partners remuneration
Keval Mahendra Muni (28 Points)
11 June 2017
whether GST will be applicable on partners remuneration also. and ITC will be available on same?
10 Replies
CA Rashmi Gandhi
(Chartered Accountant)
(86323 Points)
Replied 11 June 2017
No GST appliacble on partner remuneration as same is in purview of Direct taxes.
Preeti (Team_GSTSoln)
(Team GST Experts)
(1926 Points)
Replied 11 June 2017
partners remuneration is employer employe relation, covered under negative list
nirmalbhai thakker
(117 Points)
Replied 11 June 2017
Preeti as per my view, u can not prove it as employer employee relation. Remuneration to partners is at present most burning issue,.
reason is as under
1 see definition of SERVICES SEC 2(102})
2 AS per this section , all other than goods - money and security is Services.
3 As per various judgement , payment of interest dividend loan borrowing and profit distribution among partners are supply of MONEY. SO interest and profit distribution will be out of the net of GST
BUT HOWEVER Remuneration given to partners are subject to GST
reason is as under
1 see definition of SERVICES SEC 2(102})
2 AS per this section , all other than goods - money and security is Services.
3 As per various judgement , payment of interest dividend loan borrowing and profit distribution among partners are supply of MONEY. SO interest and profit distribution will be out of the net of GST
BUT HOWEVER Remuneration given to partners are subject to GST
CA Rashmi Gandhi
(Chartered Accountant)
(86323 Points)
Replied 11 June 2017
Correcting myself
Partners are not employee of the partnership firm, so they supply services to their firm and in consideration get remuneration which is liable to #GSTsubject to threshold turnover of Rs. 20 Lakh (Special Category States Rs. 10 Lakh)
Partners are not employee of the partnership firm, so they supply services to their firm and in consideration get remuneration which is liable to #GSTsubject to threshold turnover of Rs. 20 Lakh (Special Category States Rs. 10 Lakh)
nirmalbhai thakker
(117 Points)
Replied 11 June 2017
one more issue every partnership firm is going to face is VALUATION OF TAXABLE SUPPLY IN CASE OF REMUNERATION.
AS THE SAME IS FALL under related party definition clause E regarding one of them directly or indirectly control others. it will creates many litigations in future.
Even if any one is not giving any remuneration to working partners in books, department will value the said services as per valuation rule no 5 and demand accordingly.
AS THE SAME IS FALL under related party definition clause E regarding one of them directly or indirectly control others. it will creates many litigations in future.
Even if any one is not giving any remuneration to working partners in books, department will value the said services as per valuation rule no 5 and demand accordingly.
nirmalbhai thakker
(117 Points)
Replied 11 June 2017
PL SEE ARTICLE POSTED BY AKSHAY KUMAR JAIN BEFORE 4 DAYS.
AN INITITATIVE TO CLEAR GST DOUBTS BY GOVT THROUGH TWETTER
SEE 03-06 TWETTER
GOVT AUTHORITY CLEAR CUT MENTIONED THAT REMUNERATION TO PARTNERA IS under GST
AN INITITATIVE TO CLEAR GST DOUBTS BY GOVT THROUGH TWETTER
SEE 03-06 TWETTER
GOVT AUTHORITY CLEAR CUT MENTIONED THAT REMUNERATION TO PARTNERA IS under GST
RAJA P M
("Do the Right Thing...!!!")
(128091 Points)
Replied 13 June 2017
| Originally posted by : nirmalbhai thakker | ||
 |
PL SEE ARTICLE POSTED BY AKSHAY KUMAR JAIN......... MENTIONED THAT REMUNERATION TO PARTNERA IS under GST........... |
 |
Yes, Nirmalbhai Thakker... I saw the Article.,
It's clearly noted that Q and A...
Thanks for the remaining
Recent Topics
- GST basics for a freelancer
- UNSECURED NCD BY NBFC
- Strict action against CAs and agencies who mislead
- Commission paid to non resident tds
- Foreign Asset - Holding and Income Reporting
- Equity Share Related Enquiry
- Not able to submit Trust accounts online on Charit
- Stock Group v. Stock category in Tally prime
- Settlement of PF Claims
- Bill TO SHIP TO INVOICE HSN
Related Threads
Trending Online Classes
-
Excel Mastery Program
CA Rishabh Pugalia
CAclubindia
