Hey
Two question In TAX paper June 09
totalling 6 marks which were out of Syllabus Since For PCC We dont hv Sec 142 and Sec 143 .................. Q1 D and Q5 D
Just would like to knw wht do we doooo.................................
12 Replies
CA Nitin Wadhwani
(Chartered Accountant)
(4469 Points)
Replied 14 June 2009
There were within the syallbus.
It was there in earlier RTP and they are practical oriented questions.
JASSPRIT S JOHAR
(Chartered Accountant)
(87 Points)
Replied 14 June 2009
| Originally posted by :Nitin | ||
| " | There were within the syallbus. It was there in earlier RTP and they are practical oriented questions. |
" |
Hi Nitin
full income tax and service tax is practical oriented , then full income tax act and full service tax should have been asked in the exam.
There is a syllabus to every exam held on the earth. In chapter 10 of the study material issued by ICAI we have section upto 140 and no discussion has been given for section 143. This section was in syllabus of PE-II but is not in PCC or IPCC. So definitely this is irresponsible act on the part of ICAI to ask these questions.
CA.PRAMOD KUMAR PANDA
(Chartered Accountants)
(204 Points)
Replied 14 June 2009
I agree to the opinion of CA.Johar. When students get questions out of the prescribed course in the Exam, they get confused and loss their balance and commits silly mistakes while attempting normal questions. The Institute should not play with the career of the students.
Sowmya.N
(article assistant)
(42 Points)
Replied 14 June 2009
me too... i agree to the above... will dey awrd marks fa dese!!! do any one knoe abt all this??
Ankur
(CA Final Student)
(999 Points)
Replied 14 June 2009
i may further add that the Fund-flow question in Costing paper was out of syllabus as AS-3 clearly mentions to make CFS.....
yasirma
(student)
(30 Points)
Replied 14 June 2009
ca is a professional exam not like degree exams so this leval questions are we will expect from institute
vinit
(Article)
(56 Points)
Replied 14 June 2009
Guys
I hv even checked the module and even Manoharan specifically states tht Sec142 and Sec 143 Relating to Assement Procedures are not in syallbus for PCC
So all i want is y dont we post a question to the Institue and wait for them to Reply us on it...............
Lets ccc wht they hv 2 say on it............
vinit
(Article)
(56 Points)
Replied 14 June 2009
Ankur
Would suggest you to please pick up a Costing Module and ccc Fundflow is there
and as far as Sec 142 and Sec 143 is no where related to PCC
and all i m concerned abt is if we dnt raise a nosie abt it now
and donot let the institue knw abt are concern ................................ it will only be a loss to us .....
So guys i think we should really get together post a question to Examination Committe and let them reply us on it wht do u guys think
vinayak
(article)
(22 Points)
Replied 15 June 2009
the Students are supposed to read RTP also. if it is covered in RTP there no point in objecting as the institute would not reply to us.
lucky
(none)
(108 Points)
Replied 16 June 2009
it was a practical questions........n the institute wants us to think like professional student..............
vinit
(Article)
(56 Points)
Replied 16 June 2009
| Originally posted by :Shubhangi Gaikwad | ||
| " | it was a practical questions........n the institute wants us to think like professional student.............. | " |
HEY
to Precise your syllabus says u need Working Knowledge for Income Tax and not Expert Knowledge as in Final
As Far as particual question is concerned then toh they can even ask Question on other Section Still u say u need Parctical Knowledge
In Taxation atleast if they as Question which are related to some Section from SYllabus we could hv said Parctical Knowledge
Pur this Sec is totally not there
Wht say ppl
Recent Topics
- Form 3CEAB
- Form 3CEAA and Form 3CEAB
- DIR 3 Web KYC
- Can i declare LTCG income as business income if I
- Stock entry in new software
- I have an EMI collection shop, what is its SAC cod
- Making payment once in quarter possible under QRMP
- Master File Documentation related
- Applicability of 44AD needs clarification
- ITC reversal in GST 3B
Related Threads
CAclubindia
