is taking action against this. some students has send E-mail to President. soon i think there will be an announcement regarding this. lets hope for this.	"

yes u r right look at my topic "Reduction in Period of articleship by 6 months for PCC students" I 've mailed 2 Mr. president & others n thy hv replied +vely hope further decision will be taken +ve

yogesh sharma (student) (61 Points)
Replied 01 August 2009

Originally posted by :Narayan paudel
"	Hello Friends, I Feel Institute is Doing Injustice To Pcc Students by Implimenting 3 1/2 years articleship.. whereas for new ipcc and PE II is jus 3 years.. and they can write final exam in 2 1/2 yrs... I Feel There is no need to form STUDY GROUP for Considering the REduction of articleship period for PCC student.. bcoz they 're only suffering 3 & 1/2 years period... I Strongly feel that , it is really an INJUSTICE with PCC students..... If ICAI DO not consider in reduction in articleship period then IT is purely known that ICAI Is Selfish and alwa consider only its members and not students... PLEASE EXPRESS UR VIEWS, WE NEED TO TAKE THIS UP TO ICAI COMMITTEE .... PLEASE THOSE WHO R NT PCC STUDENTS ALSOARE WELCOME TO EXPRESS UR VIEWS.. PLEASE HELP US	"

Hi Narayan got 2 d topic Reduction in Period of articleship by 6 months for PCC students

n U'll get ur ans.. bye frend....

vikram (student) (184 Points)
Replied 03 August 2009

friends please take a look over this case.

one of my friends is an article under a CA where the principal's son is also an article.his son went abroad for tour for 2 months.then he went for coaching in a metro city for nearly 6 months.but in his attendance sheet only 1 week leave has been put.whereas, one of the students went for coaching in the same metro city.now that particular student is undergoing the last year of articleship.but now the principal is insisting that the student has taken excess leave and should undergo supplementary articleship.the student asked for credit for extra time worked.the reply of the principal was that "we dont count such overtime in the case of students." please see friends.two students under the same principal has two type of rules.why coldnt ICAI take a look over theses kind of discriminations.the status of the son of the principal is that of a deemed dummy.why uttam prakash is not considering this.are the rules of ICAI regarding students not applicable to relatives of the members?