ICAI - Announcement | ||||||
|
||||||
|
CA VINAY BANSAL (In job with KPMG) (289 Points)
27 May 2008
ICAI - Announcement | ||||||
|
||||||
|
CA. Dashrath Maheshwari
(TaXpert)
(15103 Points)
Replied 27 May 2008
Its a step in the right direction...
Above Announcement is fantastic... We sud appreciate such a great steps taken by ICAI.. But did anyone complain ICAI tat how many hours do the article works in office? During September,October, March, April???
Maximun an article student takes class for 3 months or so.. tat too not daily but in alternative days.. and 100% coachin centre teaches only morning n evening... Bcoz even most of them teachin are practising CAs.. So Where is d question aries on attending class during office hours..??? maybe student'll be late for half an hour or so while comin to office from class.. but tats nt the issue.. CAs r compensating all those with makin to work for extra hours..
I am surprised tat no regulation and rules r made to principle but only to poor articles.. who has to attend office, classes, study and all..
Let me talk about dummy article.. iicai knows abt it, n still why it is silent????Why it is silent?????? Bcoz d giver of dummy article is icai's member.... Its so terrible tat aftr knowing also icai is putting oil in its ear.. If u realy want to make rules n regulation ,, make in such a way which can b in favour of both..
Who is there to hear article assistance(AA)?/?? Who's there to give justice for them?? No one is there,, .... No one is there...
An AA never complai anythin bcoz of fear f losing registration.. bcoz everybod knows justice 'll be in favour of principle..
Iam sorry to say all these things ,but i have no other choice,.. bcoz too much of anythi is good for nothin....
thanks
chaitanya
(Asst Manager finance)
(85 Points)
Replied 27 May 2008
hi sir,
I'm a CA final student registered in new syllabus.As per Institute regulations new syllabus students will get attempt only when they complete articles for period of 2 1/2 years. But now i'm hearing that there may be change in attempt and it may be as like in old scheme i.e., after completion of 2 years articles. Is there any fact in this statement?
Please provide the information for my query.............
Alex, you are right and I fully agree with what you say about regulations on AAs. One fails to understand why ICAI is so cruel on its students. Why so many curbs on the pretext of practical training ? Once a person registers for PCC does he have to become a slave ? With so many controls and regulations, the ICAI itself is forcing the students to tell lies and manipulate even before they became professional CAs. Should a CA aspirant work right from the beginging of his course without any theoritical knowledge ? Just like a scooter or car mechanic ? Why not the training part start after completion of PCC ? Why can't they do their regular B.Com. along with CA course ? Why not flexible hours for training ? I would like the Institute to answer these questions without getting offended. Because I am sure each and every student of CA course is going through this unnecessary tension and anxiety about his future.
krutika
(CA FINAL)
(49 Points)
Replied 02 June 2008
the new declaration made by the institute could be abetter one if it was with respect of proper timing. how can u expect a cpt passed student , who deals with other subject of PCC 4 the first time, can be properly trained by articleship. the coachings are just for 3-4 hours that to alternete days then how can a student spent 6 hrs in office .
the time limit must b reduced now since the student is ignorant about various matter.
but after he clears PCC and gainnig
some knowledge at the college can b asked to fix to articleship more stirctly.