Go AD-Free with CAclubindia Pro and get a FREE CCI Coffee Mug. Subscribe Now!

Munish bhandari

Sumitra Dudani (Student CA Final ) (34 Points)

05 March 2015

Hello, I will be appearing for CA final this may. I want to know if Munish Bhandari Sir's handbook contains case laws relevant for exam ? Since time is less I don't want to buy his textbook. I already know the provisions, just want the case studies asked in exams. Would handbook serve the purpose ?

Reply
Follow
Share

33 Replies

Kishor Bhat (CA final CS executive (from Bangalore)) (1881 Points)
Replied 05 March 2015

Handbook not worthy, it does not contain practical illustrations/ case laws. If u knw the provisions then refer pm new edition.

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Sumitra Dudani (Student CA Final ) (34 Points)
Replied 05 March 2015

Thank you for the much needed reply.

Vivek Venkataram (Just cleared CS(441/800) now C.A Final Attempt in May 2015) (772 Points)
Replied 05 March 2015

Actually i would beg to differ with this opinion. Munish bhandari handbook will help you a lot and i score 74 in november attempt in law only by using munish bhandari and practice manual for imp questions.. although i dint clear in all got exemptions in law and imdirect tax.. This is what i feel since u are not totaly a newbie and have idea already of the provisions. Also u can buy the latest edition on makemydelivery.com ...thanks

1 Like

Vivek Venkataram (Just cleared CS(441/800) now C.A Final Attempt in May 2015) (772 Points)
Replied 05 March 2015

There are certain topics where i agree the handbook is a little under wheling for those parts u can use the practice module..but for most off allied laws and some chapters of corporate law munish bhandari has topics that come as straightforward case study questions in the exams. ;)

Sumitra Dudani (Student CA Final ) (34 Points)
Replied 05 March 2015

Thanks everyone.. I'l buy the handbook and PM. Can any one pls tell the chapters which I must do from the PM after reading from the handbook..?

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Siddhant Singh (Student CA Final ) (62 Points)
Replied 05 March 2015

Do all the companies Act 2013 i.e acc audit dir meeting since the questions are new and the chances of the same questions being asked are also high.

Kishor Bhat (CA final CS executive (from Bangalore)) (1881 Points)
Replied 06 March 2015

Those case studies given in munish bhandari is nothing but past exam questions only which u guys can see that in icai practice manual. Moreover, in munish bhandari handbook and even in main book, many sentences/ provisions are wrongly given. If u want I will show many in new edition. I have compared all such wrong sentences with icai modules only and telling. However, now u don't have time so keep handbook n pm. Complete the pm. Concentrate the wordings used in pm rather than given in munish bhandari. In authors book, important sentences are missing which may fetch u more marks.

1 Like

Kishor Bhat (CA final CS executive (from Bangalore)) (1881 Points)
Replied 06 March 2015

For instance: Sec 127(dividend chapter), point 2 i, e exception...one point has been amended but the same sentence not updated in munish main book. Like this, be carefull while reading in handbook.

2 Like

Sumitra Dudani (Student CA Final ) (34 Points)
Replied 06 March 2015

Thanks Kishor... Could you pls let me know the other errors which I need to keep in mind while reading because I want to keep the handbook as my base for the preparation.

Rohit Kochar (article clerk) (34 Points)
Replied 06 March 2015

Hey this time handbook dont hav any practical qstns or caselaws...handbook is just for quick revision...so be careful

1 Like

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Kishor Bhat (CA final CS executive (from Bangalore)) (1881 Points)
Replied 06 March 2015

Ya I will Tel. Once u read in handbook, if u want to see any detail provisions then download icai modules. U get chapter wise. Its really gud. Especially, in between examples are given to understand the provisions. For the first time in icai life, icai study material is tooo good.

1 Like

Vivek Venkataram (Just cleared CS(441/800) now C.A Final Attempt in May 2015) (772 Points)
Replied 06 March 2015

Do it the other way round. keep pm as your base for case studies and exam oriented questions. And use munish bhandari for definitions and other points which u find difficult to understand. Indirectly i mean pm must be done fully and mb u can do also

1 Like