Guys I am new to accounts and trying my best to learn without any coaching. I came across the following problem in NCERT's 11th std textbook:
jrmchess (na) (197 Points)
12 September 2012Guys I am new to accounts and trying my best to learn without any coaching. I came across the following problem in NCERT's 11th std textbook:
Gunjan Tulsyan
(Article)
(222 Points)
Replied 12 September 2012
According to me the question u have put is incomplete
jrmchess
(na)
(197 Points)
Replied 12 September 2012
Originally posted by : Gunjan Tulsyan | ||
According to me the question u have put is incomplete |
No this is the complete question. You can check this yourself by downloading NCERT's 11th std accountancy textbook from the net. I think they have arrived at this answer by calculating profit on sale of machinery but I feel this is wrong.
Gaurav Joshi
(M.Com)
(44 Points)
Replied 19 September 2012
i think Mr. Gunjan is correct, this is not complete question or some misprinting is there..
Gunjan Tulsyan
(Article)
(222 Points)
Replied 21 September 2012
yaa whatever u concluded could also be rite since they have asked for the gain amount so it can be gain from sale of the machinery....but as per my conclusion if they are asking for gain from the entire transaction then the question is wrong...btw can u tell me what is the name of the chapter in whch the said question is asked..???
jrmchess
(na)
(197 Points)
Replied 21 September 2012
Originally posted by : Gunjan Tulsyan | ||
yaa whatever u concluded could also be rite since they have asked for the gain amount so it can be gain from sale of the machinery....but as per my conclusion if they are asking for gain from the entire transaction then the question is wrong...btw can u tell me what is the name of the chapter in whch the said question is asked..??? |
I have attached the file. Go to page 18.
Gunjan Tulsyan
(Article)
(222 Points)
Replied 22 September 2012
Yes brother i have gone through the attachment as per my reading its mentioned on the 16 page or so the definition of gain and as per tht it pertains to the sale of FA transaction thts mentioned in the question...and we said u tht the question was incomplete becoz u did not tell us tht the question has so many other sub questions and the next question to urs is the one whch we were previosuly trying to answer that is the loss he has made in the business....so hopefully u r doubt is resolved that the qstn u asked refers to the sale of the FA..so it is correct (45000-40000 = 5000) whch solves ur doubt...!!!
jrmchess
(na)
(197 Points)
Replied 24 September 2012
Originally posted by : Gunjan Tulsyan | ||
Yes brother i have gone through the attachment as per my reading its mentioned on the 16 page or so the definition of gain and as per tht it pertains to the sale of FA transaction thts mentioned in the question...and we said u tht the question was incomplete becoz u did not tell us tht the question has so many other sub questions and the next question to urs is the one whch we were previosuly trying to answer that is the loss he has made in the business....so hopefully u r doubt is resolved that the qstn u asked refers to the sale of the FA..so it is correct (45000-40000 = 5000) whch solves ur doubt...!!! |
Hi, thanks for following up. I am sorry I did not realize that the you were referring to the sub questions when u asked me to post the entire question. But I still did not understand how u came to know that they were referring to the sale on FA by reading the sub questions?
Gunjan Tulsyan
(Article)
(222 Points)
Replied 27 September 2012
See they have asked u the loss amount in the next question to the the one whch u have asked so it should click to u that they have asked for gain and its the only part in the question whch is showing gain whereas the entire business as a whole is showing a loss so they have asked for both the things in consecutive questions and also in the attachment refer the DEFINITON of "GAIN" there they have mentioned the sale of machinery as a transaction for gain...!!! as simple as that... hope finally u r satisfied...!!!