Ad Free CAclubindia and Daily Updates on your Mobile. Subscribe Now!

Ltcg wrongly shown as stcg in itr

Khushboo Somani (Business) (90 Points)

14 May 2013

One of our client has an asset purchased in 2005-06 and sold in A.Y. 2012-13 and thats why has LTCG but the same was shown as STCG in return (filled within the time limit). Due to which he receives a demand notice of Rs. 5500. Now please advice whether I revise the return or make a rectification application.

Reply
Follow
Share

5 Replies

ROSHAN BHARTIA (ACCOUNTANT AND CA ARTICLE) (2250 Points)
Replied 14 May 2013

U CANNOT REVISE THE RETURN BECAUSE UR RETURN IS PROCESSED UNDER SECTION 143(1)

NOW U HAVE TO FILE RECTIFICATION UNDER SECTION 154 (1)

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

ROSHAN BHARTIA (ACCOUNTANT AND CA ARTICLE) (2250 Points)
Replied 14 May 2013

FIRST U CONSULT THE CPC BANGLORE FOR UR DEMAND RAISED THEY TELL WHAT U HAVE TO DO

Khushboo Somani (Business) (90 Points)
Replied 15 May 2013

Its only an intimation and not the assessment order and I think we can revise the return.

ROSHAN BHARTIA (ACCOUNTANT AND CA ARTICLE) (2250 Points)
Replied 15 May 2013

HOW CAN U REVISE THE RETURN THE RETURN DATE IS OVER FOR 31/03/2012 ACCORDING TO ACT (INTIMATION MEANS YOUR RETURN IS PROCESSED BY THE INCOMETAX DEPT THEN AFTER THEY RAISE THE DEMAND OF RS 5500

U HAVE TO FILE RECTIFICATION 154

BY THE WAY ANY CURRENT YEAR IS NOT SO EASILY Assessed it takes some time

ROSHAN BHARTIA (ACCOUNTANT AND CA ARTICLE) (2250 Points)
Replied 15 May 2013

1- Revise tax returns within one year from the end of the assessment year or before theassessment. For the financial year 2010-11 one can filed the revised return up to march 2013.

2-You can’t refile your return if income tax department already did the assessment of your return.

3-If you missed any deduction or income in the return you can refile it.

4-If some information come to your knowledge after filing the return you can refile it.

5-The receipt no. & the acknowledgement no. is must for the refiling of the return.

6-Revision is allowed only if the omission was unintentional. The benefit of Section 139 (5) cannot be claimed by a person who has filed fraudulent returns. Section 139 (5) will apply only to cases of ‘omission or wrong statements’ and not to cases of ‘concealment or false statements’. Once you revise returns, the original stands withdrawn. If the omission(s) in the original return is intentional, the assessee will be penalised

7-No need to pay interest u/s 234A if any tax due, but you have to pay 234B, 234C interest if due

8- you can only revise the return if the original one was filed on time. Belated returns cannot be revised

9- You can file a revised return only in case of ‘omission or wrong statements’ and not for ‘concealment or false statements’

10- Returns can be revised when filed pursuant to notice under Section 148 as it is provided u/s 148 that for such return all the provisions of section 139 shall apply.

11- You will have to cough up 100 to 300 per cent of tax due as penalty for concealing income

12- If the returns are revised before the notice under Section 148 is issued, then there is no penalty.

13- If income was hidden in the original return and is revised and disclosed after the assessing officer pursued it, then a penalty is levied. If the revised return shows a higher income than originally declared, a penalty may or may not be levied.

14- Revised returns have a higher chance of landing a scrutiny letter from the I-T department.

15- To file revised returns, one can use both the online and physical methods. However, you can revise returns online only if you have filed the original returns online and have the 15-digitacknowledgement number. You cannot, otherwise, file returns online. The I-T department searches for the original details once the returns are revised. On not finding the original return, an error is shown. Therefore, it may be wise to revise in physical form.

16- If the taxpayer has revised return after the survey and it was has found that the mistake in the original return was not bonafide then levy of penalty is justified.

17- If some income was concealed in the original return and revised return disclosing such income is filed after the AO has unearthed such undisclosed income then penalty can be levied.

18- If the asseessee after the search filed the revised return declaring higher income than declared in original one, to buy peace of mind and to avoid litigation then penalty cannot be levied .

19- If the taxpayer has declared higher income in revised return of his own and there is nothing to prove that the taxpayer had concealed income malafidely then no penalty can be levied.

20- If the asseessee after the search filed the revised return declaring higher income than declared in original one, to buy peace of mind and to avoid litigation then penalty cannot be levied.